Review ...

Tools

Review ...

‘Mustang: The Saga of the Wild Horse in the American West,’ by Deanne Stillman

By Jack McNeel, Today correspondent

The history of the horse in the Americas goes back millions of years before humans of any color inhabited the earth. Then they disappeared from this continent, about 12,000 years ago, till reintroduction by the Spaniards in 1519. Since that time horses have had a major impact on the history of North America. Deanne Stillman, in her book “Mustang: The Saga of the Wild Horse in the American West,” tells that history from prehistoric times to the current day.

It’s not an “Indian” book, but horses have been so intertwined with Native American life over the past 400 or 500 years, depending on when a particular tribe first got them, that the history of Native peoples in North America cannot be told without referencing the importance of horses. Stillman tells of the vision that Montezuma had before Cortez arrived with the first horses, a vision that the fair-haired god Quetzalcoatl would return riding a fierce animal breathing fire. That vision essentially came to pass when Spaniards arrived on horses and quickly conquered the Aztec empire.

It was those horses, and others which followed that would expand northward and change the way of life for many Native tribes. Oral history also indicates that small pockets of horses were already here; survivors of the ice age, and later joined with those from Spain.

Stillman writes of that period, “Shortly after their return to the New World, horses swept through the deserts and plains like a fast-moving secret. They partnered up quickly with Native Americans, players taking to the script with astonishing ease. From the Apache and Comanche to the Zuni to the Hopi to the Navajo to the Ute; from the Shoshone to the Flathead, Crow, and Nez Perce; from the Arapaho to the Ponca, the Cheyenne, the Sioux, the Mandan, the Ojibwa and beyond, horses allied with tribe after tribe – perhaps not in that exact order, but the deed was done, and by the early 1700s, it was as if their kind had never disappeared from their native turf.”

She tells of particular individuals and their association with horses. Wakara, a Ute, who led “perhaps the biggest horse theft in the history of this country,” and Crazy Horse, Black Elk, and others.

Stillman writes about the Battle of the Little Bighorn and the involvement of horses during that battle. “These beleaguered four-legged troops were the great unsung heroes of that horrible firestorm in the greasy grass.” She writes about the one cavalry horse that survived, a horse named Comanche, and the horse cemetery that few know about located between Last Stand Hill and the Indian Memorial erected in 2003.

Shortly after the Indian wars, Buffalo Bill begins his Wild West spectacles and takes them around the world. He visits Europe, taking horses with him along with buffalo, longhorns, elk and deer, sharpshooters like Annie Oakley – and nearly 100 Lakota people. Black Elk was one of those who took the opportunity to see more of the world and the white man’s ways.

Stillman tells of the cattle drives and the millions of horses and cattle that were moved from Texas to markets farther north. She writes about horses made famous by the movie industry after the turn of the century and the cowboy stars with which they were associated: Tom Mix, Bill Hart, Gene Autry and others. And she also tells of the deadly abuse sometimes used in movies that resulted in the injury or death to scores of horses.

It was an event in this same vein that prompted Stillman to write “Mustang,” and what the final third of the book is about. In 1998, she heard of the massacre of 34 wild horses near Reno, Nev. Stillman had a long association with horses and these killings sparked her interest in wild horses resulting in years of research that led to the production of this book in 2008.

Two million wild horses were scattered across 17 states when the 19th century came to an end, most of those in Nevada. Today, there is an estimated 25,000 left in small remote areas in half a dozen states. She documents the cause for this drastic reduction often in vivid detail of horses rounded up and sent to slaughter houses or simply shot and left to rot. She tells of individuals and their efforts to provide legal protection for the wild mustangs, and those working to eliminate wild horses. And the controversy continues today.

It’s a book of passion about the “wind drinkers,” the mustangs, who have played a role in the history of this country.

Sunday, Nov 8 at 12:03 AM Stalemate wrote ...

How many of our readers grew-up in the West, in the mountains, near wild horses? I have seen many herds of wild horses, trained/rode a few and captured some by roundups. First, most wild horses are not mustangs-they are domestic horses in the wild. There are many breeds, while the mustang is the opposite, droopy very hearty animal. Each with its own territory,routine trails and same eating/drinking locations. Second, slaughter was common before that control manageable numbers in the wild.

31771599 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 16 at 8:35 AM Denise wrote ...

As to your comment...just maintaining balance? There is only one animal that I know of that is “out of balance” in this world…Man.

30664262 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 16 at 8:33 AM Denise wrote ...

And it is very similar to the treaty breaking, white man corporate thuggery that is parallel to the destruction of this continent’s original inhabitants. There may be over 9 million horses in the US, but they aren’t all mustangs/burros. The mustang/burro situation seemed to be just fine until special interests (mining, ag, forestry, development) decided their needs were more important than any indigenous species (let’s look at the bison and wolves as an example of stellar management). (con't)

30664148 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 16 at 8:30 AM Denise wrote ...

“nitewind”: What a truly tragic post, either bubbling from your ignorance or worse yet, your self-serving greed. You also don’t have some salient facts correct. There are less than 70000 mustangs/burros left in the US; more than half are in holding and estimated to be around 2 million in the early 1900’s and 4-5 million in centuries before. How many more we need to knock off “nitewind”???? Can you spell “extermination”? I can. (continued at post #3)

30663987 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Oct 16 at 8:27 AM Denise wrote ...

First, a thank you to Indian Country Today and Jack McNeel. Ms. Stillman’s book is worth the read, if only to remind us of history, human nature and the gift of legacy to all mankind because of the service of equines. The story of the North American mustang and burro is all that more poignant because of it’s critically intertwined history with the continent’s original Peoples. (continued)

30663827 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Oct 15 at 9:58 AM nitewind wrote ...

We get all focused on the wild horse and trying to save as many as possible. But the truth of the matter is there are over 9 million horses in American today so we are not killing off the horse population we are only trying to control the wild horse numbers. Putting it into prospective we don't try to protect wild dog packs why because we have domesticated dogs. Keeping all things in balance is what makes for a healthy world.

30612662 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Oct 15 at 7:28 AM Kathy Grant wrote ...

I use to look up to the Indians, and loved their customs & culture, but now it was like having a slap in the face....I will no longer look up to the indians who support the slaughter-houses of our American Mustangs.

30605098 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Oct 14 at 11:30 PM Annette G wrote ...

It really doesn't look good that Native Americans who are known for their reverance for life and Mother Earth are now wanting to wholesale slaughter these beautiful and intelligent animals who have given so much to their history and culture. It is truly a sell their soul for profit scenario.

30596833 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Oct 14 at 10:33 PM Barb3000 wrote ...

I think it is shameful that any of the tribes would even consider a horse slaughter plant on their land. Have they forgotten what the horse did for them? If not for horses they could not have held out so long during the Indian wars. They would have been overran and wiped out. At least they had a fighting chance. What they need to do now is give the horses a fighting chance.

30595261 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Oct 14 at 10:02 PM judithkay wrote ...

Of all the people to want to profit from the slaughter of horses, the Native American community was the last group I would have suspected would stoop so low. I agree with ellieroo: you have lost the last battle of your proud heritage and become like the greedy whites who took your land in the first place. What a shame!

30594138 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Oct 14 at 12:10 PM lee Chesterfield wrote ...

Ken Salazar should be replaced he is a lifetime rancher. Now that the senate doubled the buget for the BLM they are now going to roundup a record amount of mustangs and burros 12,000 this fiscal year. We need a moratorium on these roundups until a sustainable plan for the animals is in place. Appointing Ken Salazar to care for the mustangs and burros , is like putting a mountain lion in charge of the hen house.

30565598 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Oct 14 at 11:51 AM ellieroo wrote ...

Most people in America are so far removed from the land and its animals as to be unconsious of what it means to lose these wonderful Wind Drinkers but to have those so steeped into natures world it just brings great sorrow. In bowing down to the idea of horse slaughter for profit NAtive Americans have lost the very last battle and become white

30564493 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Oct 14 at 9:06 AM Mary wrote ...

We need to bring quality to the herds ,stop breeding **** if you have to breed why not go and buy a horse or adopt one ? Quality to quality breeding needs to be the order of the day PERSONAL RESPONSIBILITY for some reason it has eluded a whole generation.We need to grow up and stop the abuse and neglect o all animals in the USA we have the ability --stop puppymills only adopt from adoption centers and fix all pets ---we cannot afford the 36 million ayear forwildhorses that double every 4 yrs

30554682 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Oct 14 at 9:03 AM mary wrote ...

WHy not have an american stallion registry.com where we can list stallions that are vet checked and have no obvious defects,and should show they are proven and only breed to quality purebred horses to bring up the quality of our herds 100,000 still get shipped to MEX/CAN We our govt are paying 36 million a year to feed and care for mustangs that double every 4 years why are they not castrating birthcoontro should have had a V_8who is the idiot in charge birthcontrolwe need to use birthcontr

30554497 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Oct 14 at 2:58 AM rosalie delgadillo wrote ...

Who in the hell invented the slaughterhouses anyway? Lets put you in one and see how it feels

30543526 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Oct 13 at 8:08 PM mlrapelye@aol.com wrote ...

why are you so surprised at "moral disconnect" when it is, tragically, the way of our day on all levels.

30533218 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Oct 13 at 3:41 PM Uncle Rob wrote ...

Yes, all good. And if you admire the relationship between the Wind Drinkers and Native America, ask, why are some tribes now considering hosting slaughterhouses for these and other Wind Drinkers on their lands....Isn't that a moral disconnect?

30523598 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

By posting a comment, user agrees to all Terms Of Use. Comments may also appear in other website locations and in other Indian Country Today products, without notice and at the discretion of Indian Country Today.

Indian Country Today and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand