Tools

Rosebud Tribe battles Black Hills lawsuit

Wants Obama administration and Congress to intervene

By Rob Capriccioso

WASHINGTON – Rosebud tribal leaders are asking for time to work out an agreement with the Obama administration and Congress before any courts decide to dole out a decades-old financial settlement for the federal government’s historic plunder of Sioux lands in the Black Hills region of the Great Plains.

Chairman Rodney Bordeaux said his tribe and other Sioux leaders may be able to work with the government to get their lands back, instead of money.

He said the tribe mentioned the issue specifically to President Barack Obama when he campaigned on the reservation last year. A fellow tribal member, Wizipan Garriott, now works as a special assistant in the Department of the Interior and served on Obama’s transition team.

“We keep the lines of communication open,” Bordeaux said, adding that he is excited for the administration to appoint a long-promised White House senior advisor on Native affairs. “And there is no reason not to have hope.”

Bordeaux’ hope is rooted in history. The U.S. government agreed in an 1868 treaty that the Black Hills would be set aside for use by the Sioux. But after gold was discovered there, the government soon changed its tune, and Congress passed a law taking the land in 1877.

The tribal government’s concern over a financial settlement has been piqued as a result of a new lawsuit, filed in federal court in Sioux Falls, S.D. It seeks to circumvent the tribal government and get money directly awarded to individual tribal members.

The tribe’s council passed a resolution last year, which states that the Rosebud Sioux Tribe has not authorized, approved, or consented to any lawsuit filed by individuals to seek Black Hills settlement funds.

The council has now authorized funds for legal services to file the appropriate opposition to the lawsuit on behalf of the tribe.

Lawyer Wanda L. Howey-Fox, who represents the tribal members trying to receive a financial settlement, said the best that can be done is to get money. According to the lawsuit, courts cannot give back the land the Rosebud Tribe and other Sioux tribes claim as their own.

“We don’t think they have a chance,” Bordeaux said of the tribal members who are suing. “But you never know with this federal court system anymore.”

The suit stems from a ruling by the Supreme Court in 1980, which upheld a lower court ruling that awarded eight Sioux tribes $106 million for Black Hills lands that had been wrongfully poached by the federal government.

The award was equal to the 1877 value of the land plus $17.5 million plus interest. Trust funds held for the tribes by the Department of the Interior now contain about $900 million, according to lawyers for the tribal members.

The lawsuit seeks a federal judge to decide how to distribute the money to individual tribal members from Interior’s trust funds.

Since the Supreme Court’s decision, all of the Sioux tribes have refused to take the money, instead insisting on the return of their lands.

The lawsuit, which officially lists only 19 tribal plaintiffs, is a class-action suit with approximately 5,000 tribal members signed on, according to Howey-Fox. She said that some fear retribution from tribal governments for taking part in the case.

Bordeaux and other tribal leaders and members believe it is irrelevant what the lawsuit says the courts can do in terms of land. They say that both Congress and the Obama administration can help them get back the land they view as rightfully theirs.

The issue has already been raised many times to Congress members, including Sen. Byron Dorgan, D-N.D., who chairs the Senate Committee on Indian Affairs.

“They’ve listened, and they say they want to uphold treaties,” Bordeaux said. “But when push comes to shove and we start asking for our lands back, then you find out how supportive they really are.”

The Rosebud Sioux Tribe has long refused a financial settlement, partially because leaders did not want to be seen as ceding their treaty rights in any manner.

Accepting the monetary award for the Black Hills, Bordeaux said, could forever extinguish the claim of the Sioux nations to the return of any land in the Black Hills.

He also noted that Sioux Nation member tribes do not seek return of all the Black Hills, only lands under federal ownership. He added that there would be no retribution against tribal members involved in the suit.

“I do think they are being shortsighted and going against the wishes of their forefathers and ancestors. But it’s not a position that is shared by a vast majority of our members.”

Tribal legal officials are already arguing that federal law prevents a court from ordering federal officials to disburse money from the old court cases. They say that because the tribes refused to accept the money during an allotted time period, the Interior can now only disburse the funds with the approval of Congress.

Beyond legal arguments, some tribal members have said that taking the money would amount to blessing the theft of tribal lands.

9:08 PM bmacN wrote ...

Writing from an Irish point of view. We lost our Language,our customs and have had our country divided by British imperialism. Your peoples have faced many hardships from the Europeans,and to my shame many Irishmen served in the US forces,who committed crimes against your Nation. It appears to me that the US Government would like to divide your Nation,by offering money for their theft of the He Sapa. Don't accept the Blood money. Remember the brave people who gave all for the defence of your Nation and think of the generations to come. Your cause has many friends around the world, and if your Nation stays united you will win in the end.

37235194
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Dec 26 at 1:22 PM Anonymous wrote ...

One little indian with a small voice says .......take the money and buy back the scared Hills

34374034
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jul 28 at 2:05 PM Craig wrote ...

I understand the confussion and tradition that some tribal members have on this issue. Being married to a Rosebud women for 24 years and living on the reservation for half that many, I have seen a lot of people who claim tradition but do not really practice these things on a daily basis. The money could do some good for some people instead of just sitting there waiting for the department of interior to give it to some other cause. If you dont want it, dont take it. We want it.

26936059
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jul 18 at 8:40 AM nish wrote ...

You gotta believe. You gotta stand for something. Every dollar I ever got is gone, don't even remember 'em. My beliefs, my land, my rights, they still are with me. When I leave this world, they will be with me. My uncle told me "show me one thing we signed where we get something, every deal we make we lose something, and what is ours that we keep, they say they 'give' it to us" Don't take the money, the land will always be there. There are things more powerful than wasicu justice.

26309457
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jun 12 at 11:45 AM WmTHawk wrote ...

I am a Sicangu. The lands in question, particularly the Sacred Black Hills were for the Oceti Sakowin Oyate. The Oyate originated from that land, and the 1868 Treaty reserved that land for the Sioux Nation. It is immoral, unethical, illegal, unjustified, dishonorable for the U.S. to take it by force in violation of the treaty. Who ever sells the land is greedy and selfish. They do not speak for the entire Oyate and they dont think about the next generation of our young. It's not for sale, never.

23663744
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jun 1 at 11:27 AM Fed up wrote ...

why don't the people who want the money get it and then be disenrolled from their tribes? That is what they are asking in return for a few dollars. There are many items attached to the treaty that once it is settled the benefits tribes receive will disappear and we all will be assimiliated. Before you think of only money take the time to read the whole thing. I am a Sioux and I would rather have the rights to the land that our Ancestors shed blood for than a few dollars spent on material.

23012579
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, May 29 at 2:28 PM kunsi wrote ...

We can use the money to buy back all the land we can get ahold of in and around the Black Hills and then get our act together and buy back the rest of the state. The fact is, if we stop buying booze and drugs and making the "While Clay's" on and near the rez million/billionairs, we can get our land back.

22895039
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, May 29 at 9:39 AM Niecie wrote ...

Don't the Sioux Nation know by now that the taking of the Black Hills by the 'Government" we will NOT get it back. I am an enrolled member of the Sioux,and I am tired of hearing that we want the Black Hills back,don't take the money. Sooner or later the theiving Government will get tired of paying interest on the settlement and start issueing the money whether you like it or not because we are not going to get the Black Hills back. Get real.

22873699
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, May 27 at 8:06 PM Spirit Deer wrote ...

My gracious indeed...as we continue this fight for our lands against the government I am reminded just how selfish the gov't really is and how much they like to backstab people. I mean think about it, did they really agree to the Laramie Treaty of 1868? Look at the wars we have been in for these lands, remember the people who have died fighting for these lands. Remember, the government cannot be trusted, we can only trust each other, our native brothers and sisters.Trust only in each other.

22772667
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, May 27 at 7:35 PM stephanie wrote ...

I read that the Trust took a big hit via stock market. I really doubt that the trust still holds 900 million. The Black Hills Trust has become a huge joke in Indian country. The feds will never give the land back. I say take the money and fight to get back tribal lands that have been seized illegally by local, county and state governments.

22771422
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, May 27 at 2:00 PM Lucille A. Quilt wrote ...

Someone told me that the Black Hills was the heart of the United States. They said that a heart was in the black hills. I told my son and he looked on the computer and pulled a picture of the heart that truly is in the black hills. What does that speak to your hearts? Money is here and slips through your finders like water. How long would you have that money? Lucille

22749817
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, May 26 at 2:59 PM misty t. wrote ...

just give us our money who needs it

22687047
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, May 25 at 10:32 PM divka1 wrote ...

Yeh, I've been to Mr. Rushmore and I'm sure it draws a lot of revenue for a racist, "Mississippi burning" state in its actions against Native Americans. I suggest Mt. Rushmore be dynamited, blown up, and completely obliterated since it is nothing if not a slap in the face for the Native American population in South Dakota. I hope Steven Spielberg goes to South Dakota and makes a film along the lines of "Mississippi Burning" about the treatment of Native Americans.

22428462
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, May 24 at 8:54 AM donna in duluth,mn wrote ...

I have a article that says the man who builded mt. rushmore was friends with the kkk, I will be sending this down to rosebud, hope you can use the info

22124487
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, May 24 at 2:49 AM Native NDN wrote ...

The Black Hills Claims Settlement is only one of many such claims where the outcome becomes controversial among its members. The US Government controls all aspect of the litigated case, from start to end; in fact one cannot sue unless given permission to do so. We forget the Indians are "wards" of the Government with limited quasi-sovereignty and all traditional lands held in trust or ownership by the US Government. Time and time again, we see our treaty rights eroded with each case litigated.

22118974
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, May 22 at 9:16 AM Savilla, a.k.a. Storm Cloud wrote ...

As a long-time friend of the Sioux, I back up their claim for the Hills. A Treaty is an agreement to do certain things, so again I say all 565 sovereign Ndn nations should finally unite behind the Sioux and for the first time show the U.S. the power of our legal treaties and our inherent sovereignty. Too many people seem willing to give up the fight for $$. Crazy Horse, Sitting Bull, Red Cloud, et al, would be ashamed. Call a Council of War, now.

22034709
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, May 20 at 4:09 PM Old Colville Woman wrote ...

I was married to a Rosebud and have two children enrolled at Rosebud. Don't let money divide the "People" and don't lighten up on the real "Government" that put the people at "odds" with each other.

21918019
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, May 20 at 9:48 AM Wanbli wrote ...

Our Black Hills is about spiritual and phyical principles, laws, degrees from our common Creator to us, as a Nation, nothing more. This government has poured in billions of dollars to so called fix, yet maintain, their dirty little secrets in relation with our Red Nationalist Nationhoods that they continue to kill. A aboriginal without divine spiritual principles anylonger is a immoral slave to those that holds his soul for more torment. He is just another victim, condemned, with his oppressor.

21816234
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, May 19 at 10:35 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Mr. Bourdeax we never had the communication line open, you tribal leaders always made the decisions for us without acknowledging what we think first. In the bible those who had faith prospered. You had little faith in us. its about time we agreed and decided to make our own individual decisions, and now it looks like you are interfering with that if you was so worried about it why didn't you do step forward before and take some kind of action instead of waiting until the lawsuit was in place.

21787319
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, May 19 at 10:25 PM dakota john wrote ...

I think we all have a different point of view and my point of view is that we should get the money because,i dont think we should keep the land because its never gonna happen.Thats just my point of view i might be right or wrong.so take it.

21786839
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, May 19 at 8:42 PM 2009 century wrote ...

you can all sit back and wish for the Black Hills to to be given back to you. But this is the 20th century and life goes on. All the blaming and judging. Those of you who want to sit and wait can do just that. and those of us who need the maza ska can get ours and invest in it. Its either that or nothing. I speak for myself and this is my opinion. this world belongs to God. like they say this world is the only thing that will live forever.

21781719
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, May 19 at 1:44 PM Wanbli wrote ...

The world is watching and they know the Truth about what is happening to our Sovereign Homelands and its Oyate and its the Truth that will set us and our earth free from imperialist capitalistic rule and dominance. A house divided cannot stand. We must admit we- the Red Nationalist nation-hoods are divide by this empires mechanism of manipulations. So, the solution is easy; "Unity in Truth" for Justice to prevail across our planet. We seek opportunities to be truly free and self-determined sov.

21747547
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, May 19 at 1:19 PM Wanbli wrote ...

To say to our youth you can live in two world is a munipulation. Its not possible, if the world that is opposeing our Red Nationalist reality is a munipulator of its power. My Sicangu Oyate is on the path of true liberation when they oppose the sale of Unci, Mato Sapa. I'm proud of my counsel and relatives and the Ochti Shakowin Oyate that understands that freedom cannot be about profitablity anylonger. Its time for universal ceremonial solidarity and freedom to live self-determined and free.

21745659
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, May 18 at 3:29 PM BH_dreamer wrote ...

I am an enrolled member of the Rosebud Sioux Tribe - Sicangu Lakota Oyate, and in my part or should I have the option to vote, I would not take the money, I prefer the land, there is no amount of money that will be traded for the land. And yes, this is something to think about, should the federal government decide to give back the lands, the question I have is in regards to the original boundaries of the treaties, what will happen to all the Non-Indians living here? They are in trespassing.

21675519
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, May 18 at 2:57 PM Nancy wrote ...

Keep up to good work of representing our Tribe Rodney. "Our Black Hills are NOT for sale". Our ansestor fought hard to retain "He Sapa" (Black Hills) and our future generations are depending on us to continue to defend our treaty rights to the claim of "He Sapa".

21673477
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, May 18 at 1:46 PM Chris wrote ...

Keep fighting to get the land back regardless-the Government Fathers did it-Pray/dance for the land to return to its rightful owners.

21669129
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, May 18 at 1:10 PM pierre guy wrote ...

What? Tribes can't even stop a liquor license from being sold to protect Bear Butte! How are they going to get land back in the Black Hills????

21667067
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, May 18 at 11:56 AM space man wrote ...

and no on is talking reconciliation? i backup the people to get their lands. lands has more value than money. i hope all indigenous groups help out.

21662322
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, May 18 at 11:45 AM aSolution wrote ...

Disenroll all of the people who are trying to receive the money. They won't be eligible if they don't belong to the Nations the award was forced upon.

21661709
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, May 18 at 10:07 AM Larry Swalley wrote ...

The award settlement did not takin into account the amount and value of the Gold taken from the Black Hills. The gold was used to build the military of the Union. Thereby producing rifles and train tracks through the country. There is no amount of money that can replace what has been stolen. The settlement is a pittance compared to how much the USA has gained in luxury and wealth. Any amount is a downpayment on continued lease that should have been paid out from day 1 to the Individual membs

21656289
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, May 18 at 1:14 AM Chuck Tanner wrote ...

It's high time our government did the right thing and gave back the land to its rightful owners. I teach my kids they shouldn't steal from people and I wish my government wouldn't. The land belongs to the Sioux. It's quite clear if we're honest about it.

21644397
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

By posting a comment, user agrees to all Terms Of Use. Comments may also appear in other website locations and in other Indian Country Today products, without notice and at the discretion of Indian Country Today.

Indian Country Today and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand