Tools

Elder abuse in not traditional

by wpmahkee (Subscribe)

Posted on: Mar 13, 2009 at 10:22 AM EDT

Channel: iTell

Location: Flagstaff, Arizona

I read in the news just a couple of days ago — on my mother’s 70th birthday, coincidentally — about a 50-something year old Navajo man who beat up his 90-year old elderly father in a drunken fit of anger, threw him out of their vehicle and basically left him to fend for himself alongside a fairly busy stretch of Interstate 17 near Munds Park.
My reaction to this was nothing short of sheer disbelief — that someone would actually commit such a despicable act against an elder, let alone their own parent! What compounds the situation even more was that this elder couldn’t even get around without the assistance of a walker and is reportedly a decorated military veteran on top of that.
The fact that alcohol was involved is disappointing enough. Unfortunately, however, alcoholism is an all-too-common way of life for a lot of people on the rez. Being from around the Gallup, New Mexico area — which at one time was iniquitously labeled “Drunk City” — I have seen elders abused in many different ways, whether overtly or subtly. The abuse isn’t always physical, but it is abuse nonetheless.
Elder abuse is typically defined as any action (or lack of action) by a person in a relationship of trust (usually a family member), which results in physical and/or psychological harm to an older individual. While the elder in the aforementioned situation wasn’t badly harmed or injured physically (thankfully), the fact that he was left alongside a busy highway by his own son will most likely leave irreparable emotional/psychological scars.
Throughout my entire childhood, I was always taught to respect my elders because elders were the wisdom and tradition bearers of our people. No matter what tribe you’re from, our elders deserve respect because they possess the collective knowledge about all of our traditional ways, our languages, our cultural and religious observances, our heritage and most importantly, our collective histories. I firmly believe that without knowledge of and respect for our past, we cannot possibly pave the way towards our future.
Nowhere is this more evident than in Native American culture. For one thing, it’s rare to see Native American elderly in a managed care facility or “old folks home.” Why? Because that’s just not the Native American way! Often times, our elders remain at home with the family where they are most comfortable, and where they are free to pass their knowledge on to the next generation. In my case, I was fortunate enough to spend much of my childhood with my grandparents because that’s where I was able to learn how to speak my Native Zuni language.
As precursors to the next generation of Native Americans, it is up to us to properly acknowledge those who came before us, as they paid homage to those who came before them. If we don’t, then how can we expect our grandchildren, great-grandchildren and their children to respect who we are today? If we, as the children of today, get ourselves caught up in the mix of alcoholism and elder abuse, then all we are doing is opening the door to where we will eventually be the ones getting abused by our children and grandchildren. And we may be the next one to be left out on a busy stretch of highway to fend for ourselves … or worse!
Long story short, elder abuse is not a part of our traditional ways. So let’s learn to better respect our elders for who they are today because no matter what background or situation you come from, abuse hurts at any age.

quiet-thunder says ...

On Friday, Mar 13 at 2:03 PM

Commenter

IAbuse comes in many ways, verbal abuse are words that can never be taken back. The hurt and emotions will always be there.Why can't we all except being an American Indian one tribe to another tribe. Are we not brothers and sisters?

17983636
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Virginia says ...

On Saturday, Mar 14 at 4:17 PM

Commenter

This is too sad. In the US it's the middle to upper class white that are responsible for the majority of Elder Abuse. I've been using Native Americans as an ex of 1%. Asimulation- sad because of social status-you forget you're better than us.

18038212
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

ndn angel says ...

On Monday, Mar 16 at 1:54 PM

Commenter

Elder abuse comes in many forms. I work for an elder's program, i see it as abandoment;this 50 yr old leaving his father alone on that road. there's no excuse for such an act drunk or sober. we need to be relearned again how to respect our elders.

18102462
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Phoenix Navajo says ...

On Monday, Mar 16 at 2:06 PM

Commenter

The cycle of abuse is in all cultures. In some way the author hints at, it may have been coming to the elder left by the highway, because he may have practiced abuse on his children and so forth. Be responsible and learn to heal and break the cycle!

18103257
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Phoenix NDN says ...

On Monday, Mar 16 at 6:26 PM

Commenter

Send this article to Russel Means of AIM. Still fighting jurisdiction issues and not the facts that he abused an elder. But still fighting some other pysch war somewhere.

18118182
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Kuruatutu says ...

On Monday, Mar 16 at 9:36 PM

Commenter

I am an elder abuse prevention expert and the granddaughter of a Maori elder, I am witness to this horrific epidemic that is exploding across nations, classes and cultures. Dare to stand up for the elders - no excuse for elder abuse in any form!

18125582
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Montana Sioux says ...

On Tuesday, Mar 17 at 9:27 PM

Commenter

Our society doesn"t Promote kindness but a what can you do for me attitude.If you can"t or won"t help financially elders are no longer needed.Saddly,respect is a thing of the past,because it doesn"t buy any thing.

18179897
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

joddie says says ...

On Thursday, Mar 19 at 2:08 PM

Commenter

The elders today are a far cry from the elders of the past, I see elders today that want to control their family members with their money, land, wills (written and unwritten)...as they see l themselves losing control of life...

18268772
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Shocked Native says ...

On Thursday, Mar 19 at 7:48 PM

Commenter

The article unfortunately made it on the Navajo Times "Police Blotter" section. I was utterly shocked myself to read such an inhumane act. Our Elders should be treated with the utmost respect, as our lineage stems from them.

18287532
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wanbli says ...

On Friday, Mar 20 at 8:58 AM

Commenter

When you as Indigenous nations and spiritual and political leaders serve your oppressor are attacted to his imperial colonized ideologies and myths, his rewards, his image of manhood and womenhood then abuse has become the very theme of traditions.

18303741
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

orrin.allen@nezpercesystems.com says ...

On Monday, Mar 23 at 11:05 AM

Commenter

nothing new? when your off spring wants money for a wild week end and the younger one's not working, guess who gets knocked around and the family car gets used for the wild weekend. The law and order says they must have someone who saw it happen.

18411477
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

WAMP1 says ...

On Tuesday, Mar 24 at 1:25 PM

Commenter

ELDER ABUSE IS SOMETHING THAT SHOULD NEVER HAPPEN TO NATIVE AMERICANS BECAUSE WE HAVE STONG BELIEFS ABOUT TAKING CARE OF OUR ELDERS AND RESPECTING AND LEARNING ALL WE CAN FROM THEM THEY ARE TRULY OUR FUTURE WE NEED TO LISTEN AND LEARN OPEN YOUR EYE

18471472
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

CrowGoodMedicine says ...

On Wednesday, Mar 25 at 9:33 PM

Commenter

elder abuse in not triditional, ICT mean is not traditional?

18555462
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Celeste Strikes With A Gun says ...

On Thursday, Mar 26 at 2:53 PM

Commenter

There was full family support when my father's mother needed it in the 60's. When my parents needed palliative care, 10 and 15 yrs ago, I took care of them with very little support because they were kind and good to me. Children need respect from us.

18598287
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

nobozo says ...

On Thursday, Mar 26 at 3:54 PM

Commenter

Elder abuse is so commonplace among all communities, Indian and non-Indian. A big problem is lack of facilities to care for the very specific needs of a geriatric population. Not the concern of my tribe's council. So much for "respecting" elder$.

18602612
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Night Sky Watcher says ...

On Friday, Apr 3 at 1:24 PM

Commenter

Our Elders, as like our children, are our hope for future generations. Our Elders tell the young ones of our ways and the young ones (hopefully) will learn to respect and carry on. Our Elders should be held is especially high esteem. NightSkyWatche

19073497
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Kenneth says ...

On Monday, Apr 6 at 12:35 PM

Commenter

I see the same problems in my country. How do we want things to be when we get old? To learn from someone with a long experience is important, that`s how I got through the hard times in my life. Find what was lost in the past, that might be the key

19177716
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Kevin says ...

On Thursday, Apr 9 at 12:03 PM

Commenter

Not much else can be expected from cultures that put more value on material goods than human beings. A new car means more than Grandma - it is that sick and simple. My guess is per capita there is much less abuse of elders amongst Indians.

19345111
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

WAMP1 says ...

On Tuesday, Apr 14 at 1:51 PM

Commenter

elders never get abused here verbal or other wise its just not the way we were brought up elders are like gold to be cherished and idolized to learn and to listen to their wisdom

19569362
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Lee Max says ...

On Friday, Apr 17 at 2:03 PM

Commenter

I have a policy that Elders should not abuse. Moreover every one is going to come to that stage one day. How do they feel if they are in that stage is my point.

19787437
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wrangler says ...

On Friday, Apr 17 at 2:15 PM

Commenter

Please do not abuse elders. They are one among us. Automated Forex Grail

19788182
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Alan says ...

On Friday, May 8 at 2:40 PM

Commenter

Its a sign of the times this like that would never have happened a few generations ago, or even 1 generation ago. I dread to think what its gona be like in 100 years time.

21145702
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 250 Characters Left

Indian Country Today and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.