EPA to rebuild uranium- contaminated Navajo homes

Photos courtesy Environmental Protection Agency

This house in Red Valley, Ariz. was assessed by the Environmental Protection Agency and found to have contamination that posed increased health risks to the inhabitants. Like all the others that were demolished by the EPA, it was first evaluated by a structural engineer to determine if low impact procedures could be utilized to remove only the contamination while maintaining the structural integrity of the house during the removal procedures and following the removal.

Tools

EPA to rebuild uranium- contaminated Navajo homes

By Felicia Fonseca, Associated Press Writer

FLAGSTAFF, Ariz. – The federal government plans to spend up to $3 million a year to demolish and rebuild uranium-contaminated structures across the Navajo Nation, where Cold War-era mining of the radioactive substance left a legacy of disease and death.

This home is a replacement option the EPA provides. The log-cabin style home is from a majority Navajo-owned company. Replacement homes were based on the square footage of the original structure.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and its Navajo counterpart are focusing on homes, sheds and other buildings within a half-mile to a mile from a significant mine or waste pile. They plan to assess 500 structures over five years and rebuild those that are too badly contaminated.

“These families, with the resources they have, they would not be able to put up a new home for themselves,” said Lillie Lane, a spokeswoman for the Navajo Nation Environmental Protection Agency. “We don’t know how radiation in the home affected these families, but in the end people will be living in safe homes.”

Between the 1940s and the 1980s, millions of tons of uranium ore were mined from the 27,000-square-mile reservation that spans Arizona, New Mexico and Utah. Many Navajos, unaware of the dangers of contamination, built their homes with chunks of uranium ore and mill tailings.

The U.S. EPA estimates it will cost $250,000 to demolish each structure, haul away the debris and rebuild. The residents of contaminated homes will not be charged for the rebuilding.

“If we find more homes that are contaminated, we certainly will work to find the resources to address them,” said Clancy Tenley, associate director for tribal programs at the EPA in San Francisco.

The effort is part of a five-year plan that expires in 2012 in which a number of federal agencies joined to address uranium contamination and its effects on the Navajo people. Navajos who toiled in the mines and their dependents have suffered or died from cancer, lung and kidney disease, and other health problems caused by exposure to low levels of radiation over time.

This picture of a home in Red Valley, Ariz. was taken Jan. 14, 2008.  The house was assessed by the EPA and contamination was found in it that increased potential health risks to the inhabitants.

“There is growing confidence that each agency is stepping up to its responsibility and doing more,” said Stephen Etsitty, director of the Navajo EPA.

So far, the U.S. EPA has assessed 117 structures and demolished 27 of them. Thirteen have been or will be rebuilt, and the owners of the others received financial settlements.

Lane has done much of the outreach work, traveling to homes across the reservation to advise families of the EPA’s efforts and securing agreements to allow officials to assess structures they believe are contaminated. She said most families are cooperative, though some have rejected the assessment without reason.

Crews measure the background levels of radiation against levels in the structure. If the levels are high, families are asked to move away from the property while it is demolished and rebuilt. Arrangements are made for them to stay in hotels and for their livestock and crops to be cared for if needed, Etsitty said.

With more than 500 abandoned uranium mines across the vast reservation, EPA officials acknowledge that the issue of uranium contamination is bigger than assessing and rebuilding structures. “We might have taken care of a good piece of the problem,” Lane said, “(but) that’s just a little part.”

Navajo EPA officials worry about recontamination when it rains and contaminated soils are carried toward homes or into the drinking water supply. The caps that cover some former mining sites are eroding, and Etsitty said “we run the risk of the exposure happening again.”

Aaron Riutta, a member of the US Coast Guard - National Strike Force - Pacific Strike Team, assisted the EPA by scanning structure debris to segregate contaminated materials for proper disposal.

Tenley said that President Barack Obama is seeking $7.8 million in the 2010 federal budget to work on structures and abandoned mines on the Navajo reservation.

The project is stretching the staff at Navajo EPA thin and has forced other projects to be put on the back burner, Etsitty said. For every three U.S. EPA officials who go out in the field, two Navajo staffers must accompany them, partly to serve as interpreters.

Copyright 2009 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Monday, Jun 29 at 12:07 PM writer on mesa wrote ...

i have always wondered what has happened to the uranium and fissionable materials materials mined just up this big rock which is actually a mountain. How much money was paid? who granted the contracts? the halflife of fissionable materials makes them recyclable(sp). who will find the documents to write a healthy and meaningful history of this interesting topic, especially for literate Navajo? is there opportunity for unity here?

25131887 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jun 28 at 11:05 AM Storm Cloud wrote ...

"We don't know how radiation...affects the family...but people will be living in safe homes, so says Lillie Lane. How stupid is that? As an official federal employee it's her job to find out exactly how nuclear radiation affects people. Too many Navajos have already died. Tell the EPA to stick it, and move families to a safe area. They make geiger counters, you know. 35 yrs after mining stopped you don't know inhaling uranium dust will kill you? Get the DOE involved. They are the culprits.

25091679 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jun 25 at 6:54 PM Anonymous wrote ...

I've seen piles of destructed homes alongside roadsides with black plastic covering them. It is a ghastly sight. PROGRESS is needed!! Seriously, time freeze or what?!?!

24978299 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jun 24 at 7:24 PM Gary wrote ...

We suppose to look at this and be happy? Sad, very sad, long after the damage is done!

24916264 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jun 24 at 3:26 PM David Velarde Jr wrote ...

Too little, too late and the Republicans want us to jump on the bandwagon toward energy independence, why? From day one we always get the short end of the shaft.

24903356 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jun 24 at 2:03 PM KNOW CANCER wrote ...

Another example of U.S. imperialism and reckless development. It seems even more dangerous to rebuild and stir up the toxic dust...It would be great if the EPA could rebuild these homes on non-contaminated land; such as alotting Nation Forest land to replace the land the U.S. govenment contaminated...

24896924 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jun 24 at 11:12 AM teacher wrote ...

I recall in Las Cruces, NM, around 1985 or 86 something like 1 million dollars was allocated for a new animal shelter. Now more than 2 decades later 3 million (in Az) for rebuilding people's homes due to toxic contamination. I'm sorry but I don't think the math adds up. I wonder how much is spent on animal shelters in Arizona?

24879169 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jun 24 at 10:16 AM nobody's friend wrote ...

its been how many years since the cold war or WW2? And just now theres 3M$ for contaminated homes. Is this progress? How fast or how slow should 'progress' occur? my theory is there is a timespace warp at rez boundaries. i as indian go from 21st century to 15th century. Is there a way to make things run better, faster? Or is indian relations with US like the internal combustion engine--on its last legs?

24875059 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

By posting a comment, user agrees to all Terms Of Use. Comments may also appear in other website locations and in other Indian Country Today products, without notice and at the discretion of Indian Country Today.

Indian Country Today and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand