Click to enlarge

Captain John, leader of the Mono Lake Paiute, dressed in traditional Central California regalia. He was loved by his people and feared by his enemies. Besides being a chief and a warrior, he was also a medicine man who reportedly carried around a rattle snake. Whites once threatened to throw Captain John in prison after he told his young men not to fight in white man's wars during the WWI. Captain John died in 1924.

Tools

Yosemite Indians, where did they go?

by yosemitepaiutes (Subscribe)

Posted on: Oct 1, 2009 at 8:57 AM EDT

Channel: Lifeways

Location: Yosemite National Park, California, United States, Mariposa County

If you have been watching the series on PBS by Ken Burns called "The National Parks, Americas Best Idea" you will see Yosemite Valley featured several times. Yosemite was one of the first national parks created in the United States so everyone could share in its beauty, but have you ever wondered what happened to the original Indians of Yosemite?

Burns did mention in the first part of his film that the conflict between the gold miners and Yosemite Indians, the Ahwahneechees, was how Yosemite Valley was discovered. James Savage and the Mariposa Battalion stumbled upon Yosemite Valley when they were chasing Chief Tenaya and his band of Ahwahneechees, a tribe that was attacking gold miners as the miners were encroaching into their territory. The film only mentioned the point where Yosemite was first entered by the Mariposa Battalion.

But who were these Ahwahneechees and what happened to them after that? If you enter Yosemite National Park the crown jewel of the National Park system you will see signs and books displayed in their bookstore describing the original Native Americans as Southern Sierra Miwoks and that they never left Yosemite. Actually that is one of the biggest fabrications and injustices in the National Park system's history.

If you watched the Ken Burns' film you would have noticed that Dr. Lafayette Bunnell, who was part of the Mariposa Battalion, was with the expedition and described the beauty of Yosemite when the first European entered the Valley in his book "Discovery of the Yosemite and the Indian War of 1851 Which Led to That Event". Bunnell was the only person to describe the Yosemite Indians in detail. The Yosemite National Park also uses Bunnell to describe the first time a white man had stepped into Yosemite Valley.

So how did Bunnell describe the Yosemite Valley Indians? Bunnell wrote that Chief Tenaya spoke a Paiute jargon. He also wrote that Chief Tenaya was from Mono Lake, which is Paiute country and that the Mono Indians were proud of Tenaya and his war exploits. In one of the most telling passages Bunnell wrote that Chief Tenaya was the founder of the Paiute colony of Ahwahnee. In fact not once did Bunnell, the only man to meet and write about Tenaya and his band of Yosemite Indians, write that Tenaya and the Ahwahneechees were Miwoks, not once.

So why does Yosemite National Park and the Park system have signs in the park and sell books in their store saying that the original Indians of Yosemite were Southern Sierra Miwoks when in the first encounter Bunnell wrote they were Paiutes and Monos? That is a very good question.

The Southern Sierra Miwuks were not just any tribe, they were also mentioned in Bunnell's book. No they were not mentioned as part of the original Ahwahneechees, they were in fact the scouts for the white militia, the Mariposa Battalion. The white militia heaped praise on the leader of the Miwuks for assisting them in capturing Chief Tenaya and the Ahwahneechees. One of their important chiefs, Chief Bautista, even told the whites that he and his people were afraid to enter the Yosemite Valley. The name of the Valley, "Yosemite", was coined by the Southern Sierra Miwuk chief Bautista, which in their language means "They are Killers". Which would mean they are not the same people, but their enemies. So the original Yosemite Indians were not Miwoks as the Park system falsely claims but were the war like Paiutes from the eastern side of the Sierra Nevada.

So what happened to the fate of the original Yosemite Indians that the Ken Burns' film did not mention?

After being captured twice by the white militia, the Mariposa Battalion, led by Miwok scouts, Chief Tenaya escaped. He led his band of Ahwahneechees across the snow capped Sierra Nevada to hide out with his cousins the Mono Lake Paiutes. There the war like Mono Lake Paiutes gave Tenaya and his band a piece of land to live amongst them. Tenaya stay was short lived as he missed his Yosemite home. One evening when the Mono Lake Paiutes were off during horse raids on Spanish rancherias in San Bernardino some of Chief Tenaya's men stole their hosts horses and they fled back into the mountains. Upon their return from their raids the Mono Lake Paiutes were so incensed at how they were treated and the theft of their horses that they tracked Tenaya and his band back into the mountains. There they found Chief Tenaya and his band resting, bellies full of the stolen horse meat. The Mono Paiutes shots arrows at them until they were decimated. A handful of men escaped. The young chief of the Mono Paiutes found old Tenaya and with a big rock crushed his skull thus ending Tenaya's life. The remaining members of Tenaya's band were gathered up and taken back to Mono Lake were they were once again absorbed back into the Paiute community. Thus the bloodline of the Ahwahneechees, the original Yosemite Indians, runs in the veins of the Mono Lake Paiutes today.

Bunnell writes that the year after Chief Tenaya's death and destruction of his band that the only Indians the whites saw around Yosemite were Paiutes gathering acorns in the Valley.

So the next time you enter Yosemite and see all those signs with the Miwoks as the original Indian people of Yosemite, remember that they are not the original Indians of Yosemite. That is a myth. That is one of the major falsehoods still perpetrated by Yosemite National Park and the Park system. They were the scouts for the white militia and workers for the gold miners. The real Ahwahneechees are now in the Paiute people, who were warriors and tried to fight off the influx of gold miners.

That is what happened to the original Native people of Yosemite Valley.

I read that the Park Service lost their says ...

On Thursday, Oct 1 at 2:09 PM

Commenter

I read that the Park Service lost the Court case over the Merced River Act and now the Park Service must start all over again. Once again Millions wasted on incorrect bias studies which contradict history and common sense. Sheesh!

29975207
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Stalemate says ...

On Friday, Oct 2 at 2:29 PM

Commenter

The Miwoks may have been the original people of the Y area. This could have been previous to the 1800's when no written documentation was recorded as a result of "no white-man" there - oral history was passed to generations which "everyone" forgot.

30035454
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

reelndn says ...

On Friday, Oct 2 at 7:40 PM

Commenter

It does not surprise me that the Wasicu gets it wrong, again. Although I am enjoying the series, it also brings to mind that these were Native lands at one time, and what price we have paid to exist today. Yet Cal. Gov. just cut our health benefits.

30049674
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

To Stalemate says ...

On Saturday, Oct 3 at 1:51 AM

Commenter

Not everyone forgot. The Paiutes remembered. Even Southern Sierra Miwuks remembered. They remembered they were frightened to enter Yosemite Valley and called the Yosemite Indians "They are Killers".

30061014
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

To Stalemate says ...

On Saturday, Oct 3 at 1:54 AM

Commenter

The ones who forgot were those Indians calling themselves the American Indian Council of Mariposa. They forgot who they really were, and it was not Chief Tenaya's band, but Chowcitty's and Bautista's people. That is who they are.

30061082
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

To Stalemate says ...

On Saturday, Oct 3 at 2:00 AM

Commenter

The Southern Sierra Miwuk's ancestors remembered who they were. Their ancestors talked about their old ancestors; Cypriano, Bautista, and Cowchitty (Capt. Lewis). They honor them today. The men who helped the white man. Now they want to steal Tenaya

30061187
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

To Stalemate says ...

On Saturday, Oct 3 at 2:02 AM

Commenter

...they want to steal Tenaya and the name of the Ahwahneechees, who were their ancestors ENEMIES, and claim THEY are the original Indians of Yosemite, when they were the scouts for the white militia.

30061222
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

GP says ...

On Monday, Oct 5 at 2:13 AM

Commenter

What strikes me most about this series is watching the "white people" come to know what the "Indians" have known all along. Regardless of tribal membership. Can't we all just get along?

30127234
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Stalemate says ...

On Monday, Oct 5 at 7:48 PM

Commenter

Sooooo, who was there at Y before the 1800's? Before the whiteman knew of Y?

30165582
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

White people say says ...

On Tuesday, Oct 6 at 2:23 PM

Commenter

"Regardless of tribal membership. Can't we all just get along?" My answer would be people do get along, its the National Park Service now has changed the history of the Park and this should be of the public's interest. The Park Service is in error.

30208147
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Read the Fitzwater Report says ...

On Tuesday, Oct 6 at 2:28 PM

Commenter

"Sooooo, who was there at Y before the 1800's?" read up on the artifacts found below the 1962 Fitzwater sewer plant excavation. All the material comes from Paiute Lands such as Obsidian from Mono Lake, and Owens Valley Brownware. Ask about the bones?

30208439
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Stalemate says ...

On Tuesday, Oct 6 at 3:29 PM

Commenter

Ridiculous, Obsidian and Brownware are common the the Great Basin Indians, Washoe, Paiute and Shoshone. What makes it specific to Mono and Owens????? The bone analysis could also originate from any of the three tribes also.

30211909
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

To Stalemate says ...

On Tuesday, Oct 6 at 8:28 PM

Commenter

Scientists have tested the Obsidian is traced directly related to the Mono Lake basin and the brownware is traced back to Owen's Valley. Red Orce comes from Nevada. DUH. Plus the pictrographs located in the Park are Great Basin culture not Miwok.

30224829
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

I thought you told them the Miwoks says ...

On Wednesday, Oct 7 at 3:16 AM

Commenter

Thought you told them the Miwoks were were the scouts for the Mariposa Battalion and were afraid to enter Yosemite Valley since they called the indians of the valley "the Killers." Now how could the Miwoks be the Yosemite Indians if they were afraid.

30234059
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Secretary of Interior Ken Salazar says ...

On Saturday, Oct 10 at 12:59 AM

Commenter

The Secretary of Interior Ken Salazar and National Park Service Director Jon Jarvis plan to visit Yosemite National Park and learn about its innovative interpretive program.

30383547
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tracy Spencer says ...

On Tuesday, Oct 13 at 3:56 PM

Commenter

One of the tactics of the American government is to lead people to conclusions...even historical information that has been whitewashed to pretend Indians had no part in the establishment of non-indigenous folks "new land." Today, it is called stealin

30521381
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tracy Spencer says ...

On Tuesday, Oct 13 at 3:58 PM

Commenter

stealing when somebody encrouches on lands that other people use/own. Back in the day, it was progress and only the Indians were known to steal! English words can boggle almost any story and those who believe they are academically accomplished...

30521473
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous says ...

On Tuesday, Oct 13 at 4:01 PM

Commenter

are those who twist history. It's like propaganda...knowing others will read and be ignorant to any other version of the story. Sadly but truly, we Natives are a blessed people when we maintain our spirits as strongly as our ancestors!!

30521623
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Yokuts/Monos/Miwoks/White Blend says ...

On Wednesday, Oct 14 at 1:33 PM

Commenter

Yokuts/Monos/Miwoks/White Blend now claim to be one distinct Tribe, no I don't buy their history. However it appears the Park Service uses certain Indians to OK development projects. Pity the Park lost the Federal Lawsuit! Pity the Myth. lol

30567108
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

pkrnger says ...

On Friday, Nov 13 at 10:11 AM

Commenter

What has been the outcome of the meetings that the National Park Service has held with local tribal stakeholders and historians on this issue?

32051734
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

To pkranger says ...

On Sunday, Nov 29 at 11:06 AM

Commenter

Some Park pple gathered information...which our elders had MOUNTAINS of evidence and they will write a report. Hopefully they will fix THE BIG LIE.

32803184
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

pkrnger says ...

On Wednesday, Dec 9 at 2:51 PM

Commenter

I feel very confident that the weight of the evidence will win the day and the National Park Service historic record set straight at Yosemite. Thank you for persistence and accuracy of reporting.

33381699
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 250 Characters Left

Indian Country Today and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.