Story Published:
Dec 11, 2009
Story Updated:
Dec 14, 2009
PRESCOTT, Ariz. – A Sioux Nation treaty council delegation is demanding that those responsible for sweat lodge deaths at Sedona, Ariz. be held accountable and prosecuted under provisions of the Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868 because the event and its aftermath violated both the treaty and the Lakota ceremonial way of life.
“The Lakota follow traditional laws, in accordance to ancient oral history,” states a petition filed in federal District Court in Prescott by the Oglala Lakota Delegation of the Black Hills Sioux Nation Treaty Council, including delegate Floyd Hand and Ivan H. Lewis, Pima/Maricopa/Yavapai. “In adherence to these laws, oral teachings and ancient ceremonies are not abused or misused.”
The Inikaga, or purification lodge, is one of seven sacred rites “brought to the Lakota by the White Buffalo Calf Woman according to ancient oral history,” the court filing states.
Multiple non-Native people died after participating in a lodge conducted by James Arthur Ray, a self-help guru, at Angel Valley Retreat Center in early October. The deaths are under investigation.
The suit contends that the center “is culpable for allowing individuals like Ray to rent their property which offers a sweat lodge for paying participants,” according to a prepared release that alleges Ray and the center “committed fraud by impersonating Native Americans and must be held responsible for causing the deaths of the victims and serious injuries to the survivors.”
The Inikaga and other traditional rituals constitute “a way of life, not a religion,” Hand said.
“Ray is a spiritual vampire who will use whatever means necessary to turn a profit. He and others like him that profit from our culture must be held accountable for their continual fraud and desecration.
“This ceremony comes from the Lakota. We maintain our cultural identity today and people like Ray are trying to mock it as a means to acquire material possessions. They cannot hide behind the Religious Freedom Act. This is not a religion,” Hand said in the release.
Asserting that “Ray and the Angel Valley folks are a dime a dozen in Yavapai territory,” Lewis said the group “claims that they will authenticate and qualify individuals, including non-Indians, to conduct our ceremonies. Our people know who is a real healer and who isn’t. Yes, everyone is entitled to pray, but our ceremonies belong to us in our Native tongue.”
The lawsuit was filed “because (the sweat lodge) was a desecration of Oglala ways,” it was explained.
Hand said by phone Nov. 24 that he had gone to the Sedona locale to check into everything he could about the lodge but has not talked to those who participated in the event at which the deaths occurred.
Hand cited a provision of the 1868 Fort Laramie Treaty that promises to arrest and punish “bad men among the whites” or others subject to U.S. laws if they “commit any wrong” to Native people or property, and said Ray and the center violated the treaty-established peace between the U.S. and Lakota Nation.
The petition contends that Ray and the center violated laws stating that community recognition as Indian is not sufficient; rather “the person must be considered a member of a federally recognized tribe.”
In addition, those who dismantled the lodge “caused the destruction of crucial evidence in this crime scene” and should be “charged with the destruction of evidence,” the petition states.
The filing cites provisions of the U.N. Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples concerning the full ownership and protection of cultural resources, enforcement of treaties, and the submission of unresolved conflicts to international bodies. The U.S. has not ratified the Declaration.
The Lakota abide by the Treaty of 1868 and retain their rights as a sovereign nation parallel to those of the U.S. Hand said, reiterating that treaties are “the supreme law of the land” by which judges are bound.
Arizona judges should remand the case to the federal district prosecutor for action, according to the petition which does not seek monetary damages.
Saturday, Jan 9 at 3:37 PM greenriverkate wrote ...
Okay, this is a murder case that they are trying to blame Native ways for and it is junk. Sweats are in all tribes. My own husband had many before he died and he got comfort and peace from them. No charge! We are getting away from the fact, this is about money, money money and murder of the ignorant white rich people. They have the right to live but the problem is this outfit of crooks. I hold sweat as sacred and would never tell or give away information, but that is my moral upbringing.
35207041Wednesday, Dec 30 at 12:58 PM Anonymous wrote ...
I THINK THAT THE WHITE PEOPLE SHOULD STOP COPYING THE NATIVE WAYS. THE LODGE IS SCARED TO US IN SO MANY WAYS.
34619529Tuesday, Dec 29 at 6:24 PM Rufus Spear wrote ...
What about "Sweats" and other "Native ceremonies" depicted in movies; Black Cloud, Dream Keepers, and Skinz, just to name a few? Isn't that type of exploitation on par with this issue? But in this instance, it's Indians doing it for profit. How can you have a ceremony if you don't have the language? Language is a critical element of ceremonies that a tribe has sole ownership of, if they still maintain their language. Without language, people are just going through the motions, if even that.
34570076Monday, Dec 28 at 6:36 PM lengualarga wrote ...
why do white people get all tingly at the chance to copy what they find amusing about other people's cultures, packaging and marketing it, and ultimately robbing it of any semblance of spirit until it's nothing but a corny, mass produced shell of what it once was. stop it already, find your own authenticity.
34495129Monday, Dec 28 at 4:41 PM Cougar wrote ...
Also a sweat should never be purchased
34488647Monday, Dec 28 at 4:15 PM Cougar wrote ...
Sweating is older than all of us. A few years ago they where digging something up in France and found the pipe and bag of somebodies that was dated over 12,000 years ago. People have been sweating forever its not just one races way
34487044Saturday, Dec 26 at 9:45 PM Beth Robertson wrote ...
I hope this council wins. I am Navajo, Mdewakanton and Wahpeton Dakota. I live in Myrtle Beach South Carolina. In November we had a woman here selling a $175.00 per person sweat lodge. We have been inundated with these people recently and I think Myrtle Beach will be their new nuage home. They are planning some pretty big events and some of the South Carolina tribal groups are "courting " them. I wish Floyd Hand knew about his.
34387434Saturday, Dec 26 at 6:18 PM RunningElkWoman wrote ...
MOTHER EARTH You think your superior civilized man; look what you've done to these precious lands. We are not but a flea on our mother's back. How much more before she cracks. Hear her call us one and all, for if not we all will fall. You've taken advantage of these precious lands what is to come, is now at hand. © 1995 Running Elk Woman
34380886Saturday, Dec 26 at 6:17 PM RunningElkWoman wrote ...
are things I see seeking peace and living free. © 1995 Running Elk Woman
34380844Saturday, Dec 26 at 6:16 PM RunningElkWoman wrote ...
SEEKING PEACE AND LIVING FREE You think you've broken our spirit but now you must know. The clouds were dark but the sacred winds will always blow.We love and care for our mother's land. See you've forgotten you not but a grain of sand. As the tree sprouts and knows when to grow hidden from the winter’s snow. We will rise and shine these sacred things you'll never know. Like the rivers we have moved through time fast and slow. You see we have kept that sacred flow. Things I speak about are thing
34380811Saturday, Dec 26 at 6:12 PM RunningElkWoman wrote ...
The White Buffalo I hear her speak. Her words are strong, like a million Buffalo thundering along. Her words are Peace, Love, and Life No more strife and no more fight. Hear our people; we are still alive, with the sacred wisdom that lives inside. As one nation, we come alive to fulfill the dreams that live inside. © 1995 Running Elk Woman
34380684Saturday, Dec 26 at 4:15 PM l.l wrote ...
as a "dine" i see that learning the native way is a scared thing to know you have to know from the elders some of these things are so scared that prays come with it not only that special cermonies are conducted the creators we pray to listen to us i heard what happened as i said to myself it wasn't good and these pray invaded someting that is so scared that it a terrible ordeal some1 above didn't like what was going on in there that is my own opinion
34377299Friday, Dec 25 at 5:20 PM rezprincess wrote ...
floyd hand was happy to take my money and numerous others before he was removed from the minneapolis indian health board. Why does the terms pedophile and rape keep surrounding him?
34345742Friday, Dec 25 at 5:13 PM 04-2160 wrote ...
does anyone know why floyd hand went to prison and removed for years off his own reservation? Doesn't anybody do their homework?
34345624Wednesday, Dec 23 at 1:41 PM terry wrote ...
It's one thing to want to learn about your heritage, quite another to exploit that heritage for personal gain. I have always felt the need to learn about my Creek and Cherokee heritage but I would never turn around and charge people to share that knowledge. It's wrong
34233216Wednesday, Dec 23 at 12:42 PM NEZPERCE INDIAN FROM IDAHO wrote ...
STILL IS WRONG? NO MATTER HOW YOU LOOK AT IT, I'M JUST A KID AT HEART AT 75, WE NEVER HAD A NON NATIVE PERSON COME OUR SWEAT HOUSE AND TRIED TO BE A NEZPERCE AND SHOW US HOW SWEAT.SO LEAVE US ALONE? TO MANY OF OUR YOUNG ARE SELLIN US OUT FOR WHAT KIND OF MONEY THEY CAN GET. YOU CAN SEE A CITY PERSON WHO CLAIMS TO BE A NATIVE PERSON, BUT IS WILLING TO SELL OUR WAYS.I HAVE YET TO PAY FOR MY SWEAT HOUSE.
34227629Wednesday, Dec 23 at 12:31 PM Anonymous wrote ...
But you should be proud that the ignorant white man wants to follow your ways....it proves to me that it is a way of admitting they were wrong..I have Indian decent and no way to prove it, does that make me wrong for wanting to learn my culture because I know it is the right way?
34226591Tuesday, Dec 22 at 12:14 AM Minnesota Ojibwe wrote ...
Having a lodge back in the woods here. One of our teachings we have been taught, that non Indians are NOT allowed in the lodge. They were given their own place for prayer (white house with cross on top.) We were given the lodge. To cross these practices is wrong and looked what happened. I only hope someone learned from this.
34124291Monday, Dec 21 at 9:11 PM woman of law wrote ...
I'm not aware of the sweat lodge being something unique to Lakota culture, seeing as all the tribes I have worked for have practiced some form of sweat ceremony. However, white people have been exploiting Native American culture for years and it has to stop. There should be some sort of recourse for Native communities under intellectual property laws- but how the money from such a suit would be distributed is hard to determine. Many tribes would claim it, and few would actually benefit.
34115957Monday, Dec 21 at 11:54 AM nezperce person from idaho wrote ...
its wrong to try to teach,a non-native person how sweat, they don't know any of our ways and they think its great to tell others about it.
34083244Saturday, Dec 19 at 7:27 PM Anonymous wrote ...
I can see by some of these comments that we continue to devide,amongst ourselves. Well who is teaching these gurus, how many times has Floyed Hand been overseas providing "workshops" Who is authorizing the tons of books in Barnes and Noble, how to where to. If this is truley a violation of Lakota rights, then let the Lakotas come forward or is these two the only ones to speak on behalf of the Lakota. Who I understand Mr Lewis is not. Is the Yavapai,Pima,Maricopa in cluded in this treaty. Oh oh.
33994686Saturday, Dec 19 at 7:01 PM Native Man wrote ...
Well doe's Mr Hand and Mr Lewis who is not Lakota speak for the whole Lakota Nation. Where are the rest of the oyates. Reaserch needs to bedoneon other Lodges outside the Lakotas. Is there any lodge in this us done where no lakota songs or protocol is followed. Also just for referance this patition was written poorly. You need to get some legal advise Mr Lakota and Mr Every thing but.
33993709Friday, Dec 18 at 10:46 AM Terry wrote ...
I am white but with several bloodlines of Native blood, and I'm intelligent enough to know you aren't going to learn Indian ways from a white person. Until all of these idiots who pay thousands of dollars to these frauds learn and accept this you'll have these kind of people out there.
33909339Friday, Dec 18 at 10:43 AM Terry wrote ...
It may be true that saunas were used universally, but a "Sweat" was Native based and these rich white folks who think they can become "medicine men" or "medicine women" simply by attending a weekend seminar are desecrating Native American spiritual beliefs. These folks need to understand that they can't buy wisdom or respect.
33909109Thursday, Dec 17 at 10:29 PM mn old skewl wrote ...
It is no matter what others say about what belongs to the Aborigines of this continent. The spirits watch everything. They will have the final word.
33883762Thursday, Dec 17 at 1:57 PM unapologetic wrote ...
Tribes should ban the sell-out Indians by not allowing them to come back home to their communities until several years. And if they continue to sell the ceremonies to outsiders or to non-tribal members, they should be disenrolled for good. These "special-ed" type of idiots are really insecure people who do no good for the tribe. Sacred ceremony is supposed to be in their tribal language, this obviously proves they are doing it only for money. They are not to be trusted. They are SELL-OUTS.
33851779Thursday, Dec 17 at 1:27 PM Red bear wrote ...
Hello Its another bad case of insolence... sad but true. europeans didnt appear to us as humanbeing didnt really act like it either. the bloodquantum can fix all that. sort it all out. Itll make things a little easier.
33849451Thursday, Dec 17 at 1:23 PM Red Bear wrote ...
If europeans believe they were practicing something similiar to the inikaga(sweatlodge). what about columbus litter? How come when the europeans invaded they were very brutal and barbaric. If that was true you people would have never did what you did.
33849129Thursday, Dec 17 at 5:38 AM Wonderment wrote ...
Sauna-type experiences have evolved in all cold cultures, for health, cleansing, warmth, family gathering, emotional renewal. The "native way" of bringing ceremony to all of life has enhanced this activity by showing that it can be used ritually to elicit sacred experience. Floyd Hand wants to limit who is entitled to practice spiritual well-being? How was he or his tribe specifically wronged by the Ray tragedy? While Ray is responsible for what happened, it is not an Indian issue.
33826354Wednesday, Dec 16 at 5:57 PM Rufus Spear wrote ...
When you are seeking to have non-tribal institutions (Euro-American or any other foreign entity) uphold or enforce your "tribal/traditional law" you must ask yourself what you are going to do to your sovereignty? The exploitation that goes on today is ridiculous, and its most often these tribal exploiters that go out on a mission. Keep your ceremonies in house, and their protection and enforcement, otherwise there is no point in taking it into a non-Native court, they won't respect the tribes.
33799009Wednesday, Dec 16 at 2:57 PM wovokanarchy wrote ...
"This ceremony comes from the Lakota."?? Really? As far as I know the "sweat lodge" was a universal ceremony in most Indian communities in the western hemisphere. Sometimes the Lakota are so ethno-centric when it comes to displaying ''traditional" knowledge.
33784489Wednesday, Dec 16 at 1:38 PM nobody's friend wrote ...
well, there is a possible secret weapon.
33777999Wednesday, Dec 16 at 12:11 PM kinajin wrote ...
No one knows how to listen Nilakota hantas Lakoliya yo!
33772014Tuesday, Dec 15 at 3:47 PM yelia kissen wrote ...
Every nation on earth have some kind of sweat bath. Many Finnish immigrants to US and Canada still continue the old way of building the sauna first and living in that till the house gets done. These saunas were also part of old religion in Europe and the xtians persecuted them without mercy. The point is, there is no culture that has a patent on taking a sweat bath. This has to be dispensed with if there is to be any effective prosecution of a conman who got people killed.
33719417Tuesday, Dec 15 at 2:19 PM urban ndn wrote ...
doesn't everyone ever get tired of fighting we fight amongst ourselves as to how NDN we are and we fight with others because they are not, it is no wonder we are where we are, so sad.
33713034Monday, Dec 14 at 11:43 PM Wanbli Woglaka lo wrote ...
It might be a good idea to leave things alone if we aren't experts in our cultural beliefs and traditions. Leave it those who have not only practice our spiritual ways but have gained valuable information passed down from our elders and famous leaders with the likes of Sitting Bull and Crazy Horse. The "Pipe Keeper" of the Sioux should be given the authority to make determinations of what should happen in Arizona in concurrence with those people who are knowledgeable about treaties/moral laws.
33678912Monday, Dec 14 at 8:04 PM joypony wrote ...
yeh its almost too much, hey? rite at ten grand and you can be a harmonic wealthy spiritual warrior? this should be plain and clear to see for all. a plastic imitation of a peoples sacred ceremony. it is sad and disgraceful and very dis-respectful.
33669324Monday, Dec 14 at 7:34 PM J. Kills Straight wrote ...
The 1868 Ft. Laramie Treaty has been violated, desecrated, and rescinded for the past 150 years. Why does the ODBHSN want to pursue legal action now? The OST does not sanction this frivolous lawsuit. The Sioux have been ripping themselves off with the assistance of corrupt tribal council members and rampant nepotism. There are real issues 1000 times more relevant than this charade. This is what happens when non-Indian con men con the OST. J. Kills Straight Enrolled member, OST
33667927Monday, Dec 14 at 7:20 PM Dr. Alice Carroll wrote ...
Siouxing Oprah who is black for helping Ray who is white for "desecrating" the sacred inipi? Something stinks in Indian Country. I have been personally hunting and cyber-stalking these exploiters of NDN's for decades. I am the one and only official of Native Spirituality. Me and my Euro supporters will not rest until justice is done. Or until we get tired of this and move on.
33667209Monday, Dec 14 at 5:48 PM hiatsistsalagi.... wrote ...
rufus...i agree with you 100 percent....a sauna gone bad...NO one OWNS sweat lodge traditions...they are different with each/all people who use them...gifts from the CREATORS..not CREATED by man...however, plastic shamans STILL need to be stopped...
33661734Monday, Dec 14 at 5:19 PM rezzie wrote ...
Blame Kevin Kostner's "Dancing with Wolves" for bringing these fakes out of the woodwork, pretending they're better than real indins.
33659712Monday, Dec 14 at 3:33 PM Rufus Spear wrote ...
The Sioux Nation does not own the Sweat Lodge Ceremony. Pan-Indianisms may say so, but each tribe has a unique set of ceremonies based on their historical experience and geography that directly effect their cultural and spiritual laws and practices. In reality, this was not a Sweat Lodge Ceremony, it was a SAUNA GONE BAD. Why the media categorized a non-Indian event that had no ties to any tribe a NATIVE AMERICAN ceremony is grossly unjust and naive, and Natives are responding? ASSIMILATED.
33652469Monday, Dec 14 at 2:44 PM resis_tanz68 wrote ...
I agree that those who commit such facades and exploitation of our spiritual beliefs should get the book thrown at them in court. However, it is not ones right to dictate what spirituality one is allowed to believe, either. Let the fire of spirituality either humble and enlighten them, or (on it's own power) burn their *** when they ignorantly play with it! That's how one learns! Danitoh!
33649117Monday, Dec 14 at 12:46 PM Wasichu wrote ...
An interesting conundrum & hopefully the Sioux Nation is successful in bringing it to court. The Inikaga should not be used as a means to genrate capital; however, it would be a tragedy if the doors literally shut to those who are non-Indian. The Paths of the People have alot to offer the world and to limit the Inikaga to just the People will only strengthen the lies of mysticism that are perputrated by those who sell the experience of the Sweat Lodge to anyone.
33641562Sunday, Dec 13 at 9:48 PM Red Bear wrote ...
Only natives should conduct ceremonies. We need to teach our own to conduct these ceremonies. when its there time what will they have....
33611861Sunday, Dec 13 at 3:37 PM Great journalism wrote ...
I'd like to publicly thank Carol Berry for doing an excellent job with investigating and researching the topic. I've be fortunate to work with Berry and respect her for the efforts she puts for in obtaining true and correct information. Let us all pray for the judges of the U.S. so they may have the ability to think beyond "laws" of the land to know that our way of life is one all people would want to live by.
33598537Sunday, Dec 13 at 2:45 PM anonymous wrote ...
James Ray violated Sioux Nation treaty and the Lakota ceremonial way of life?? But a few sentences later there's a contradiction. Ray "committed fraud by impersonating Native Americans." Carol Berry would have done better if she interviewed Hand & Lewis, and ideally with lawyers and ask the right questions. Is it a issue with all Nations or just Sioux? Sorry, but this article makes this petition BORING.
33596659Sunday, Dec 13 at 2:02 AM PTC wrote ...
Hand and his group are misguided. By claiming authority over who will be permitted to perform Native ceremonies, they are effectively eroding the sovereignty of all Native Americans and others. Demanding that the Feds step in to enforce their “way of life”? Who do they think will then be the ultimate arbiters of their OWN ceremonies? No one owns the wind, the rain or the sweat lodge ceremony. These reactions open the door to complete subservience for all Natives in every aspect of their lives.
33577032Saturday, Dec 12 at 9:15 PM anonymous wrote ...
Also, it's the promoter's such as Oprah Winfrey who are at fault. She's never once responded to James Arthur Ray killing those people in his nuage sweats. Maybe why she decided to end her show FINALLY. Oprah, you and the plastic people you promote made way too much money off other. Please, hurry and go and don't let the door hit you in the ...
33568722Saturday, Dec 12 at 3:11 PM Celeste Strikes With A Gun wrote ...
Among our Blackfoot/Peigan Peoples, some Members freely give our ways to whites, governments, & universities. It's oppressive. It denies us free speech, self determination, and use of our own ways. White institutions have made these "sell-outs" untouchable so they can act elitist and live lies. As a result, some Members get into "pan-Indian" things while a white man purports to have transfer rights to dominate and exploit us. Due to our socio-economic conditions, we don't see the UN's role.
33557091Saturday, Dec 12 at 1:35 PM native wrote ...
This should send a message to their promoter's, such as Oprah Winfrey. Has she ever just ONCE responded to James Arthur Ray killiling those people? And I also noticed, just weeks after the deaths, she announced that she's ending her show. FINALLY. I say, Don't let the door hit you in the ***. You made too much money promoting bullcr@p
33553469Saturday, Dec 12 at 1:03 AM Chuck Crane wrote ...
I'm not a Catholic priest, and if I hired an auditorium and conducted a "Solemn Easter Tridentine High Mass" I would be perpetrating a fraud. Seems to me Ray was doing the same kind of thing. Problem of course is that not all Indians are competent to run a sweat lodge either, so some thought needs to be given to how this should be handled, and presumably will be, if the suit goes forward.
33535401Friday, Dec 11 at 5:05 PM jhk wrote ...
get that SOB, non-natives trying to be some fake-a@# native is the most irritationing thing to watch!!! especially those claiming that their great grandmomma was 1/8 cherokee!! mis-use by fake natives make us real, blood qualified natives look bad. leave the culture, tradition, ceremonies, native names, tribal membership to the real natives!!!!
33516629Friday, Dec 11 at 1:34 PM TKM wrote ...
I think the Oglala Delegation of the Black Hills Sioux Nation are right. The desecration that James Arthur Ray committed served not only to line his pockets, but also misrepresented the Sweat Lodge to the world. There are too many non-native people running around "performing" native rites claiming they are authenticated by virtue of their "medicine woman" grandmothers, or some such nonsense. This type of behavior mocks the cultural traditions of all native peoples.
33502954Add a comment
Most Popular