Story Published:
Jan 13, 2010
Story Updated:
Jan 14, 2010
WASHINGTON – Instead of apologizing without condition for using a racist term, the top GOP leader parsed his own words, while calling on another politician to step down for using racially offensive words.
Republican National Committee Chairman Michael Steele encountered criticism after his Jan. 4 appearance on the Sean Hannity Fox News program for using the phrase “honest injun” to punctuate a point he was making about conservative ideals.
Several Native American leaders, including the Native American Journalists Association and congressional advocates, noted that the term is racist, and said Steele should apologize.
But Steele did not do so in the immediate days after the program aired, and calls to the Republican National Committee for comment went unreturned on the matter.
Then, later that same week, word came by way of a new political book that Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., had said during the 2008 presidential campaign that now-President Barack Obama had a good chance at winning the election since he is “light-skinned” and has “no Negro dialect.”
Almost immediately, Steele called on Reid to step down from his Senate leadership post because the words are racist.
Reid instead apologized and several top Democrats, including Obama himself, came to his defense, saying he has a strong record on race issues.
It was during another Fox News appearance, this time on Jan. 10, where Steele was confronted with his apparent hypocrisy.
After covering Steele’s distaste for Reid’s remark, host Chris Wallace asked the top GOP politico about his own “honest injun” remark, noting that congressmen from both parties said that it is a racial slur. Dictionaries agree, noting that the phrase is considered impolite and politically incorrect because “injun” is a slang term for American Indians.
“Well, if it is, I apologize for it,” Steele responded on the show. “It’s not an intent to be a racial slur. I wasn’t intending to say a racial slur at all.
“The reality of it is that’s not the same as what we were talking about before. That’s not saying I’m some loose cannon and wild, you know, dog out here running around not being able to be controlled.”
Steele’s conditional take on the phrase has outraged some Native Americans, as they say he is qualifying his own racism, while hypocritically calling for the resignation of a person who has said he was wrong – and apologized unconditionally – for using a racist term.
“It is astounding that his mind can separate himself from Sen. Reid when it comes to deciphering racist remarks,” said Ronnie Washines, president of the Native American Journalists Association.
“How can Steele let others decide if his words were racist – and then surmise that if others think so, then he would apologize?” asked the Yakama Nation citizen.
“All that I have heard or read coming out of his mouth since does not resemble anything close to an apology.”
Nick Reo, director of the Native American Institute at Michigan State University, said Steele was being hypocritical, and that the statements by Reid and Steele are problematic in similar ways.
“They both used disrespectful and disparaging language,” said the citizen of the Sault Ste. Marie Tribe of Chippewa Indians.
“Each has claimed that they didn’t intend their comments to be hurtful, and I believe them both.”
He doesn’t think either Steele or Reid should lose their jobs over their comments.
But Jeff Harjo, director of NAJA and a citizen of the Seminole Nation of Oklahoma, believes Steele should indeed be punished for his hypocrisy.
“From reading parts of the [Jan. 10] transcript, it seems that Mr. Steele is never wrong, he is arrogant and I would think the Republican Party needs to ask him to step down.”
The Steele scenario has called increased attention to the complexities of racial language in America – and the sometimes divergent ways people think about Native Americans and racism, compared to African Americans and racism.
Michelle Bernard, a political commentator for MSNBC, hit that point home when discussing Reid’s words on-air Jan. 11.
Bernard, an African American, discussed the Reid situation, saying she didn’t think the words he used were completely “off the reservation.”
Ironically, many Native Americans have a problem with the “off the reservation” phrase, saying it’s disparaging and infers that Indians should be kept in line.
No MSNBC hosts called Bernard on the irony.
Calls to the RNC to ask Steele to clarify the continuing controversy have gone unreturned.
Wednesday, Feb 10 at 1:08 PM Red Bear wrote ...
Senator Daniel Inouye should run for President hes more Native. that would be a Blessing to all Native People. this country is run by the ink and paper. Black/White. After Mr michael Moores comment i dont Trust the Black people.... We certainly dont come from Africa
37368334Monday, Feb 8 at 2:30 PM Not sure wrote ...
But is I think it is the ebonics dictionary.
37223274Monday, Feb 8 at 2:28 PM Just wondering wrote ...
Maybe the eubonics dictionary has led Mr. Steele astray.
37223122Saturday, Jan 30 at 3:45 PM Lauren Unruh wrote ...
I think some Indians should ask Sarah just what she meant by that. This is from her website, SarahPAC P.O. Box 7711 Arlington, VA 22207 (202) 747-1812 Email: info@sarahpac.com
36684392Tuesday, Jan 26 at 2:52 PM Anonymous wrote ...
"injun" by itself is racist and inaccurate and just plain ignorant usage of the English language. the phrase was used as a contrast against all the "dishonest injuns" of which the majority of indigenous people were according to the lily white and pure settlers. HONEST INJUN - "from Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn, has been traced back to 1851, but it is probably much older than that. Originally it was probably an expression of sarcastic derision - 'as honest as an Indian.'
36399062Tuesday, Jan 26 at 2:14 PM resis_tanz68 wrote ...
Kwe! Kwe! Since there is much hypocrisy in both the left and right wings of America's political system, why do we have to still support them? Over 2 million independent Native voters can "move political mountains!" We live in a time and place of socio-political hypocrisy and spiritual apostasy. This may not indicate the end of this world, but really can see it from here! Look out 2012! Danitoh. akwe:kon.
36395577Tuesday, Jan 26 at 1:15 AM NDN Mike wrote ...
This situation is so obvious; isn't this the classic case of "the pot calling the kettle black?"
36364707Monday, Jan 25 at 4:22 PM Green Eyes Walking wrote ...
Those that love this Country should go see the Broadway Play "Nanye'hi" then they too will realize that it wasn't Paul Revere that saved the colonists from the British.It was two young men Who were Tsalagi--Moytoy X11
36336594Monday, Jan 25 at 3:05 PM Circular 1665 wrote ...
It’s my experience that the world in not politically correct. There will always be stereotypes and racial undertones. Everyone is racist to some degree and I don’t feel that is the biggest problem we have. The biggest problem is that people do not respect Indians/Indian Nations for what they are. They are separate cultures and sovereign nations. We do not have the things we have because we are a different race; we have them because we are a different nation.
36330909Monday, Jan 25 at 12:22 PM beswishes wrote ...
We are all the same, but different. Yet, we'd do well to clean up our language.
36318149Monday, Jan 25 at 3:36 AM Hoka hey wrote ...
Certainly he didn't mean to make a racist remark. He's just self righteous and ignorant. Perhaps a little pale complected himself.
36293339Saturday, Jan 23 at 8:24 PM jake sundown wrote ...
i am a native american and i think anyone in politics should think before they speak.
36221594Saturday, Jan 23 at 3:20 PM Yee Haw wrote ...
Cindi has possible cause for a law suit. I don't believe they want "Indians" on Alcatraz Island either.
36206642Saturday, Jan 23 at 1:33 PM Cindi Alvitre wrote ...
Bottom line...There seems to be a double standard when it comes to Native Americans. I was recently denied a job simply because the Catalina Island Conservancy doesn't want us on the island (our traditional landbase). That is racism and discrimination, yet people are playing it down. If the director and her staff had made similar degrading statements about blacks or jews, they would have their heads! Reid's remarks were racist...
36201774Saturday, Jan 23 at 3:23 AM "Help here..?" wrote ...
Where are the "Rev's" Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson when there is a legitimate case of racism? Consulting with the "Rev." Chivington? Onward, Christian Soldiers?
36182132Friday, Jan 22 at 3:40 PM Ruby E. Russell wrote ...
People in high office's should know better. It appears that the more educated a person is, the chances he will say something racist and we put up with it because we don't want to make waves. Especially the Native people. We were taught that from way back when we were not allowed to speak in our own language. Shame on this people who should know better or just don't care believe it or not.
36149252Friday, Jan 22 at 11:38 AM edwin wrote ...
what is up hommie
36130404Friday, Jan 22 at 11:36 AM edwin wrote ...
i just wanted to say hi
36130199Friday, Jan 22 at 11:34 AM anna wrote ...
hi
36130104Friday, Jan 22 at 2:56 AM Calvin L. Wooten Dba "Geronimo" wrote ...
Date: 01/21/2010 From: http://www.indiancommerceclause.bis To: American citizens/Business Owners and Tribal Officials and citizens of 564 American Indian and Alaska Native Tribal Governments. Reference: Article 1-LEGISLATIVE DEPARTMENT, Section 8-POWERS OF CONGRESS, Clause 3-REGULATE COMMERCE OF THE FEDERAL COMMERCE CLAUSE (CC)/INDIAN COMMERCE CLAUSE (ICC) provision Constitution of the United States.
36109837Thursday, Jan 21 at 6:42 PM i_sculptor wrote ...
The U.S and the world is infested with hate and racism. Indifference, greed, and jealousy the components even among us natives. The RNC is dressed it it and even the black and brown haters are with them. Now they have altered health care with lies. 2012 really needs to happen now!
36089304Thursday, Jan 21 at 4:15 PM VGHS wrote ...
messed up
36079244Thursday, Jan 21 at 3:45 PM Daisy wrote ...
Wow, Triniti...how open minded. This is what frustrates me about the left. They assume that all blacks, Natives, Asians, etc should vote for Democrats "because they care." Bull! THey want the votes by keeping people down & thinking they need the govt in order to live.
36076797Thursday, Jan 21 at 12:30 PM Yonv wrote ...
Every individual on the face of our Good Mother is a bigot in one fashion or another, regret - no exceptions. Many of the comments posted reflect such, even the article. Little children on the playground. Thank you.
36062042Wednesday, Jan 20 at 1:13 PM HH Higgins wrote ...
I am a Marylander (home state of Michael Steele). Sadly I must tell you the man is touched.
35994479Wednesday, Jan 20 at 5:20 AM fed up wrote ...
Reid, Steele, both of them should watch "Soldier Blue." Whose country is it anyway? The barbaric, bloodthirsty christians? The African imports? Who imported the African? And for what purpose? Whose country is this?
35968864Tuesday, Jan 19 at 9:50 PM Triniti Braided Blood wrote ...
Okay...I'm half black, and any black person with an ounce of sense will tell you that we don't acknowledge Michael Steele any more than we do Clarence Thomas.
35953014Tuesday, Jan 19 at 5:05 PM acting wrote ...
ah yes one of my grad class mates once mentioned "don't even think about going into acting if you can't take rejection" I replied hey that's right up my alley, I'm ndn. so this just gives me more credibility AAAiiiee!!
35935604Tuesday, Jan 19 at 11:43 AM mix blood wrote ...
There is an old episode of Jerry Seinfeld show where Jerry has a Native girlfriend and during their courtship he begins to see all the negetive phrases pertaining to"Indians" that he had been using ---this shows how racism is EMBEDDED in American English language and that is the true danger.
35912259Monday, Jan 18 at 4:18 PM dmoccasin wrote ...
Living in occupied territory...Comments such as this should not be accepted or tolerated. The reality is that they don't know what is acceptable. Back to re-education is the task before all indigenous peoples.
35863059Monday, Jan 18 at 12:41 PM johnypaycut wrote ...
We borrowed our system of goverment from the iroquoi confederacy,made a mess of it. now we ask why? (we should have simply joined)
35848759Monday, Jan 18 at 2:46 AM Food4Thought wrote ...
http://www.topix.com/forum/city/farmington-nm/TRLT919Q7I7O84U78 Indian bashing is alive and well in New Mexico and across the country as well. If the political leaders do not respect Indians those who voted them in won't either. I have posted an address to one of the most racist forums I have ever read. The worst is 'No racism promblems? That's simply denial' although almost all the threads are unbelievably racist towards Indian people. Lets for once ban together and be of one voice.
35829737Sunday, Jan 17 at 4:24 AM Helene wrote ...
Always easier to point the finger at another than to face their own issues. Case in point: both Bernard & Steele slight indigenous peoples of this country. Hypocrisy is rampant; they are ALL thoughtless fools!
35782104Sunday, Jan 17 at 1:22 AM mahto wic'asa yata pi wrote ...
The fact that this issue isn't on the mainstream media calls to the forefront the true effects of genocide. The fact that this isn't being derided by the network talking heads illustrates how diminished the validity of our very existence as a people and culture is within the consciousnessand reality of the amerikkkan social order. They may not be hunting us down anymore, but the truth is most people aren't too concerned about a troublesome aside that stood in the path of progress, we're lucky.
35779204Saturday, Jan 16 at 11:40 PM Jim TH wrote ...
What else can you expect from a modern "Uncle Tom" whose appearance is comparable to an "Oreo" cookie? Self-mirrored Ignorance, is the key word here. Look into the mirror! What do you see?
35776554Saturday, Jan 16 at 4:15 PM Crystal Cole wrote ...
As long as there is life in us, we should all strive for a higher standard of behavior and appreciation for each others differences. Just as racism is vile, hypocrisy is vile and so is "sweeping things under the rug" in the name of moving on. Remember history lest we be doomed to repeat it.
35762797Saturday, Jan 16 at 3:31 PM Raven Skye WinterHawk wrote ...
You know, I find that people think that slang terms are OK to say about any culture. They think it is humorous and something that should be overlooked but they need to realize that to our people it is not funny when they speak of us using a term that was used by European invaders in an attempt to defile, humiliate and dishonor our ancestors and our culture as a whole..
35761302Saturday, Jan 16 at 12:25 PM Josie T Francis wrote ...
Here again , no matter of what party affilation, predijudical remarks without an appology reigns suppreme in the goverment "for all people. He of all should know better. Unless it is comming form discrimination based on wealth and greeed of power over others who hve less.
35754092Friday, Jan 15 at 2:23 PM hd pinkham wrote ...
The point of this is this is a man who represents "people, all people". He is part of a group of people who makes decisions on our behalf. What he thinks, how he thinks & how he feels or DOES not feel about the people he represents, his co-workers see this. If we allow him to degrade us, Native Americans, if we do not stand up for our selves, if we allow this unacceptable behavior - then we get what we deserve. Remember our ancestors died fighting for our rights....
35636289Friday, Jan 15 at 1:48 PM jay day wrote ...
I really think people need to grow up a little. First let me say that the guy is stupid for that and should just man up and apologize. But at the same, other people need to stop being so senitive about what people say. If someone says a bad word it's not the end of the world poeple are stupid we need to accept that and move on with our lives.
35633264Friday, Jan 15 at 12:19 PM stink bug wrote ...
do the republicans have a data dictionary that lists what is acceptable and not ok? especially to avoid offending people of any ethnicity? i hope someone sues the republicans for this.
35626592Friday, Jan 15 at 12:00 PM anonymous wrote ...
"Injun" is derogatory slang for an American Indian and has not been in use for decades, yet Republican National Chairman Michael Steele thinks it is socially acceptable to use the term.
35625022Thursday, Jan 14 at 6:12 PM IndigenoustoNA wrote ...
The Black community hates the words "sambo", "blackface", "negro", White community dislike "cracker", "milk", "honky" "white-trash", Jewish people dislike "jewed down". So why do people indigenous to the Native American continent get ignored for being "dissed" by an African American politician? The harassment laws are alive and well in the USA and the "Native Americans" are covered by them as well. If you are offended by something it is considered harassment, you have been violated.
35578882Thursday, Jan 14 at 5:13 PM Anonymous wrote ...
Sreele suffers from the same condition that Rush Limbaugh and Glenn Beck and Dick Cheney suffer from: * "Boca sensa patrona". It sounded so melodious when my mother would say it in Italian, (and I confess, sometimes she said it about ME when I was a kid). *Translated, it means "Mouth without an owner.". Mary ;)
35574412Thursday, Jan 14 at 4:43 PM Dakota woman wrote ...
To all ya, round-eyes , There's a big difference between being housed fed and breed. The true people were genocide.
35571994Thursday, Jan 14 at 4:31 PM saber tooth mountain man wrote ...
well to racist america. this makes it legitimate to say rascists slurs against all foreigns! Its unity time for indigena.
35571047Thursday, Jan 14 at 10:03 AM the big native wrote ...
this is getting ridiculous. this is obviously a liberal journalist trying to stir things up. If you want to see real mistreatment of natives go to any reservation and see how native american non-tribal members are treated(navajo working for oneida). unfair benefits, unfair hiring practices, etc.
35539277Thursday, Jan 14 at 9:23 AM to exasperated wrote ...
I think a case can be made that racism against Natives is much more accepted in American society at-large. Think national football teams called Redskins, think museum displays with Native bones, think of broken treaties.
35536424Thursday, Jan 14 at 4:46 AM Mike Putfus wrote ...
LOL I started using that term when I heard back in the 50's. Just like raising your right hand and saying "HOW". Just about everyone on the reservation would do it then say "Want me to show you", and start laughing.
35529522Thursday, Jan 14 at 1:26 AM caldun1983 wrote ...
If we forget that we are African-American or Native-American and so forth, then it will only help to create a more 'colorblind society'. It sounds like you have become attached to this ideal of forgetting our uniquenesses as black people, native people and so forth of America, but rather you would want us to strip ourselves of those unique qualities and become nationalistic "Americans"?for what reason? To empower our own communities, which have long suffered or to empower the "white dominance"?
35524139Thursday, Jan 14 at 12:44 AM blackwhitegreen wrote ...
Everyone "grow up" or did I just offend the youth. Time to stop refering to ourselves as type-American. We are all just Americans no hyphens. Once we realize that we can stop making every word offensive and move forward. People should be judged on who they are not their race or sex. Everything is just an adjective as thats how we describe people. Let us stop wasting time crying victim over being called names and accomplish something positive like helping one another and improving our community
35522469Wednesday, Jan 13 at 11:51 PM exasperated wrote ...
What "sometimes divergent ways people think about Native Americans and racism, compared to African Americans and racism?" So many times when Natives discuss anti-Indian racism they do so by pretending that anti-black racism is always recognized and condemned. Two people made racist statements about two different racial groups and both got to keep their jobs - blacks and Natives got treated the exact same way.
35519804Wednesday, Jan 13 at 11:12 PM Brad Fluetsch, Tlingit wrote ...
I think we need to think of the comment in terms of Washington D.C. home of the Redskins. I think it is time for us in Indian Country evaluate Indian Policy being legislated, implemented and evaluated in the home of the Redskins. Just makes you wonder if it has an impact on the thinking of Senators and Representatives as they consider Indian health, Safety, Sovereignty?
35517497Wednesday, Jan 13 at 9:07 PM Kathy L wrote ...
The way I was raised, the term "Honest Injun or Honest Indian" meant that you were telling the truth because Indians were honest and trustworthy. How did it ever get racist? Are we just nit-picking to find something offensive so we can spout off or are we just like little kids keeping score?
35510827Wednesday, Jan 13 at 8:11 PM hiatsistsalagi wrote ...
ya know what...racist is racist is racist...there aint any 'degrees' of it...however, in the 1970's i remember there were a whole bunch of names white folks were called also...still doesnt make it right
35507224Wednesday, Jan 13 at 5:44 PM paleo-con wrote ...
This was apparently contrived to show the hypocrisy of the left. But what a loser to use native Americans for this experiment. How about have some guts and make a tongue in cheek anti-semitic remark, then sit back and watch the hypocrisy fly.
35497109Wednesday, Jan 13 at 5:04 PM NRproducer wrote ...
"Off the Reservation" Finally! Palin and her staffers had used that quite regularly during her unsuccessful run for office. I emailed Palin staffers to explain what they meant, and do you think I received a response? I'm tired of fighting the fight anymore...let whomever say whatever.
35493847Add a comment
Most Popular