Tools

Obama to replace Hopi U.S. attorney

Administration wants one of its own to hold the position

By Rob Capriccioso

WASHINGTON – Diane J. Humetewa, the first female Native American U.S. attorney in history, will soon be out of a job – and not because she’s doing a bad job, either. Instead, she will become a casualty of the political appointee process that comes with each new presidential administration.

Humetewa took the oath of office to become a U.S. attorney from Arizona in December 2007 and was formally sworn in a month and a half later.

Indian country found big reason to celebrate.

Not only was the longtime tribal justice advocate breaking a glass ceiling, she was rising to the heights of a system that had recently experienced the controversial firings of several U.S. attorneys by the Bush administration and former Attorney General Alberto Gonzales.

Many of the fired U.S. attorneys happened to be strong in the area of tribal justice, so Humetewa was seen to be filling a big void – and she was doing so under the Bush administration, which wasn’t exactly known for going out of its way to promote Indian faces to positions of power.

Humetewa would ultimately oversee a plethora of tribal justice issues in her state, and she made it part of her agenda to highlight Native safety and justice concerns on the national level, too.

In an interview with Indian Country Today in June 2008, Humetewa noted that she had previously served as a tribal liaison under former U.S. Attorney Paul Charlton, and once she was promoted to the position herself, she joined the Native American Issues Subcommittee, made up of U.S. attorneys who have Indian country jurisdiction.

“Our responsibility is to inform the attorney general about our issues, and therefore he is apprised of them,” Humetewa explained.

“We suggest solutions, and we may come up with positions with respect to what we’re doing in our offices. We have great responsibility to take our grass-roots knowledge of our districts up to the attorney general level.”

She also felt it was crucial to communicate with tribal governments, so they could recognize, understand and be participants in the federal judicial system.

“It’s important to help the leaders of our tribal nations understand the reality that, today, this is their system, and they have to pay attention to it.

“We want them to be aware that a lot of the work in Arizona is being done at the grass-roots level of tribal law enforcement. And we always welcome their input.”

Humetewa admitted that her work – often centered on homicides, sexual assaults and other forms of battery – was often depressing, but she said she found the challenges of the job to be another avenue to connect with folks to try to turn the situation around, especially on reservations.

When asked how long she expected to hold the position, she said she tried not to spend too much time thinking about it, as the decision was outside of her control.

When the new presidential administration took office, it was in President Barack Obama’s control. And word soon came that Obama would ask Humetewa to step down.

Democrats who had ties to Obama’s campaign and transition team said in mid-June the replacement would likely be Dennis Burke, a former top aide to former Gov. Janet Napolitano, who now serves as Obama’s homeland security chief.

Burke is not widely known to be well-versed in Indian justice issues.

When asked why Obama would replace a history-making Native American tribal justice official – when the president himself has noted the need for more American Indians in top political positions – White House officials noted that it is not unusual for presidents to want to fill political appointee positions with allies.

It may be a political reality, but it is not one that sits well with those who know Humetewa and her work.

Thomas Heffelfinger, a former U.S. attorney and lawyer in Minnesota, said she has inherent credibility on Native justice issues that doesn’t come naturally for most U.S. attorneys.

“Diane has been an amazing representative,” said Heffelfinger, who was invited six months ago by Humetewa to the Navajo Nation to discuss school violence issues. He has strong knowledge in the area as a result of overseeing legal issues involving the Red Lake reservation shootings of 2005.

“It’s unfortunate that the political appointee process is going to remove a really qualified U.S. attorney.”

Still, Heffelfinger noted that it would have been unusual for a Bush appointee – even a Native American U.S. attorney – to hold on to the job.

John Dossett, general counsel for the National Congress of American Indians, said that despite the political reality of the situation, many tribal leaders have been strongly supportive of Humetewa staying in the position, and are disappointed she will be replaced.

“It is a loss, for sure,” Dossett said. “But it is not a surprise.”

He didn’t know how likely it would be for the Obama administration to appoint another Native American U.S. attorney, but he noted that NCAI has been pleased with the choices of Native Americans that the administration has made thus far to serve in key positions.

“The most important thing is for good resumes to keep going forward to the administration, so they have folks to consider for these positions,” Dossett said, adding that NCAI has been forwarding resumes since the administration’s beginning.

Dossett noted that many positions within the administration at varying levels are still open.

Humetewa could not be reached for comment on her departure.

Wednesday, Sep 2 at 3:52 PM Hrezdog wrote ...

Well now the Humetewa Sister is here at the hopi tribal prosecutors office, now lets see if all you Diane supporters will here what good she bring to Hopi, she ain't staying long, she she won't change a darn thing, right now our ACTING CEO tribal secretary just terminated the prosecutor becaues he won't drop the charges against her son, what a joke the HOPI tribal Secretary and council are.

28644303
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jul 31 at 4:08 PM hrezdog wrote ...

good thing Diane left, her father and sister are messing up the hopi people, her fater in the tribal council and her sister right next door in the tribal secretary's office here at HOPI, they think that because Diane Humetewa give them the right to NOT listen to their own poeple

27133139
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jul 26 at 11:52 AM You've been duped by O! wrote ...

Bunch of hypocrites here. You all should be outraged that Obama fired Humetewa. NCAI made a big stink when Bush fired 8 federal prosecutors. What a joke. Democrats have screwed you for years and you still support them!

26809062
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jul 24 at 9:42 AM BraveModoc wrote ...

You Realy Need to look at History and history of the World. Not just our History We need more Educated Natives to Repesent us as a People and not the Invaders As I see All people not Native blood of this soil

26714094
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 22 at 2:40 PM real Hopi [s] wrote ...

All this chatter about how knowlegable Diane is on Indian issues, well she has not proven herself well as a Hopi, what does she really know about being Hopi, what has she really accomplished being a Hopi, a Hopi Woman at that. The day she starts actually starts to carry out her Hopi Woman responsibilities will be the day she can have some of our respects.

26574452
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 22 at 2:15 PM real ndn fr hopi wrote ...

Diane's luxury car won't make it on Hopi, we still have dirt roads that needs fixin & she had a chance to fix em but instead was part of a process that helped tear apart a system by misusing her judicial position.

26572392
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jul 10 at 11:31 PM Hmm wrote ...

Maybe she can drive her luxury car out here to the rez and do some work.

25828111
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jul 7 at 12:06 PM Shame the Devil & Tell the Truth wrote ...

Here we go again! Just because someone is Native does not automatically mean they will work for and on behalf of Skins! Good riddance, Ms. Humetewa was nothing more than a token appointment to placated folks in Indian country. She was highly ineffective and was nothing more than a McCain crony! Ms. Humetewa is best to return to her Hopi Rez and assist them with their issues! President Obama is better off selecting a replacement that will serve and respect tribal rights and their people.

25545412
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jul 4 at 5:26 PM Arizona Indian Education Doctor wrote ...

I've read the comments about the AZ U.S. Attorney. Even if she was still in office,the fact is the Arizona Indians would still be with an ineffecitve AZ U.S. Attorney. We, as educated Indians must work to be excellent so others can see that we are not mediocre workers. We must show a track record of achievement, especially in difficulty. Crime is out of control in AZ reservations, such an opportunity to have done something good. Some of us have dealt with her regarding crime. Nothing done!

25416182
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jul 3 at 9:42 PM ArizonIa Indian wrote ...

You guys couldn't the truth! Shame on you ICT! Typical Indians. No wonder most of Indian Country is overun with major crimes. Indian people suffer because of people like you. This probaly won't get posted but it's worth trying.

25385309
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jul 3 at 2:52 PM Arizona Indian wrote ...

Good Move! She was an incompetent and a passive U.S.Attorney. She failed to protect the people and uphold her federal trust responsibilities in Arizona. She was notorious for "declination" of criminal cases. The term "decination" means as it applies here in Arizona that she as U.S. Attorney made decisions not seek crimnal charges after being presented with confindential findings of a law enforcement investigation of a suspected federal offence arising in Arizona reservations.

25371289
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jul 3 at 12:09 PM S.A.M. wrote ...

A typical political move, although Obama said after he was elected to the Presidency he would use both parties in his administration. Politicians lie.

25364827
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jul 2 at 6:17 PM V wrote ...

Looks like Diane will bag former San Juan Southern Paiute Prez Evelyn James for 25 years in prison. Some Indians stole more and only received 3 months and jail and a restitution of $50/month. Renzi is still a free man. Maybe will find out the real reason for replacing her.

25331937
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jul 2 at 2:40 PM Apache NDN wrote ...

Remember these words? This is not about a red state or a blue state, but about these UNITED STATES of America! Stupid me! And I believed him. Obama nows whats to replace a history making (like himself) Native American U.S. Attorney because she was appointed by a red state Republican President? I take back all the emotions I felt for Obama and the African Americans the night he was elected 44th President of the United States of America.

25320502
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jul 2 at 2:26 PM Arizona NDN wrote ...

The state of Arizona has many Natives, therefore replacing a Native U.S. attorney doesn't make alot of sense regardless of political ties. It's another loss for Native America! Obama was a smooth talking brotha, but he didn't fool me. Its time for the Montana tribes to have a sit down with him and teach him the true meaning to Native integrity.

25319559
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jul 2 at 5:12 AM BraveModoc wrote ...

Native

25289679
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 1 at 11:29 AM rezzie wrote ...

That's politics fer ya. We could always use her on da rez.

25247552
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 1 at 8:52 AM Newest wrote ...

She's a McCain "clone", what do you expect? Maybe she can go home and provide some leadership for her own people...

25237252
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jun 30 at 4:02 PM Dewaine wrote ...

She is great, but she has been associated with McCain a long time, she just picked the wrong party, if the other party won she could very well be promoted to a higher level, but nope. party ties make a big difference, we'll see more change when people associated with the party of "NO" are replaced with people for change. There is a place that really needs some legal guidance it's called the Hopi Reservation! Why not give her own tribe a hand? You can live on the rez even if you are educated!!

25205329
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jun 30 at 10:55 AM nobody's friend wrote ...

the hopi woman worked for US as an attorney. somewhere along the line she didn't cut the mustard, and its politely said to be the appointment process. maybe she will be motivated to work for indian group--maybe she can be another 'advocate' like teehee!

25184552
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jun 30 at 2:10 AM LSL wrote ...

Diane is a leader and will always be a leader. This is an opportunity for her to take her talents and put them to use in Indian Country in a different venue. She will continue her rise...

25167049
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jun 29 at 8:55 PM Lloydd Snowater wrote ...

Typical! Whitemqan makes promises that they have no intension of following! And I thought this President was suppose to be for change. HA! He lied!Seems blackman is no better than whiteman!

25158779
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jun 29 at 4:15 PM stewart wrote ...

Good luck Diane. I will always think highly of you, you have gone a long way. I know you will keep moving forward. See you at the next ceremony.Thanks for all your work.

25146817
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jun 29 at 2:41 PM Southwest wrote ...

I wish her nothing but the best, I hope she runs for public office, I have herd nothing but great things about her from dems and reps, native and non-native. But then again maybe she shouldnt cause she's doing fine in her field. Maybe Obama has a place for her in his administration, cause she is an expert indian country.

25140772
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jun 29 at 12:06 PM "Hopi"ng for change wrote ...

Diane is an intelligent, Native woman who knows Indian country and what goes on and how it works on the rez. Obama is making a huge mistake in replacing her--with a political appointment that knows nothing and cares even less about natives. So much for being adopted into a tribe--where's all the talk now. Diane will survive as the strong Indian role model she is and no doubt will help Indians in the future.

25131829
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jun 29 at 11:53 AM T.Paine wrote ...

Foolish people...haven't you realized yet that the ''KENYAN''messiah'' only cares if you're: 1)a muslim 2)a marxist In that order,just call it the m&m rule.

25131054
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jun 29 at 12:47 AM asher wrote ...

i love obama, he has take over crisis and i hope he woul get more luck to make us go up regard

25112567
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jun 28 at 3:40 PM KEVIN wrote ...

I know some people will be angry at me for having a comment to them I am sorry ,but I have to say something about this.I as an american find this sad it makes me realize how afraid our goverment is to have any NATIVE AMERICAN in real power and instead we make a big deal out of saying we are sorry for having slaves when we destroyed the real founders of this country and are afraid to do anything about this at all. When I read this story it just made me sad. I am sorry

25099994
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jun 28 at 12:44 PM Indian Joe wrote ...

Politics are politics - Native or not. This is part of how the game is played. Republicans are noted for it. Remember the American people voted for a CHANGE. This is only a part of the change the country needs. Obama appointed many great Natives including the first ever in the White House, mind you; and in the BIA and IHS. Get over it and move on. Diane is not going to make or break Native America. She will still have a role somewhere.

25094549
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jun 28 at 9:38 AM Ninch wrote ...

The Obama explanation for replacing a very successful Hopi is completely opposite of what Obama "promised." Remember that Obama was NOT raised in any authentic culturally relevant way, and he does not get it. He learned to pander and maipulate, but he did not learn to stand by his own words. BTW: Do not be willing to "accept" his broken promises to Indian Country because of other appointments. Obama will be "taking" Indian land for his national energy "grid"... i.e. anti-tribal sovereignty.

25089129
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jun 27 at 8:49 PM CreekProf wrote ...

Now...tell me again why the Democrats insisted on that congressional witchhunt when Gonzalez fired those atty's for political reasons? Indians always hope the next guy will do right...

25076117
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jun 27 at 7:34 PM mik maq wrote ...

i was mistakenly told by our tribal chief that obama liked natives. guess we were all wrong

25073774
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jun 27 at 4:39 PM HonorIndians wrote ...

Yes, we should be satisfied! Based on our history, we should be very satisfied. He didn't remove us, assimilate us, reorganize us, send us to boarding school, and he only "terminated" one of us! We were thrown a couple of crumbs, so let us all be satisfied and now get freaking lives. Forgive us for getting uppity and believing another politician!

25069319
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jun 27 at 4:28 PM BraveModoc wrote ...

Its Not the way I see it..Its just the way it is..and has been For many full bloods..just because your an eighth doesnt mean your one of us..My Bones come from the Ashes and dirt of this soil as my GreatGrandfather and His Grandfather but how many of my people get to Vote..there put buss and sent to the poling station

25069087
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jun 27 at 4:09 PM Sparr0w wrote ...

When one door closes another opens, hang in there Diane, you are a GREAT NATIVE WOMAN. He'll realize he made a mistake when you continue to make history for all Indians be it feather or dot. You are capable of one day sitting in Obama's seat. Love from Nevada

25068674
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jun 27 at 1:08 PM Triniti Braided Blood wrote ...

Some of you ndn's will never be satisfied! He could not have made any appointments of indigenous people at all! Get over yourselves..get a freaking life!

25063567
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jun 27 at 11:07 AM Don Quixote wrote ...

His Majesty Barak Hussein Obama the First, Blessed of Allah, doesn't hesitate to throw away anyone, for any reason, if he wants to. That's the sign of a totalitarian and dictator, not a president. He's a Chicago thug politician, nothing more. Indian Country supported him overwhelmingly, and now he's turned his back on it. Every Indian should see this as a deliberate slap in the face. It's disgraceful.

25059984
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jun 27 at 9:59 AM shae wrote ...

I am sorry that you feel this way i am african and native american so i do understand what you are going through but just remember through all of this that there is only one master who gives the final word and it not the president of the united states it is God! God say that the first will finish last and the last will finish first! Have a blessed day!

25057912
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jun 27 at 7:31 AM BraveModoc wrote ...

This Is A time We Need to stand And Fight once again We Have a Politician in the whitehouse full of lies and will do anything oust the Natives once again MY family has fought for My Tribe and this Country and now we are once again put on the back burner for Mexicans and Blacks I am Neemeepooh and Modoc and very proud..I will no one take my fredome and I will fight likemy Greatgrandfather and his father I am Strtill a Brave for my people and Not theres

25053389
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jun 26 at 11:38 PM Real nden wrote ...

see...nobody cares for us natives, even a man of color.. the only way we'll ever get ahead is to charge rent.. our way of life was the only way we could survive.. white mans money means the end of native america.. remember what grandma and grandpa said a long time ago..

25046252
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jun 26 at 4:04 PM N-nationbuilder wrote ...

I hope someone puts this into Barak's face. Good Indian polichy apparently doesn't trump political expediency for this pres.

25029964
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jun 26 at 3:55 PM denise wrote ...

Obama has his own personal reasons on why he replaced her, if she was stellar I don't think she would of been ousted. But, then again its just an opinion.

25029534
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jun 26 at 3:38 PM T.Paine wrote ...

For all of you that voted for the empty suit in the White House-Chairman Maobama...how's that workin' out for you? Where's the outrage?????????

25028672
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jun 26 at 2:48 PM Obama-How? wrote ...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dIxK9HWideQ&feature=related

25025904
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jun 26 at 12:54 PM Smitty wrote ...

Hopi changie LOL.

25019347
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jun 26 at 12:46 PM Pitt wrote ...

How's that hope and change working for ya?

25018897
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jun 26 at 12:28 PM Evelyn wrote ...

He's foolish to get rid of Diane. She was doing a good job. Many U.S. attorneys don't know Indian policy, so this is a loss to the administration.

25017847
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jun 26 at 11:53 AM HonorIndians wrote ...

"The cowboys always win" Thomas Builds the Fire, (Smoke Signals)

25015669
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jun 26 at 11:07 AM rezzie wrote ...

You win some... you lose sum.

25012832
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jun 26 at 9:48 AM NDNLady wrote ...

It's "not unusual" to fill political appointees with allies? Isn't that just another way of saying this is "politics as usual"? I thought we were promised that "politics as usual" would not continue. Some "Change" ennit??? Yes, we can?? Well, we could of but didn't!

25007669
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

By posting a comment, user agrees to all Terms Of Use. Comments may also appear in other website locations and in other Indian Country Today products, without notice and at the discretion of Indian Country Today.

Indian Country Today and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand