Story Published:
May 9, 2009
Story Updated:
May 11, 2009
WASHINGTON – The Native American Apology Resolution is back.
Kansas Sen. Sam Brownback re-introduced the proposed legislation April 30. A companion proposal was introduced in the House by Oklahoma Rep. Dan Boren.
“The resolution seeks reconciliation and offers an official apology to Native peoples for the poor choices the federal government made in the past,” Brownback said. “I firmly believe that in order to move forward and have a true reconciliation, the federal government needs to formally apologize.”
Brownback first introduced the Apology Resolution in 2005.
“While we cannot erase the past, it is time for us to heal past wounds. We should acknowledge previous failures, express sincere regrets, and work toward establishing a brighter future for all Americans,” he said.
The resolution would extend a formal apology from the U.S. to tribal governments and Native people nationwide for its “long history of official depredations and ill conceived policies” that resulted in indigenous peoples being dispossessed of millions of acres of land, lingering poverty, and ongoing erosion of tribal sovereignty largely through the judicial branch.
The resolution was attached to the Indian Health Care Improvement Act last year, but the act has not passed yet.
“The U.S. government broke hundreds of treaties it made with Indian nations; these were government-to-government treaties ratified by the U.S. Senate,” Boren said. “The impact of many U.S. policies is the source of many of the social and economic disparities that tribes face today. It is time for our nation to face these injustices and reconcile our relations with the Native Americans.”
He said it is important for the government to acknowledge injustices “such as forced removal and painful events like the Trail of Tears. While this apology doesn’t recognize the complexity of those wrongs, it’s an important step in moving forward. From my seat on the House Natural Resources Committee, I will work with Chairman Rahall (Rep. Nick Rahall) and Senator Sam Brownback to see that it gets the attention it deserves.”
Boren described the proposal as a resolution of apology and reconciliation.
“It is a first step toward healing the wounds that have divided us for so long – a potential foundation for a new era of positive relations between tribal governments and the federal government. It is time – it is past time – for us to heal our land of division, all divisions, and bring us together as one people.”
The apology resolution does not settle any claim against the federal government or authorize any funds to be used to settle such claims, and does not resolve many challenges still facing Native peoples.
“No kidding,” a writer on www.dailyyonder.com said. “Indians are still waiting for a resolution of the Cobell action lawsuit brought over 12 years ago that seeks United States fulfillment of its trust responsibilities to Indian peoples. The mismanagement of Indian land and resource trusts dates back to 1887 according to the Cobell lawsuit.”
The Web site noted that a similar apology for Canada’s role in forcing Native people into residential schools resulted in $1.9 billion in compensation for victims.
Although Congress issued an apology in 1993 to the Hawaiian people for illegally overthrowing their government 100 years earlier and seizing land they had never ceded, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled recently that the apology bears no moral, political or legal weight in stopping the State of Hawaii from selling 1.2 million acres of the land before resolving land claims by Native Hawaiians.
Tuesday, Jun 9 at 5:55 PM Saunders Crowe wrote ...
The real definition of an "Indian Reservation" is:A tract of land retained by the American Indian that is surrouned by European Thieves,the snake tongued,and the one's who devour like pig's. Not only do American Indian's need an apology,but also a massive restitution.
23483297 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Tuesday, Jun 9 at 4:17 PM Anonymous wrote ...
Before the Europeans came ... the men hunted and fished, the women and children tended the fields and homes, we had free medical. We had it good. Maybe the Europeans should leave.
23477384 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Tuesday, Jun 2 at 4:40 PM TrackingWolfie wrote ...
scratch od means of
23097289 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Tuesday, Jun 2 at 4:39 PM TrackingWolfie wrote ...
In this clear and present danger we still fight amongst ourselves. Sadly we make very little strides towards our goal.A simple apology. Wow! As I climb this magnificent mountain I reach the pinacle of its spectral crown and open my eyes and throw out my arms and ask God how much longer must this suffering go on. I look down the loftly cliff below and a resounding wind ushers upward not long my son. The end od days are here. May God forgive us our insults and hardened hearts towards each other.
23097174 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Friday, May 29 at 9:38 PM TrackingWolfie wrote ...
Many men and women fight to this day but the truth is in their hearts. Stiffnecked and arrogant they push forward living the lie perpetuated by evil men. Where is the the understanding of love amongst us. Are we all to selfish and narrow minded. The blind leading the blind to inhumanity. Is this what God wants. You have read the truth but still fight this growing hatred. Let all Indians in. DNA test them all and give way to the real truth. Evil flouishes when good men do nothing! Truth!
22916097 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Friday, May 29 at 9:29 PM TrackingWolfie wrote ...
I have been on a vision quest and the resounding answers came to me over the Great waters. They echo through the corridors of my mind. Until an opology is made to all indians native to this Country we will never live in true peace. I was told that indian should not fight against indian but we should lift each other up. Its not because some are on roll call lists that make them indian it is because they were born indian. What is in paper if there are only lies. A treaty makes you indian.? Truth!
22915712 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Saturday, May 23 at 12:03 PM Candace Colbert Odom wrote ...
How can an apology be made if the Cobell case is still on-going? Its like stealing cookies from a bottomless cookie jar and saying "I'm sorry, with chocolate all over your face and your hand still in the jar...
22098739 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Tuesday, May 19 at 10:14 AM Walking Woman wrote ...
An apology needs to be in place. Let's start with the Cobell lawsuit long overdue! Speaking from my people from the Sand Creek and the Washita...we can forgive but not forget...something that does not happen for all. Our own government is like yours and makes divisions for the love of greed. I just pray for Maheo's blessings for our grandchildren.
21732482 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Monday, May 18 at 6:46 PM Anonymous wrote ...
To those who would say that “non-status Indians” will water-down, misuse, or not conduct themselves in a manner that is done in the right way, a good way and pleasing to the Creator, I would say then come, guide us, show us and teach us. For at some point in the future there may not be any “Federal Indians” to perpetuate and further the culture and traditions of our ancestors; and at that point We as a People will cease to exist on Turtle Island.
21685039 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Monday, May 18 at 3:00 PM Ruby E. Russell wrote ...
I feel that an apology is long over due.My Mother survived some of the cruel treatmen and punishment when she was a child in one of those BIA boarding Schools where she was not allowed to speak her native language.children were severly punished if they were caught speaking indian. today there are a lot of immigrant in this country who speak their native language in public.
21673714 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Monday, May 18 at 7:08 AM Hides-His-Pee-Pee wrote ...
Judging from the comments here, maybe we oughta just ship them all to Detroit, where education isn't as important as "being a warrior." The world left these people behind a long time ago. The Japanese, Jews, and Hawaiians all moved into the 21st century, while all Indians do is drink and hang out in their trailer parks. Stop pandering to whiners and worry about the real issues.
21648279 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Monday, May 18 at 3:36 AM Two Feathers wrote ...
Yvette Roubideaux is a true warrior. Congress has utmost respect for her. She represents the American Native Indian. It seems that we have more warriors that are women in this country. We are in a period of time that is called the End of Days. May the oppression that has been bestowed upon us, be lifted. May YHWY move that mountain that is before us. May a new day begin. Justice delayed is justice denied. May YHWY make straight what is bent and give eyes that can see and ears that can here.
21645589 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Saturday, May 16 at 11:44 PM Desatoya wrote ...
The apology and reconciliation are words in the wind and whispers of thoughts floating by the ears of those of us who continually experience the double-talk of Washington. Yes, it is a first step, but one that must be repeated until such time positive actions merge to become a serious contention regarding our treatment on Washington policies. Today is another time for our people and tomorrow surely another, especially in light of our dissipating bloodlines and the emergence of the melting pot.
21612564 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Friday, May 15 at 10:14 PM wakinyan luzanhan wrote ...
take your apologies to the pope and tell him we are sorry for living in the only true civilization and that the peace we had with the rest of creation was a mistake on our part. and that when we go to the white mans hell for not wanting to be saved we will surely discuss the reason why with all the american presidents.
21584837 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Friday, May 15 at 4:03 PM Sush Kha wrote ...
Hate begats hate. By the sound of the comments - we adults are beyond repair. Let's look at the next 4 generations and began the healing process with our children in mind. Let them have the opportunities to bring back the true traditions of our people. As we were growing up, our so call native leaders, or tribal polictians, fell us with tribal politics as usual i.e. cronyism, corruption and greed. The healing process must start somewhere. Become proactive and stop whining!
21572584 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Friday, May 15 at 12:46 PM John wrote ...
It is funny how when the word warrior is used for a white man it it is meant as a good thing. The only time the media or half you sellouts here apply warrior to mean an honorable thing to a Native person is when he or she wears a US uniform. How did it become an honorable thing for Native people to kill for those that want to apologize for perpetrating the worst holocaust the world has ever known against us?
21561207 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Friday, May 15 at 11:17 AM New Mexico Native wrote ...
Why are we still waiting for an apology? Why are we still debating and beating our heads against the wall as to why the federal gov't does not provide enough funds for our programs? We are capable in provding our own despite policies and tactics of the white man--BECAUSE our ancestors have shown us how to survive in all adverse situations. I am not here to say quit whinning, I am here to say...TAKE ACTION, Be Proacative, Mentor & encourage our people. We are a people that survive all.
21555164 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, May 14 at 8:41 PM 1/16 Cherokee wrote ...
It is true that I am half breed, but I say that the gap to be bridged must be built and completed for our people to move on and peace be in our hearts forever. I pray that this gesture is one that is genuine, and without hidden agendas. I think of our children and their children when I hear of this apology, and wonder what they may gain by it. Let us leave a mark of peace for them so they may have a better life. What is in the past cannot be undone, but the harm it left can be more easily healed
21528839 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, May 14 at 12:25 PM Willow Hunting Hill wrote ...
How, Mitakuyape. Cunte washteya napecuza pelo. What is it we see in this land we call our home? Who are our warriors who fought to protect us? How can we live on when we are stepped on by the white world? Great Spirit, where are our people? I'll tell you where we are. We are here. Where are not leaving. The people look to you and ask for guidence. Help us with the white man's drugs that kill our people. Today I ask for for all of our Red people, give us the strength to live on. Ha-ho. Me-gwitch.
21435634 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, May 14 at 11:10 AM Anonymous wrote ...
How many Natives are willing to accept the theft of 150-299 billion dollars from the Native American Trust Fund, the deliberate underfunding of Native American programs including Education and Health? and the theft of Native American lands? How many Native Americans are preaching and praying to the same anglo religions who condone and sanction the enslavement, rape, murder and genocide of Native Americans..In order to rob, steal, and plunder, their natural resources and lands for colonization.
21429812 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, May 14 at 7:15 AM Lazy Wolf wrote ...
Hey, an apology would be a good place to start, with an apology at least you know that both sides are willing to work together for improving relations with each other. We are not responsible for what our forefathers did but we can certainly apologize for their actions. It's the game of life, let's play it accordingly, where all people benefit equally.
21413834 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, May 14 at 2:11 AM TrackingWolfie wrote ...
By the way wether your on a roll call list or not no one can take away your blood and where you came from. If you are Native American then all should be honored not just those on the reservation. By the way I served this country and am retired military. It is and was an honor to serve all Americans. No one left behind so if an opology is given no one should me left out. All Native Americans should be counted no matter where they live. Be of a peaceful mind and Love.
21409304 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, May 14 at 2:03 AM TrackingWolfie wrote ...
I am here by the grace of God my ancestors made it through the Trails Of Tears. Remember the Removal Act 1832. Then President Andrew Jackson, clearly voiced his decision to send my people away from their homes in Tennessee and Georgia. As I look back at the fatal decision imposed upon my people ny heart is saddened. That dark cloud will always be in our hearts, but with resolve and bilateral commitment to start a new is always present. Step out and say your sorry. A new day begins. Peace!
21409227 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Thursday, May 14 at 1:52 AM TrackingWolfie wrote ...
It is at this very pinacle of time upon the crest of the highest wave of mercy hope and faith, but most of all love that we should as a nation come together. Yes the past haunts us and divides our profound love for one another and for some unknown reason keeps us ever separate. I agree with Two feathers in saying that the Senator Brownback and Boren are spiritually born of the same seed. To straightened the path to create the bridge that will bring us all together. God of heaven watches.
21409089 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Wednesday, May 13 at 11:35 PM LB Harjo wrote ...
To just say, We're sorry and believing that would make all thing's better, will it bring back those who lost their life and way of life for another person's cruelty and greed? Remember HOW the many million's died.I believe that history will have to be re-written and taught what really happen by the way of the truth,of Genocidal Holocaust of OUR NATION"S. The rein of Freedom of Religion be released so that we can pray in absolute Freedom and not pray according to U.S. Laws.
21406947 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Wednesday, May 13 at 6:10 PM Marianne Coats wrote ...
Certainly an apology is necessary, an act of good faith, but the People need restoration. I am a white person and I think we should give it ALL BACK! Wopida Tunkashila.
21393959 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Wednesday, May 13 at 9:55 AM tseligaii wrote ...
there is no reconciliation, till lands, water, sky, etc is returned to its rightful owner. the foreigners can practice democracy in the lands they floated in from.
21360937 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Wednesday, May 13 at 9:42 AM Pashka wrote ...
Are they going to DEBATE this? Upon returning to America, the Litvan Kosciuszko was outraged by the treatment of American Indians. After he spoke out for them in Philadelphia, he was visited by Chief Little Turtle of the Miami tribe, who brought him a tomahawk as a sign of appreciation. Kosciuszko gave the chief his eyeglasses, his jacket, and a pair of pistols and instructed the Native American leader to use these against "the first man who ever comes to subjugate you!"
21359944 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Wednesday, May 13 at 8:53 AM John wrote ...
Are you people nuts? An apology? Really? Well here's one; I am sorry you feel that way. There; all better. These people don't give a crap about us. Boren is right. This is about reconciliation. In there view, once an official apology is made, all can be forgiven. And, apparently, a whole lot of naive Indians agree. When they use their "bright future for all Americans" and "bring us together as one people", it sounds like the final stages of assimilation to me. Remove legislation, don't add more.
21356694 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Tuesday, May 12 at 1:58 PM Walter Pacheco wrote ...
The treaties were signed by our ancestors in the NW promised our health,education and housing needs would be taken care of. To this day the funds provided to tribes from the feds only allow for a minimal need to be addressed and do not fulfill the promises by the federal government. The Apology should be attached to a bill that imposes the fiscal responsibilty of the federal government to fulfill the promises made to our people. Otherwise let us get some of our lands back.
21317132 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Tuesday, May 12 at 1:34 PM ThunderChief wrote ...
The apology contains a few mistatements. First, not all Native Peoples believe in a Creator, in the sense of a christian god. Secondly, the genocide of millions or the American version of the holocaust is not mentioned directly. Third, there is an ongoing problem that the Federal goverment's claims legal title to all native lands by virture of a court decision. I do not believe a single tribe agreed to relinquish title to the US in any Treaty.
21315434 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Tuesday, May 12 at 11:41 AM little hawk wrote ...
The legislation is a baby step in the right direction. What's needed is a full apology for the genocide. That word must be emphasized. Then, extensive programs to compensate natives for all that was done violently over the centuries. Finally, just as Germany has a memorial to the victims of the holocaust, we must have a memorial in DC to commemorate the millions who were butchered for the empire's expansion.
21307719 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Tuesday, May 12 at 9:07 AM Rachel Moses wrote ...
While I commend the Congressional people who feel they owe the American Indian people an apology I would like to see this "apology" backed up by federal funding in all categories available only to recognized American Indian Tribes in this country. Funding of programs that we need, would go a lot farther in helping the American Indian's at this point than a simple apology. I believe the apology should include guarantees that these actions toward Indians will never be done again, ever.
21297212 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Monday, May 11 at 11:52 AM johnypaycut wrote ...
Very long in comming,a apologee for sins commited may be a begining.but how can you apologise for interrupting a entire civilization? i think theres so much shame it is unmentionable, and thus remains unspoken.
21254802 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Monday, May 11 at 9:25 AM WAMP1 wrote ...
FORGET APOLOGIES GIVE ME SOMETHING JUST LIKE EVERY OTHER GOOD PEOPLE A NATIONAL HOLIDAY FOR NATIVE AMERICANS THE PEOPLE ALWAYS WRONGED
21246562 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Sunday, May 10 at 1:25 AM Two Feathers wrote ...
Senator Brownback is a true warrior. A Senator who introduces a bill that is quite unpopular in Washington. To bring a bill to apologize to the American Native Indian. Our tribe has been waiting 400 years to hear this. A nation, eyes that cannot see and ears that cannot hear. All is forgiven.
21211029 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Sunday, May 10 at 12:37 AM Two Feathers wrote ...
Senator Boren is a true warrior. A Senator that wants to bring honor to the United States, to honor the Constitution. A nation that has a sports team known as the Redskins. A nation that has made apologies to the Japanese, the Philipino, the Hawaiians, the Black farmer. Perhaps, President Obama will apologize so that the world will witness what is long overdue. I would also like a bill for a national holiday for the American Indian. Is this to much to ask? Make straight what is bent.
21210412 Inappropriate? Alert Us!Add a comment
Most Popular