Photo courtesy McDonald’s Trimble: Custer, the plastic icon
By
Charles E. Trimble, Columnist
|
|
I would find it difficult to boycott McDonald’s over the Custer incident. It seems like an innocent, thoughtless mistake. |
Recently the conspiracy struck again. This time it was McDonald’s fast food chain, which started giving away a plastic figurine of George Custer – yes that George Custer – in every Happy Meal. Custer is depicted as riding a Harley-Davidson Hog, no less. If you are creatively paranoid you can imagine that he’s on his way to Sturgis to disturb the serenity of our sacred Bear Butte. At any rate, it seems Lakota country is up in arms again, and distracted from dealing with the problems of poverty and social pathology that beset the reservation. One Indian columnist reports that most Lakotas, Cheyennes and Arapahos are enraged over this insult and he responds with a blistering counter attack on the Big Mac army.
Being somewhat diet-conscious I’m not a great McDonald’s fan, although I do like to pig out on their french fries on rare occasions. And as far as I’m concerned, their coffee is better and cheaper than Starbucks. Otherwise I seldom go there, and thus I have been denied the indignity and trauma of seeing the historic villain Custer being commemorated. I did not get my chance to vent my outrage and expound to the smiling little obesity candidates standing in line for their Happy Meals about what a dastardly poltroon that plastic long-haired, blond general riding the tiny Hog represents. Worse yet, I didn’t get one of those little plastic icons, which are reportedly being taken off the market and will thus become valuable collectibles because of the controversial status and rarity we’ve given them. Damn!
Anyway, I would find it difficult to boycott McDonald’s over the Custer incident. It seems like an innocent, thoughtless mistake.
| All corporate advertising departments have some person that will come up with an idiotic idea that will offend someone or some group; and this is apparently what happened with McDonald’s. |
Here in Nebraska not long ago, McDonald’s gave out place mats with the story of the Trial of Standing Bear, that heroic Ponca chief who fought his way back to his Nebraska homeland after enduring the tribe’s forced march to Oklahoma only months before. His trial here, brought by helpful attorneys and a newspaper publisher, and even with the passive help of General George Crook, marked the federal court’s decision that an Indian is a “person” for the purpose of Habeas Corpus. The argument that an Indian was not a “person” under the law was used by the Army to deny Standing Bear’s citizen rights of a trial, and to force his people on a second trail of tears back to Oklahoma. That court decision allowed the chief to stay in his homelands, and it set a precedent for all Indian people. The place mat story, given away with all meals by McDonald’s, was beautifully illustrated and proved popular with kids and parents.
So I tend to think that McDonald’s is not a bastion of racism and part of the vast conspiracy that I facetiously describe above. All corporate advertising departments have some person that will come up with an idiotic idea that will offend someone or some group; and this is apparently what happened with McDonald’s.
Besides, outside of certain groups of tottering old historians who have good memories of the general and bad ones of Indians, and who re-enact their own brand of twisted history, Custer doesn’t stand high in public esteem. I think most people remember Custer only for the royal butt-kicking he took at Little Bighorn in 1876, and he is the butt of jokes as much as he is a hero in history or legend.
Time and again he proved himself an arrogant and egotistical clown. But not many people know of other ridiculous things he did besides sending his troops against a superior force of Sioux, Cheyenne and Arapaho, against the advice of his own Indian scouts. For example, he decided to put on a show for his adoring wife Libby on how to kill a buffalo. He found a herd and charged ahead full speed, singling out one old bull to chase down and kill. Closing in on it, he drew his pistol, took aim, and shot his own horse right out from under him – at full speed. Dusting himself off and staggering back to his horse, he finished it off with a single shot, and limped back to his still-adoring wife, who presumably picked cactus and sand burs out of his fancy buckskins for many weeks.
| I don’t think we ought to waste time or righteous rage over this thing and other things like it. |
He might have done better on a Harley, but I doubt it. McDonald’s Custer toy was supposed to promote the movie “Night at the Museum: Battle of the Smithsonian.” I didn’t see the movie, but from the title I gather it is a comedy. If that is so, I would imagine that Custer is made to look rather foolish in his role. In such case, perhaps we ought to ignore the perceived insult, and encourage more people to take their children to see the movie and let them get their laughs at the idiot on the Hog.
At any rate, I don’t think we ought to waste time or righteous rage over this thing and other things like it. In the minds of many people (including our own), we Lakotas are getting to look more and more like whiners instead of the strong people who have endured five centuries of onslaught to destroy our cultures and our people, and still stand tall for our sovereignty and our rights.
Charles Trimble, Oglala Lakota, was born and raised on the Pine Ridge Indian Reservation in South Dakota. He was principal founder of the American Indian Press Association, and served as executive director of the National Congress of American Indians from 1972 – 1978. He is retired and lives in Omaha, Neb. He can be reached at cchuktrim@aol.com. His Web site is iktomisweb.com.
Classifieds
On Demand
-
Digital Copy
Receive Indian Country Today in digital format Read more »
-
ICT Insider
Sign up to receive ICT Insider E-Newsletters Read more »
-
ICT audio
Listen to audio programs from ICT Read more »
-
Video
Watch ICT videos right in your browser Read more »
-
RSS Feeds
Stay up-to-date with ICT Read more »
-
Mobile
ICT on your cell phone or PDA Read more »
Thursday, Aug 20 at 3:52 PM Bizibayaash wrote ...
"Wm THawk hit it right on the head" (whoops, no pun intended)
28030437 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, Aug 20 at 3:51 PM Bizibayaash wrote ...
Wm THawk hit it right on the head: Lets say we get a Hitler figure on a motorcyle? Would we suggest that Jewish people focus on 'other strugles' & quit 'whining'? I don't think so.....(and, by the way, maybe this represents something we can actually DO something about -- compared to all the many more injustices that we seem to have little to no control over)....
28030374 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Monday, Jul 6 at 4:25 PM Tsalagee wrote ...
I read that column over three times and it doesn't seem to me that writer is praising Custer. The way I read it he is saying that we ought to not spend our energies on such a loser like Custer was.
25500424 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Sunday, Jul 5 at 2:34 AM Leonard Peltier wrote ...
If you think about it, McDonalds was doing the Native Americans good, by honoring an American. In this case, an American Civil War hero, who prided his "war" tactics on attacking sleeping women & children. I say Thank You to McDonalds for making America remember "Custer".
25428674 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Sunday, Jul 5 at 2:23 AM Mike Stiffarm Gros Ventre wrote ...
If you think about it, McDonalds is honoring "The Death,of Custer", and the aragance,of the U.S. Government! However, McDonalds is guilty of prejudice by not honoring the Warriors who won this victory. The Sioux, the N. Cheyennne, the Gros Venttre, Blackfeet, Piegan, and other Tribes; who all united to stop the white menace. According to many stories, there were over 5,000 lodges. The US Army had a habit of attacking sleeping Indian villages, Hmmm terrosim tactits?
25428522 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Friday, Jul 3 at 5:12 PM Per 'Bear' remarks wrote ...
Bear you're out of your mind, trimble is finally coming out of the closet-he's never dealt with his Lakota heritage and now that he doesn't need it anymore, his true self emerges! Nothing trimble says/does can be considered wise!
25377029 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Friday, Jul 3 at 1:45 PM bear wrote ...
another round in the Trimble v. Giago Old Timer's Boxing Match.... As I recall, Giago extended a sincere apology to you for whatever got your goat... it's time to let go of your resentment and show us the wisdom and maturity of age... no more peeing contests ....
25368527 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, Jul 2 at 11:48 PM Iyeska Bantering wrote ...
Per "louis gray",-Crazy Horse monument laser light show announces that McD's widow JOAN KROC, donated $10 million for its sound system, I thought I heard...does anyone know if this either of these assertion(s) are material. As for trimble, he's done 'overing' on playing LAKOTA, so now he sits in Omaha taking poy shots at the struggles of reservation life-the same challenges we Lakota have been taking on for centuries and his lineage couldn't handle so they divided the blood with white men...
25345184 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, Jul 2 at 3:39 PM Letalis Maximus, Esq. wrote ...
Not to put to fine a point on it, the fact is that the toy Custer is not riding a Harley-Davidson. It is clear to anyone who knows vintage motorcycles that the toy motorcycle upon which the toy Custer is riding was modeled after an Indian Motorcycle Company Chief model - most likely one made between 1946 and 1953. Personally, I think that is hilarious. But, opinions may vary.
25324007 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, Jul 2 at 1:43 PM WmTHawk wrote ...
As a traditional-minded Lakota, I say that figure of one who was dishonorable to all Natives was racist and put out by an insensitive organization, like others who proclaim to be for equality and non-discriminatory, which resulted in traumatic feelings by Natives. It's like a Jewish person seeing a figurine of Hitlre in his McDonald lunch box.
25317367 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, Jul 2 at 1:10 PM Celeste Strikes With A Gun wrote ...
The phrase "state of seige" applies to many Indigenous Peoples. If there is a war against us, then we ought to seek protection for women and children. I live on an Indian Reserve in Canada, and there is never a dull moment. Our greatest challenge is to have an effective bi-cultural approach for education. It is awful when Indigenous men and women, who possess white education/training credentials, try to force white ways upon their own Peoples. Despite the nonsense, there is hope.
25315294 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, Jul 2 at 12:46 PM Louis Gray wrote ...
Chuck I believe your inherent dislike for Tim has led you to believe this isn't about anything important. First off I agree, Custer is a disgusting image and not deserving any recognition. By the by, McDonalds also does award scholarship monies from their Ronald McDonald foundation. Blacks, Hispanics and Asians are ok, but Indians cannot apply. When questioned about this they believe those monies are best spend on historic minority groups. We remain the least educated but we are not worthy.
25313632 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, Jul 2 at 12:21 PM hiatsistsalagi wrote ...
well, i have watched this movie 3/4 times and STILL havent seen custer on a harley...will have to look closer...that would be a treat..BTW...the 'night at the museum' is a movie for kids, and should be left in that domain...
25312247 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, Jul 2 at 11:54 AM White Boy Trimble wrote ...
Its clear why trimble can weigh boths sides he more white than Lakota but can't be more than an average white guy so he's LAKOTA! OGLALA LAKOTA! My tribe except my family is full-blood He engages in literary battles with tim giago and both should address the overt racism which flourishes in SD, especially as it we Lakota in the Paha Sapa...alot of trimble's countryman are making a economic killing off we Lakota but mixed-bloods like trimble see this as OK. He is an enemy in the camp! Get a life
25310369 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, Jul 2 at 8:52 AM Rezzdog wrote ...
Damn eloquent and well put Chuck, as per usual.
25297787 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Add a comment
Most Popular