Navajo Nation suspends president

Photo courtesy Navajo Nation

President Joe Shirley Jr. has been suspended by the Navajo Nation Council.

Tools

Navajo Nation suspends president

By Rob Capriccioso

WINDOW ROCK, Ariz. – With a major investigation of tribal leadership ongoing, the Navajo Nation Council has voted to suspend long-time President Joe Shirley Jr.

The action came Oct. 26 via a majority vote of 48-22. Before the vote, the council deliberated on investigative reports focused on the leadership’s involvement in controversial business matters known as OnSat and BCDS.

OnSat is a satellite service provider, which has been shown in an audit to have overbilled the tribe.

BCDS, Bio Chemical Decontamination Systems, is a joint venture corporation of the tribe focused on manufacturing.

A special review of the BCDS deal by the Navajo Nation Office of the Auditor General previously found that many of those involved failed to exercise due diligence before investing in the company.

A statement from the council said Shirley would be suspended as investigations are carried out to determine if prosecution of “ethical, civil and criminal charges by the Navajo Nation through a special prosecutor” will be necessary.

The statement said the investigative reports “provide reasonable grounds that certain Navajo Nation officials and employees may have seriously breached their fiduciary trust to the Navajo people.”

Complete details of the reports have not been released publicly, but, according to the council’s statement, the reports allege wrongdoing by the president and key members of his staff within the executive branch of the tribe.

Shirley’s suspension amounts to administrative leave with pay, the council said, adding that the action would allow law enforcement authorities access to further information within the Office of the President and Vice President without interference.

The investigative reports will now be referred to the Office of the Navajo Attorney General for application to the Special Division of the Window Rock District Court to hire a special prosecutor. The attorney general has up to 60 days to decide whether to ask for a special prosecutor.

Navajo Nation rules say the council can place the president on leave in circumstances where there are reasonable grounds to believe that such official has seriously breached his or her fiduciary trust to tribal citizens.

Shirley, a tribal leader for more than four decades, has been vocal in expressing his disappointment regarding the suspension.

In a statement from the president’s office released after the action, Shirley said he believed the council was retaliating against him.

“It appears irrefutable that the action is in retaliation for efforts to seek an initiative election to reduce the council from 88 to 24 delegates, and to allow the president line item veto authority.”

He had spent much of the year pushing for the reform initiatives to go before the voters, which is set to happen in December.

Shirley said, too, he wanted to know specific allegations against him. The Navajo Times has reported that his office is looking into legal options.

The council quickly disputed Shirley’s accounts, saying in a press release issued Oct. 27 that the decision had “absolutely nothing to do with the two initiatives he and his office are pushing.”

The release said the OnSat and BCDS investigative reports were requested as early as September 2007.

“Despite the criticism being received from the Office of the President, the tribal government is operating smoothly and there are no disruptions in services,” said the release.

“Business will continue as usual. The council is urging the public to respect the process and allow the investigations to run its full course in a proper fashion.”

Vice President Ben Shelly has been named to take over all presidential duties, pending the investigation.

Tuesday, Nov 10 at 2:06 PM DONTE wrote ...

this Man won,t allow environmentalist on the Rez because the environmentalist want to shut down coal power plant but the navaho get 11 million dallors more than most native nations i say find and different way for the navaho get clean air is more important than 11 million dallors the navaho leaders are selling their own people for money the "president of navaho is greedy he spends it on himself the navaho leaders are betarying their own teachings the environmentalist want rejuvenate.

31897824 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 9 at 4:53 PM DONTE wrote ...

THIS MAN stole from the navaho people the navaho wanted environmentalist on the rez but he kick them out the people want clean air but he refuse it.

31852301 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 9 at 11:56 AM all weather horse marine wrote ...

in answer to nw indian, the political appointees are also under investigation, a number of them anyway. i go this info from a councilperson at a recent chapter meeting on navajo rez. once again navajo nation govt is in the news for scandal rather than governance. i hope this evidence leads navajo to think of total change of government--change from the sheep camp level.

31834114 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Nov 5 at 2:44 PM N.W. Native wrote ...

Question: So where were the other elected officials during all of this? Shouldn't they also be held accountable? Just want to be informed.

31650049 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Nov 5 at 12:37 PM Nadabah wrote ...

Wheres all the dine that voted for Joe Shirley who put him right back into office during election? This is what they wanted and believed in so stand behind your leader. We could had changed if we voted the right people in.

31641494 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Nov 5 at 11:42 AM No Suprise!! wrote ...

Where are the teachings we are so strickly brought up with? Our elders teach and praise this is what they speak of! Do you as officials in office not share these same teachings? You as a president should be ashamed of what is happening. The sad part is greed and $$$ has made you blind and deaf to your own peoples needs. Will there be change? Will it be for the better? This is what we are all wonder EVERY time. Think of your teachings..your traditions..your elders!! Respect your people!

31637726 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Nov 4 at 7:13 PM Christopher Francisco wrote ...

Wow! this is crazy. I'm in Portland Oregon and I heard about this. I moved off the reZ when I turned 18 and I'm coming home to change the BS thats going on. We have the highest rate of sucide, alcoholism, child abuse, domestic violence, drug addictions, no wonder we have problems, all the money is being stolen. Our air and water is full of pollutions. We are being occupied by a foreign government. We need to go back to the Matriarchical system. Let the women lead.

31605514 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Nov 4 at 12:09 PM chizzi wrote ...

you shall know them by their behavior. the only thing missing from the article is the amount of money under contention: its more than 40 million dollars which was literally taken. the structure of current navajo nation govt is obviously flawed: whats to be done? my view is total radical surgery: out with the old, in with the new.

31580456 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Nov 4 at 11:02 AM Corey R Armstrong wrote ...

This corruption is really surfacing now with the tribes in Oklahoma now, especially Chad Smith and the Cherokee Nation. The Illinois River has been polluted by the chicken industry and the Nation is seeking monetary damages when they should be fighting with all there wealth to save it.There are positive consequences of money and power such as more cultural and language classes being taught here at NSU, so much more could be done for the antire Native community

31575379 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Nov 4 at 10:43 AM Sara wrote ...

The Dine tribe has some educated and motivated young people. Remember you young adults have the strength to move your tribe forward.

31574071 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Nov 3 at 9:26 AM Willaim Donovan wrote ...

Joe Shirley had it coming because he had incompetent, uneducated people working for him like Patrick Sandoval, Isabelle Walker, Mr. Andrew Tso, etc. Speaker Morgan is also lead by Darth Vadar Dr. James Davis. He is pulling all the strings along with former Tucson Strip Club worker Tuurquoise Rose as staff assistant.

31509039 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 2 at 6:16 PM A shamed Dine' wrote ...

How embarrassing and we call ourselves Dine' how could we be proud to say we are DINE' when our own DINE' leaders are just corrupted and greedy. Give me a break! No wonder our younger generation are going off our DINE' reservation to fulfill their education dreams elsewhere. Come on Council Delegates wake up and smell the coffee. Our younger generation need you to be our role models don't let the $$$ get your heads. Make us be proud of our DINE' nation. BE POSITIVE!!

31484626 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 2 at 4:06 PM nobody's friend wrote ...

the permissiveness of the allegations, the types of favoritism, the length of time, all point to a type of government that doesn't work. i hope many navajo see this in action.

31478036 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 2 at 2:54 PM Frank wrote ...

Oops. Meant to type "The problems were not addressed" in previous comment.

31474514 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 2 at 2:47 PM Frank Bedonie wrote ...

President Shirley and his staff are their own worse enemy. Some of these problems surfaced via articles in the Navajo Times years ago. The problems were address, so it continued to escalate. Being put on suspension is a wake up call to him and his staff that on going problems can not be ignore. It needs immediate attention and start resolving the issues. Once again, the sleeping gaint (Navajo Nation) is awaken, lots of eyes are on it. Lets see what it does next.

31474092 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 2 at 1:40 PM Stewart wrote ...

I wish this was just a local matter but anyone who knows even a scrap of native, federal relations, knows that what happens in tribe usually affects every other tribe. That's why a case brought to the supreme court isn't just applied to the tribe who loses. It is applied to every tribe whether we had anything to do with it or not. Industry and investors also make judgement calls based on how stable they think tribal governments are in general. I could go on and on.

31470337 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 2 at 9:49 AM Non-Navajo wrote ...

Apache Warrior, what in hell does NCAI have to do with this. Navajo has never joined NCAI, and even if they did, this is a local tribal matter and it's none of NCAI's business. Probably none of your business either, or mine either.

31457531 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 1 at 9:42 PM V wrote ...

Does the hotel at Monument Valley Tribal Park have a valid lease agreement? Probably not. Why were local Navajo business shoved aside at Monument Valley? All this happened under Dr. Joe Shirley. The locals fought him, but Dr. Joe Shirley walked all over there rights and eventually pushed there business to a bad locatino where they withered and died. The chieckens have come home to roost. Finally there is justice in this world. I hope Dr. Joe Shirley goes to prison and put him in the hoel.

31438709 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 1 at 8:14 PM Navajo Voter Phoenix wrote ...

Led by L.Morgan (Speaker)Navajo Nation's Hell's Angels. You are as phony and unethical as they come. You are a disgrace to the Navajo Nation.

31435144 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 1 at 7:16 PM nora wrote ...

Guess this means more hotel vacantcies for the up coming INFR final in Las Vegas this coming weekend. And no more expensive trips to HAWAII and giving out discretionary funds to family members. This also means you, Lawerance Morgan! Time to get off your bike! You made it public, so deal with it!

31432462 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 1 at 7:06 PM Nora wrote ...

READ,READ till you found out the true facts? Well, let me share my opinion about our well respected leaders being put on leave. To the readers, we should know this is due to our own nations council delegate. They want to delegate themselves to thier old way of business. Lets VOTE 24, on December 15, 2009. Alot of elderys are without electric and running water on the reservation. The council are too busy driving around their nice SUV and beating up thier wife back home with their gold rings. Sad.

31431914 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 1 at 6:05 PM Apache Warrior - Arizona wrote ...

Donovan: Its more like 40 years! Even if the people are getting screwed they keep electing the same old people! Around election time they forget about what the complained about. Thats like shooting yourself with a 30-30 Winchester rifle. (Traditional Indian Gun)It is no wonder the young people are moving away from the rez to seek a better life. Indian "leaders" getting awful "dirty and vicious". What happen to our elders? Is this an issue at NCAI? Hell No! Just "but-kissing".

31428644 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 1 at 5:04 PM Why? wrote ...

Why do so many people reading this article have so much to say about the reservation? Move onto the reservation and create real change. From the negativist view of the Navajo President, you have no idea the turmoil and corruption the Navajo Council has caused and continues to cause. They are the lawless bigots. Do your research!

31425514 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 1 at 7:31 AM a.donovan wrote ...

Why on earth was this guy allowed to remain in office for more than for decades.When this happens the incumbent leader puts his own mark on matters and becomes complacent which in turn leads to corruption.No one should be allowed to continue in office for so long.

31406823 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Oct 31 at 1:11 PM Apache Warrior - Arizona wrote ...

The Western form of government does not work on Indian Nations. What is happening on the Navajo rez is happening also happening across the most Indian Nations. The elected leaders are stealing the people's finacial resouces. The same thing is happening on my rez, the White Mountain Apache Tribe. The so-called Trust Agent, the BIA is looking the other way, while the people's money is being stolen everyday by elected tribal leaders. The Navajo leaders is fianlly being revealed. It's big time.

31383147 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Oct 31 at 8:37 AM rezmom wrote ...

I remember when I was young this was happening with Peter McDonald.Wow!seem like times have not change.Its $$$ & greed!This is the political world, once they are in office (including the council)they forget about the people and they focus on their own material needs.Our tribal system is not working because their are far too many loop holes.

31373243 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 30 at 10:32 PM Peter June, Redhouse clan wrote ...

Wow! This contract was initiated during Kelsey Begaye's administration and has gone through a couple of Presidents & council, oversight committees and audits, yet improper accounting checks & balances were ignored, especially coming before the council, yet this oversized counci can't even comprehend what they're reading or voting on! Alterative motives by the counci?

31363197 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 30 at 8:51 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Where is they check and balance system?? How can the president sign away on loans without presenting it to the delegates. After all this is the Navajo tribal money. Sound like the delegates were sleeping on the job while the wolf was out.

31360418 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 30 at 5:17 PM Lupa wrote ...

I think any one who is to have charge of a budget for an organization needs to have a credit check to see if they can manage thier own affairs especially if they are going to manage a Tribal organization.

31353367 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 30 at 5:01 PM REZGUY wrote ...

On the one hand, its "united we stand, divided we fall" but if we want to succeed, we have to deal with bad apples the best way we can, try to stay united and move on. Din'e need to stay business oriented for the good of all, not politically oriented for the chosen few.

31352908 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 30 at 4:13 PM Spoken wrote ...

It's funny that so many people tell us to "modernize" to solve our problems without realizing so many tribal council people have known nothing but modern society. And they have picked up the worst of it with the greed and nepotism. One last thing--Can we once and for all please retire the "crabs in the bucket" analogy. It has to be most overused, cliched, and tired analogy in all of ndn country. I thought it was novel when I first heard it 30 years ago but come on people, find something new.

31350752 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 30 at 3:38 PM Phoenix Navajo wrote ...

Since native americans became fully assimilated into the american system of government, time and time again, we see corruption. Mainly from those who have spent years, if not decades in their respective areas. In Navajo, its a cycle. Every one or two decades, we find ourselves at the same fork in the road. Perhaps its a sign of the times, as the very fabric of our society becomes undone, as well as our respective cultures, by those who think they are above reproach. I hope, I hope...

31349062 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 30 at 2:23 PM heathersopinion wrote ...

A bet its "Crabs in a Bucket" again.

31345248 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 30 at 2:09 PM Rob wrote ...

It really does sound like there is a lot of corruption and shady business going on. Such a shame. It would be nice if we could just label all the corrupt people with thermal labels and then everyone would know wherever they go.

31344567 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 30 at 1:59 PM rezzie wrote ...

The tribal council should be the ones getting suspended. They are the ones who are corrupt and power greedy. Meanwhile, all they do is nap, read newspapers, browse the intenet, eat pinions in council sessions. What a joke!

31344083 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 30 at 1:56 PM Indian woman wrote ...

All I can say is Divide and Conquer! The tribal government will never advance because its a "foreign government", yet tribal members still don't know or see this.

31343898 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 30 at 12:31 PM Half & Half wrote ...

This is just another symptom of a system that is imposed on the reservations. Having said that, I think it is a good sign that people on the reservation are looking at what the leadership is doing. It's important that the leadership know that people care about what is happening, and that people expect good government.

31339283 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 30 at 10:40 AM JS wrote ...

Rex Grossman for Navajo Nation president.

31332463 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 30 at 10:28 AM Kathy X. Johnson wrote ...

NN Council has done everything they can to prevent the Navajo people from exercisng their inherent right to determine the type of government they want. NNC continue to put up obstacle after obstacle to remain in power. Very few of them have a conscience anymore, they are like a pack of coyotes guided by trickery, money, alcohol and lust. Government reform is so important now, in a few more years, these delegates will start to rob our investments. I say its time for a class action lawsuit!!

31331833 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 30 at 9:16 AM Holdup wrote ...

Okay so now the Tribal Council should do the same and suspend themselves for misconduct. There the ones who give out money to there relatives without oversight. Last I herd some delegates gave out money totaling $75,000 to three people. And they say its for the good, give me a break this whole system is messed up, trying to be someone there all not

31327518 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Oct 29 at 11:24 PM Bangle wrote ...

Wasn't this the same guy who was complaining about environmentalist and grass roots dine organizations interfering with his plans? Sounds like the bigger threat to the tribal government is corruption, nepotism and shady dealings.

31313203 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

By posting a comment, user agrees to all Terms Of Use. Comments may also appear in other website locations and in other Indian Country Today products, without notice and at the discretion of Indian Country Today.

Indian Country Today and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand