AP Photo/Northwest Arctic Borough via The Anchorage Daily News

In this file photo taken Sept. 11, 2006 and released by the Northwest Arctic Borough, a new sea wall that runs along the seaward side of the village of Kivalina, Alaska is shown. One of Alaska’s most eroded villages wants to revive a lawsuit that claims greenhouse gasses from oil, power and coal companies are to blame for the climate change endangering the tiny community. The city of Kivalina and a federally recognized tribe, the Alaska Native village of Kivalina, filed the case in federal court in San Francisco in 2008, but it was dismissed in October. Now they’re appealing to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, with their opening brief due March 11.

Tools

Eroding Alaska village appeals lawsuit’s dismissal

By Rachel D’Oro, Associated Press Writer

ANCHORAGE, Alaska – One of Alaska’s most eroded villages wants to revive a lawsuit that claims greenhouse gasses from oil, power and coal companies are to blame for the climate change endangering the tiny community.

The city of Kivalina and a federally recognized tribe, the Alaska Native village of Kivalina, filed the case in federal court in San Francisco in 2008, but it was dismissed in October. Now they’re appealing to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, with their opening brief due March 11.

Oil giants Exxon Mobil Corp. and BP PLC are among two dozen defendants named in the lawsuit. Representatives for the two companies declined to comment Jan. 28.

“These are matters for the courts,” said Rob Young, an Exxon spokesman. “We supported the original decision.”

Kivalina’s attorney, Matt Pawa of suburban Boston, said the plaintiffs want monetary damages to help with the estimated $400 million cost to relocate the northwest Alaska village. Residents have chosen a relocation site, an area known as Kiniktuuraq, about two miles southeast of the current location.

Kivalina is a traditional Inupiat Eskimo community of about 390 people about 625 miles (1,005 kilometers) northwest of Anchorage. It’s built on an 8-mile (13-kilometer) barrier reef between the Kivalina River and Chukchi Sea.

Sea ice historically protected the village, whose economy is based in part on salmon fishing plus subsistence hunting of whale, seal, walrus and caribou. But the ice is forming later and melting sooner because of higher temperatures, and that has left it unprotected from fall and winter storm waves and surges that pummel coastal communities.

“The village is being wiped out by global warming and needs to move urgently before it is destroyed and the residents become global warming refugees,” Pawa said. “It’s battered by winter storms and if residents don’t get some money to move, the village will cease to exist.”

In dismissing the case, the court said one of the factors in the decision hinged on the question of whether anyone could ever demonstrate the “causal effect” of global warming as an injury, according to Pawa.

“We’re appealing on the grounds the district court was incorrect,” he said.

Damage to Kivalina from global warming has been documented in official reports by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the General Accounting Office, Pawa said.

The lawsuit accuses some of the defendants of a conspiracy to mislead the public regarding the causes and consequences of climate change.

The lawsuit invokes the federal common law of public nuisance. Every entity that contributes to the pollution problem harming Kivalina is liable, according to Pawa.

The lawsuit was filed in California because that’s where many of the defendants do business.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

James Koenig said on Friday, Feb 12 at 4:12 PM

Don't ignore the affects of global warming on this eskimo village. The causes of global warming are man-made. A man-made solution can help this village by relocating it.

37511206
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Friday, Feb 12 at 4:11 PM

Don't ignore the affects of global warming on this eskimo village. The causes of global warming are man-made. A man-made solution can help this village by relocating it.

37511181
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Friday, Feb 12 at 4:11 PM

Don't ignore the affects of global warming on this eskimo village. The causes of global warming are man-made. A man-made solution can help this village by relocating it.

37511161
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

muddy navajo said on Wednesday, Feb 10 at 4:56 PM

there has to be a way to stop or hinder the intention of any company, setting out to get profit at the expense of often naive indigena. i think this can happen especially by protesting by however method. i encourage all indigena to give aid to the alaskan villages.

37385026
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

imjsbnme2@yahoo.com said on Wednesday, Feb 10 at 3:55 PM

It's called "Corporate Greed", which is the primary cause of America's problems... to include joblessness, transferring jobs out of the U.S. and, needless to say, the economy in general. "We the people" is more like "We the peons"

37380593
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

paul Lentz said on Tuesday, Feb 9 at 6:51 AM

Do these Alaskans get monetary aid for their lawsuit? Surely a tiny village cannot fight against greedy companies who have $billions available. We just have to look at other lawsuits against the big oil companies. What was said? Till hell freezes over?

37266064
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Grace NEFF said on Monday, Feb 8 at 6:32 PM

These people need help one way or another, not just a dismissal of their lawsuit. What is this world comming to?

37240914
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

By posting a comment, user agrees to all Terms Of Use. Comments may also appear in other website locations and in other Indian Country Today products, without notice and at the discretion of Indian Country Today.

Indian Country Today and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand