Story Published:
Sep 23, 2009
Story Updated:
Sep 18, 2009
WASHINGTON – A group of Native Americans is asking the U.S. Supreme Court to hear their case calling for an end to the controversial trademark of the National Football League’s Redskins team name and logo.
Lawyers for the case’s six Indian plaintiffs filed a writ of certiorari petition with the high court Sept. 14.
The petition asks the court to review a lower court decision that sided against the Native Americans based on a statue of limitations-based legal concept known as laches – which the petition asserts is not applicable in this case.
The case, which has been ongoing since 1992, is known as Suzan Harjo v. Pro-Football. Its lead plaintiff, Suzan Shown Harjo, is a well-known Cheyenne and Hodulgee Muscogee advocate for Native American rights. Several other respected Indian leaders and elders are involved in the litigation.
Lawyers for the owner of the team have long argued that its name and logo – depicting an Indian head and feathers – should continue.
The Indian plaintiffs disagree, believing the trademark is unlawful largely because the team name and logo are racist and offensive.
Elders, scholars and tribal members point out that the “redskins” term has historically been used as a derogatory reference to American Indians, in a similar way that the word “nigger” has been wrongly used toward blacks.
Historically, the word “redskins” was also used by the U.S. government as a way to refer to bounties it placed on scalped Indian heads, according to historians and legal experts.
Philip Mause, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, said it is “very important” for the Supreme Court to decide the case based on its merits – and, in turn, help come to a conclusion that the name and logo should be removed.
He said the petition makes an argument that there is precedent for overturning the lower court’s statute of limitations-based decision, including a Third Circuit decision made by Samuel A. Alito, a current justice on the high court.
“We have a strong argument that laches should not be applicable,” Mause said.
The U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington came to a contrary conclusion in May when it upheld a 2003 decision by U.S. District Judge Colleen Kollar-Kotelly. She ruled that the Indian plaintiffs waited too long to challenge the trademark for the team, which was first issued in 1967. She later clarified her decision, writing that the youngest plaintiff turned 18 in 1984 and therefore waited almost eight years after coming of age to join the lawsuit.
Mause, a partner at Drinker Biddle & Reath in D.C, said the statute of limitations-based ruling is not applicable in this case. He believes Alito will agree, especially if he takes the time to review the petition.
When Alito served on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit prior to joining the Supreme Court, he ruled on a case involving laches in a way that is divergent to Kollar-Kotelly’s reading of the law.
Before Kollar-Kotelly’s decision, the plaintiffs saw a panel of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office cancel the team’s trademarks in 1999. But the judge’s decision, as well as the more recent appellate decision, served to moot that trademark panel’s revocation, and the panel has since said it will wait to decide on the trademarks of the team until the legal process has been completed.
Kollar-Kotelly and the appellate courts never addressed whether the Redskins name is offensive or racist.
Mause said it will be difficult to get the Supreme Court to take on the 431-page petition. The court usually decides to take on few of hundreds of petitions it receives each year.
Legal experts familiar with the case said Native American organizations and other groups are expected to file amicus briefs in support of the petition within a month of its filing.
The National Congress of American Indians and the Native American Rights Fund have already contributed to helping file the petition, Mause said.
Defense lawyers did not respond to requests for comment. They have 30 days from the filing date to respond to the petition in court.
Thursday, Oct 1 at 10:26 PM roy black wrote ...
YOU SAY REDSKINDS ISUES IS NOT INPORTANT. YOU SAID GET OVER IT. I AM GOING TO CALL MY FOOTBALL TEAM african jungle bunnies.
30000167Thursday, Oct 1 at 4:49 PM Haters everywhere wrote ...
Oh and who are you to say urban Indians don't have traditions or ties to their land? Who are you to judge people you've never met before? Maybe you don't have traditional knowledge. Stop judging other people and take a look at yourself.
29986007Thursday, Oct 1 at 4:43 PM Haters Everywhere wrote ...
Haha haters! Why don't you become a lawyer or activist then so you can focus on the issues important to you? There are plenty of people working off and on their Rez in order to benefit their people and address concerns like poverty/ alcohol and drug abuse/ corruption/ toxic waste/health/social problems. Make a difference not by hating on others but by actually being an advocate yourself. Get over it. You can't judge every "urban Indian" u meet either. Hahaha
29985602Thursday, Oct 1 at 11:21 AM Tell the Truth & Shame the Devil wrote ...
Apache Warrior you write the truth and summed it up! I am tired of urban NDNs that claim Indian Preference to see how they can benefit. They have NO CONCEPT of what REAL INDIANS experience on their rezs. All “urban NDNs” want is MONEY they have no tie to the land, culture or tradition. It’s pointless trying to rationalize with an “Apple” I am sure, Harjo and her kind would NEVER relocate back to the tribes they claim member! They are too busy trying to capature the attention of white folk!
29962877Thursday, Oct 1 at 10:59 AM yepa wrote ...
Change it the the Washington Crackers. Has a good ring to it...doesn't it?
29961274Wednesday, Sep 30 at 1:48 PM RD wrote ...
I have to agree with Ashamed on this. This will not be resolved by this type of divisive dialogue. Yes, this issue does harm to us, especially in trying to teach our children that degrading another group is not the way and yet everyday we see/or read it...everywhere! which in turn makes some think it's okay to do.
29910229Wednesday, Sep 30 at 2:11 AM Ashamed wrote ...
Why has this even become a fight between native people? You think this makes ndn people look good to the American public when we don't even get this much press coverage usually? All this infighting makes me sick. Yes there are separate issues and concerns when it comes to being urban or on the rez. That doesn't make anyone more or less indian. Infighting destroys tribes and families. Get over it and have useful discussion without bashing each other so we can learn from one another instead.
29884379Tuesday, Sep 29 at 9:32 AM NO! to All Indian Mascots wrote ...
Our Indian warriors are in the grassroots activism, they are also Indian lawyers and all land defenders, they are tribal leaders who have all those honorable qualities, these are the ones who are our 21st century hero's. But most importantly, you need to stop desecrating the original Indian battlefield hero's. We will fight to keep them OFF the football fields and basketball courts and let them rest in peace with the dignity they deserve; that is the Indian way. You’re are desecrating them.
29835784Monday, Sep 28 at 10:58 PM ALJinMT wrote ...
I live in Montana, and all of the reservation high schools have names like "Indians" and "Warriors" and such. Only people without real problems are concerned about mascots.....
29820624Monday, Sep 28 at 10:36 PM anonymous wrote ...
Famous protest sign that says, “We need to drag some people kicking & screaming into the 21st century” (addressing racism at sports stadium), well, the same thing could be said about some Indians, they just don’t get it. They think Indian mascots are cool.
29819719Monday, Sep 28 at 9:08 PM Joe Average wrote ...
Interesting. If the Romans had conquered North America, all these cry babies ancesters would have been carried off in chains and sold. Period. Instead, what did you get? Guilty white people who have given billions and it still ain't enough. Land? 150 years ago , put a Crow warrior and a Sioux warrior in the same room alone and one would kill the other, AND, take his woman etc. Who had the Black Hills first?(Crows)Not all whites are stupid.Keep it up, and "by-by" treaties and sovereign"Nations".
29815774Monday, Sep 28 at 12:46 PM Charles F. Ross wrote ...
I'd like the team mascot to be redrawn and renamed as the "White Eyes" with the Quaker Oatmeal logo. You can't get anymore white than the nation's capital (government, not racial demographics of the city) so I believe that the "White Eyes" would be considerably more appropriate.
29789244Sunday, Sep 27 at 8:39 PM David Velarde Jr wrote ...
I'm a rez Indian that recently moved to the city in search of my dream. The Washington Deadskins need to change their mascot and that's all their is to it. CHANGE YOUR FRIGGIN MASCOT. CHANGE YOUR FRIGGIN MASCOT.
29761737Sunday, Sep 27 at 4:15 PM ray winters wrote ...
your newspaper should feel shame for printing the r--word, i am sure you wouldn't print the n--word out of respect for blacks. the indian community knows what the r--word is. in respect to our people, you dont need to print the r-- word letter for letter.
29751902Saturday, Sep 26 at 12:04 PM Change the Name wrote ...
The term "redskin" is offensive, racist, and completely inappropriate, especially to be associated with the Nation's Capitol. Why hasn't the American Indian Society of Washington, DC, ever taken action in support of changing this abomination of a name? Has the Washington team ever donated to support any Native American organization in the DC area?
29707977Friday, Sep 25 at 5:43 PM Frank wrote ...
Cheyenne and Hodulgee Muscogee? Since when?
29680167Friday, Sep 25 at 5:20 PM Apache Warrior - Arizona wrote ...
To Urban Indian: You outnumber us real rez Indians like you said. You "Indians" don't count in the cities. What little land and natural resources we have left after most of it has been taken away we will continue fight for. Yes, it has "no-impact" on you, thats because you are not a real Indian. You are a generic Urban Indian with no traditional and cultural ties to land and water like the rest of us. As warriors from Indian Country we continue to battle in the courts for real "issues"
29678669Thursday, Sep 24 at 9:29 PM NNDs R People - Not Mascots wrote ...
The difference between Indians & other minority groups is that Indians make up barely 1 percent of the U.S. population, and compared with other groups have virtually no political power. Should population or political clout determine the level of tolerance we are willing to give to racist imagery? NO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
29630114Thursday, Sep 24 at 9:25 PM skin walker wrote ...
Give fools a written language and so goes the bloody mess. Hollywood indian,public education indian,sports or entertainment indian same fools show up. If it hurts or makes some one ill there goes the lawyer game. Globalization view of what is india and then make believe america mickey mouse,donald duck,Rock Hudson doing Ronald Reagan cowboy style. Prison or indian reservation policy makes about as much since as Iseral wanting more war so as gencide is not forgot. Name branding your voice fools
29630009Thursday, Sep 24 at 3:53 PM SimpleTruth wrote ...
Ahhhhhhh the arrogance of people directly or indirectly stating that their personal opinion is correct....or that they are the "real indian", dealing with the "real indian issues"....nobody has to do anything to us, we do it all to ourselves psychologically everyday....so sad....WAKE UP!
29613989Thursday, Sep 24 at 3:22 PM Sound The Alarm! wrote ...
Who was behind WWI; IRS/Fed Reserve Act; crash of '29; Great Depression; WWII; Korea: Cold War; JFK hit; Viet Nam; oil embargo; relaxing oversight on banks; savings/loans gouge to public; subprime blood-letting/gouge; Wall St. pillaging the public; Mideast wars; TARP-bankers got paid by Fed for driving economy into ground though! Its the fed reserve and Natives can choose to play along as puppets by not with much clout so get back to your res and sound the alarm-here comes the bankers and their
29612264Thursday, Sep 24 at 2:43 PM sd grouch wrote ...
Wanted to add that though Caucasians don't call African-Americans/Blacks the N word or other racist variants has that equaled social justice for that community. If we get rid of mascot names will that translate into a justice system that rules in favor of Native govt.s or individuals because the US Supreme Court hasn't ruled in favor of Natives in the last 9 years. Will that also end the social ills affecting Indian Country, including Natives victimizing their own.
29610062Thursday, Sep 24 at 2:11 PM Urbanized wrote ...
TTTSTD-Agreed. I think Harjo does a number on rez ndns, but not on this area. Im a full blood, rez raised guy who moved to the city. What angers me is when we work on an issue in the city and some unconnected rez ndn is brought out to condemn it by our opponents. We don't do that to rez ndns so why do it to us? Growing up I heard a lot of complaining but not much action on anything. I go back and try to get people going but nothing ever happens cause most are apathetic or are afraid. Good luck.
29607947Thursday, Sep 24 at 1:41 PM Robert Xavier Betancourt Junior wrote ...
Too bad it is all about MONEY not Land. LAND is power and so are Lakes. Land and Water are forever, besides is the United States going to be here in the next one hundred years? Maybe thinking it over especially with korbel, why not ask for LAND and Lakes. Taking care of the earth and water is a tradition.
29605934Thursday, Sep 24 at 1:36 PM Tell the Truth & Shame the Devil wrote ...
@ Urban: I just relocated back to my rez from a lucrative (6 figure gig)! Why? I heart & soul is tired to my Rez / home! You nailed it, regarding tribal operations. We MUST redefine our own paradigm – do what works for us (which may require an array of methodologies) Apathetic coach potato - not me! Learned in the best universities on the planet (American, Johns Hopkins, Yale). Worked gigs that MoFos would kill for (Fed to Fortune).
29605612Thursday, Sep 24 at 12:27 PM LAKOTA ramblings Cont'd. wrote ...
The bottum line is ALL americans and most of the world, free or otherwise, are held in strangle hold by the federal reserve bankster cartel, who dictate presidency(s); Congress but most tribes are too poor to really take too much advantage of so they appoint puppets likr r swimmer-OST, to cook IIM accts books! Many can think being a Dem or Rep matters but in the long haul, its doesn't because they're tapped into the same cesspool . The fight is to preserve tribal soveriegnty and harjo's litigat
29601189Thursday, Sep 24 at 11:57 AM urbanized wrote ...
I congratulate your efforts on reforming tribal government. But, for all this talk about tradition, doesn't it seem ironic that your tribal govt is a mirror of american govt? Call me assimilated if you wish, but I don't see how trying to copy the white mans govt and his economic system on the rez makes you anymore traditional. Who funds the tribal govt anyway? Don't bash ndns who get off the couch and actually organize, fundraise, educate and make an issue of something that bothers them.
29599282Thursday, Sep 24 at 11:06 AM Tell the Truth & Shame the Devil wrote ...
You can’t have capitalism without racism! @ Urban: If you are so distraught living amongst the “American Society” goes home! Or can it be that you NEVER lived on the rez? Is it safe to assume you don’t speak your Indigenous language or participate in your culture? As for me and what I consider the real issues – that is specific to my tribe. We have formed a coalition to demand “transparency and accountable” within our tribal government. Yes, it’s a grassroots effort but it begins at home!
29596169Thursday, Sep 24 at 2:19 AM Per "urbanized" LAKOTA again! wrote ...
Your moniker says it all! How would you know what remote res life is like? It seems you're too busy waiting to bawl on que for litigation effect! No, I'm a real-live 4/4 timpsila-eating Lakota! again harjo and aforementioned groupies get a life & a grip on your ill-charted hubris!
29579469Thursday, Sep 24 at 1:48 AM urbanized wrote ...
Don't be fooled by people like "lakota". They are most likely white sports fans impersonating real natives. No Plains tribe calls the plains "the back prairies" lol
29578949Thursday, Sep 24 at 12:43 AM LAKOTA: RU kidding? wrote ...
Why do these mixed bloods and urbanized crybabies keep this nonsensical agenda going? On the back prairies of Lakota country there are far more relevant issues to seek judicial relief from...all the way to SC to cry around about "Redskins?'harjo you and your disillusioned groupies get a real life will you and report back!
29577549Wednesday, Sep 23 at 9:55 PM Urban wrote ...
I will take the same approach you do and ask you this--How do water rights for your tribe benefit those of us in the city? It doesn't. Whether or not your single tribe gets water doesn't affect the levels of anti indian racism that we deal with day to day. We have different issues in an urban area and guess what-we are the majority of indians in the united states. There are more indians in the cities than on the rez. Good luck with your water fight but just remember it doesn't impact me.
29572079Wednesday, Sep 23 at 8:35 PM Apache Warrior - Arizona wrote ...
To: Urban Indian It is no wonder that you don't see what is going on in real Indian Country. Many of us are on the front lines fighting for the number one issues which is water-rights. Many real American Indians on many reservation desparately need water. Water is life!!! Here you are about "redskins"?? What a bunch of BS!! You Urban Indians haven't got a clue. If you can be even called an "Indian".
29569038Wednesday, Sep 23 at 7:21 PM Jonathan wrote ...
Good, I'm glad it's back on tap to be decided. That name doesn't honor us, there's no honor in naming teams or things after people. Substitute any other race or ethnicity Washington "insert inappropriate slur here", and you see how it feels. This case has been lost many times, its time to turn it around!
29566302Wednesday, Sep 23 at 7:20 PM John wrote ...
Just change the name to the Washington Whiteskins and have a fat,lazy European in a loud Hawaiian shirt wearing flipflops. Have him eating a burger in one hand and shooting off a gun in the other. This way we are honoring our past and current ancestors....RIGHT!!!!
29566234Wednesday, Sep 23 at 6:29 PM laurag wrote ...
Tell the Trutha and Shame the Devil; are you serious? Suzan has been an activist for many issues that affect Native people. I think there is no honor in the team from Washington. If it were all about honoring, then they wouldn't be so blasted derisive about the move to change the name, now would they? The whole reason sports teams use Native imagry is because of the early settler perception of Indian as "savage" so consider history when you insist that the names are honorable. They are not.
29564607Wednesday, Sep 23 at 6:02 PM Two Feathers wrote ...
The Washington Redskins were once the Braves. The Washington Braves, thats honor. I charge the Supreme Court not to sidestep this issue. It's like playing ball, and your about to win for the go ahead touchdown, only to be told that the game is over, you ran out of time, our field, our rules. Scared of competition, take on those that you know you can beat.
29563504Wednesday, Sep 23 at 5:29 PM Two Feathers wrote ...
I take no offense of the Indian and feathers. As for the Redskin, it's like, defending Stalin. Imagine Blackskins, buff slaves, on the helmet, lets honor them for service and sacrifice to our country. Yellowskin, Whiteskin, Brownskin, and don't forget the reputation of the Mixskin. Laches are a form of repayment of some obligation. How about the Washington Indians? I guess the Court will interpret forever as meaning something else. This will be a measure, a mark of how far we have really come.
29561842Wednesday, Sep 23 at 5:26 PM Urban wrote ...
This is a challenge to all who say there are more important issues out there-----What are those issues and tell us exactly which ones you personally are working on. I guarantee you that none who say other issues are more important are actually doing any work on them.
29561703Wednesday, Sep 23 at 4:31 PM Anonymous wrote ...
You people are wasting your time. There are far more important issues that takes legal priorities than your stupid "redshins" carp. The radical days are over with. It's time to get real and deal with real "Indian" issues.
29558642Wednesday, Sep 23 at 4:29 PM Urban wrote ...
People are quick to bash issues that are important to urban indians but guess what, we have to deal with totally different issues than those who still live back home and have the luxury of being surrounded by their own people. If the rez issues are most important then why don't you who live there do something about it? You don't see urbans taking shots at your efforts do you? I support this suit but wish they would have used a different pic than that scary mug. How bout a young leader for once?
29558533Wednesday, Sep 23 at 3:14 PM peter lawrence wrote ...
Fourth, it's a private entity and doesn't get freedom from antitrust or tax free status like baseball and the cleveland indians. Fifth, the Redskins emblem is a proud face and no derrogatory but the cleveland indian is derogatory.
29554582Wednesday, Sep 23 at 3:11 PM peter lawrence wrote ...
Fourth, it's a private entity and doesn't get money from the government like Cleveland. Baseball gets freedom from antitrust laws and is not taxed. Fifth, the image is proud, not derogatory like the cleveland image.
29554453Wednesday, Sep 23 at 3:09 PM peter lawrence wrote ...
Several reasons why their case should have no merit. First, the team was originally a boston team and the name referred to the boston red skin beans. Second, in the original team, they were the first to have american indians in the NFL and used the name to honor them. Third, using the name "Redskins" for a team who carries respect for American Indian Heritage has changed the meaning from negative to positive ove the last 40 years.
29554333Wednesday, Sep 23 at 2:26 PM RD wrote ...
Tell the Truth and Shame the Devil: You've either led quite the sheltered life or have been too influenced by all that bogus history they taught you in public schools or...you've never been the target of hate by racists! The dirty names, the beatings, being spit on. Have you never been to an pro-sports game where those sitting next to you were "whooping", gestering the tomahawk and trying to emulate what "Indian" means!? Get real! better yet, learn some REAL history!!
29552167Wednesday, Sep 23 at 2:04 PM sd grouch wrote ...
The role of the courts lately seem to be to undermine or negate Native People, govts, and established jurisprudence. Can we really expect justice from a legal system that continually wrongs or harms us from the Marshall rulings to the Long case? Though I am sympathetic to those wanting to tackle the mascot issue, will it really benefit individual Natives or is it only a drop in the ocean?
29550937Wednesday, Sep 23 at 1:32 PM Tell the Truth & Shame the Devil wrote ...
Why ask why? If you don’t know, you’d better ask somebody! Ms. Harjo lit this match that began this wildfire and now she wants to use water from someone else’s river to extinguish this fire? Oh hell no! Let’s get real, think critically about this frivolous suit. Shall we examine the real motives behind this “bandwagon issue” – there are far more egregious issues affecting American Indian that some “name” and “face” on a helmet. But we don’t see Ms. Harjo (and others) broach those issues
29549238Wednesday, Sep 23 at 1:28 PM Skin Walker wrote ...
savage scalp 50 cents male 25 female 10 child any sex,tobacco pouch female breast high collectable frontier exploration,sun dance warrior lamp shade orginal battle field dressed,head of subject objects very mascot for children of slavery running with pig skin full of air so hot dogs and processed water is consumed along with over priced garments. Buffalo hair blacks can be paid to do anything for a buck now they have an orginal from Africa calling the game plan. Washington REDSKIN money
29548978Wednesday, Sep 23 at 1:07 PM rezzie wrote ...
Why mix politics with sports?
29547667Wednesday, Sep 23 at 12:36 PM hard start wrote ...
i as 4/4 degree blood do not care one hoot what the foreigns call themselves, even to the point of calling their teams honkies or whatever. i think there are plenty of other serious issues at hand that need work on, such as declaring the us supreme court a star court and without force when it comes to indian country. also, dept of interior needs language to hold them responsible for effects of bad decisions.
29545607Wednesday, Sep 23 at 12:13 PM Tell the Truth & Shame the Devil wrote ...
Look at the logo used by NCAI...it has an Indian man wearing a headdress. That is offensive because NOT all tribe use headdresses in their regalia and it excludes women. Should we sue NCAI?
29544153Wednesday, Sep 23 at 12:00 PM Tell the Truth & Shame the Devil wrote ...
Speaking of using offensive images. Look at the logo used by NCAI...it has an Indian man wearing a headdress. That is offensive because NOT all tribe use headdresses in their regalia and it excludes women. Should we sue NCAI?
29543322Wednesday, Sep 23 at 11:59 AM Tell the Truth & Shame the Devil wrote ...
What is more disgusting than the cartoonish images of Indians is the shabby way in which tribal politicians, self proclaimed activists and pundits behave and conduct themselves under the guise of working for and behalf of American Indians. Their behavior is more clownish and mocks the essence of what truly being an Indigenous person is about. And that is far more offensive than any image used by professional sports teams.
29543254Wednesday, Sep 23 at 10:50 AM Modern_NDN wrote ...
Long over due ! We are still here! we do not appreciate the derogatory reference and cartoonish figure that is supposed to represent us!
29539413Wednesday, Sep 23 at 10:25 AM I’m Not a Buffoon wrote ...
A big thank you to the National Congress of American Indians and the Native American Rights Fund who have filed a amicus briefs in support of this petition and other groups who contributed as well. Our prayers are with the Court that they know and understand the REDSKINS TEAM NAME & LOGO IS TRULY RACIST.
29537987Wednesday, Sep 23 at 8:27 AM Tell the Truth and Shame the Devil wrote ...
Buzz off, Suzan Shown Harjo...you don't speak for me - or a lot of other Skins! Not all full-blooded traditional Indigenous people despise or hate the word, “Redskin, Chief, or Indian” but a certain sect "urban Indians" would have the country believe otherwise. You just want press coverage! If you want a court battle then fight for something meaningful like healthcare or broken treaties -like Elouise Cobell! Go Washington Redskins: wishing you success on the gridiron and the courtroom!
29531864Wednesday, Sep 23 at 4:11 AM RP wrote ...
"...its about time!!" Many prayers & blessings to winning this case. Its a given that it is a very racist term to us, Native/First Nations people. Thanks to all those who did not give up on this and continued to move forward all these years! Please win.
29526773Add a comment
Most Popular