Tools

Crow coal-to-liquids plant could be boon for Montana

By The Associated Press

CROW AGENCY, Mont. (AP) – A $7 billion coal-to-liquids plant proposed for southeastern Montana’s Crow reservation promises an economic boon for the region, but must first overcome economic and political hurdles that have kept any such plant from being built in the United States.

The Many Stars plant – a partnership between the tribe and Australian-American Energy Co. – would convert the reservation’s sizable coal reserves into 50,000 barrels a day of diesel and other fuels.

State officials said Aug. 8 it represents the most valuable economic development project in Montana history.

“We’re talking about one of the most technologically advanced, sophisticated energy projects on the planet,” Gov. Brian Schweitzer said at a news conference detailing the project.

Covering the plant’s $7 billion price tag will be a challenge in the current economic slowdown. And environmental groups have pledged to step in to oppose the plant if it does not include measures to capture greenhouse gases.

Yet Australian-American Energy Chairman Allan Blood said he was 90 percent certain the Crow project would be completed.

“In my country, we have a record of people who have visions and dreams and make them happen,” he said.

Over the next several years, the company plans to sink $100 million into preliminary engineering and environmental work, with a goal of starting construction on the plant by 2012. It could begin producing fuel by 2016.

For Crow leaders, the project offers an opportunity to lift the tribe out of poverty. Up to 4,000 people would be employed during its construction. And up to 900 permanent jobs would be created with the plant and a new mine on the reservation that would supply the coal.

“Our kids will have something to look forward to,” said Tribal Chairman Carl Venne. “Not the six or seven or eight dollars an hour they are making now just to get by. You’re looking at $70,000, $80,000 – even $100,000-a-year jobs.”

But representatives of several environmental groups said they remained wary. An agreement between the tribe and Australian-American Energy calls for the Crow to commit up to 50,000 acre-feet of water annually to the project. One acre-foot is equal to nearly 326,000 gallons.

That prospect is raising flags for southeastern Montana’s ranching community, which is worried the project could deplete precious water supplies.

Also, while the tribe and company have pledged to capture 95 percent of the plant’s emissions of carbon dioxide – a main contributor to global warming – environmentalists said living up to that promise could be difficult.

Without capturing those emissions and storing the gas underground, coal-based liquid fuels can churn out significantly more greenhouse gases than conventional petroleum, according to the U.S. Department of Energy.

“[Coal-to-liquids] developers have been saying we’ll do something about carbon, but they’ve been unwilling to put it into their permits. It’s been a lot of empty promises,” said Bruce Nilles, director of the Sierra Club’s national campaign against coal plants.

Officials with Australian-American Energy said the Crow plant would be built on the assumption that Congress, in the next few years, will pass legislation compelling companies to capture carbon dioxide. Such laws do not yet exist.

Working in the project’s favor are high oil prices and the idea of replacing imported oil with homegrown fuels derived from coal. Despite a recent slide, crude prices closed above $115 a barrel on Aug. 8.

Still, industry officials said the economic downturn has reduced investors’ willingness to sink cash into large projects such as the Many Stars plant. Meanwhile, costs have soared due to rising global demand for construction materials and skilled labor.

“You have the optimum oil scenario playing out with prices skyrocketing, but you have the bottom dropping out of Wall Street,” said Corey Henry with the Coal-to-Liquids Coalition, a group funded by the mining industry. “It’s been tough sledding to try to get the money to build these plants.”

About a dozen coal-to-liquids plants are on the drawing boards in the United States. Only two such plants exist worldwide; both are in South Africa.

The biggest hurdle in the United States will be getting the first few plants built, Henry said. Once those are operational, he predicted investors would be more willing to fund similar plants.

Blood said he was not concerned, noting he initiated one coal-to-liquids project in Australia that was later sold for $5 billion. In June, he announced a second project in Australia, a $2 billion plant to convert coal into liquid fertilizer.

“You hear about the problems in the capital markets, but what people don’t hear is there are dozens and dozens of projects, hundreds of projects, being funded,” Blood said.

Wednesday, Jan 7 at 3:55 AM thompsonlewis wrote ...

CTL plant is cheaper to build than most other alternative fuel plants but more costly than a conventional oil refinery. The capital cost of CTL plants is expected to decrease through the ongoing development of technology. Here is an information that might be useful: lincenergy.us

14499019 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jan 3 at 8:02 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Hopefully the Lakota never sell out. Everyone will see what is going to happen to the Grandmother Earth. Remember, you are all in Lakota country. We are all allies of each other.

14371018 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 30 at 2:34 PM Northern Cheyenne I&E Tech wrote ...

Man,so wrong for a tribe to consider.Traditions and values do not include destroying our own land.Reading this article I can see a lot of not knowing.Employment,70Kyr,wow,It has taken me years to get close to this number.After construction,where you going to work then? Sure there is technology,do you have the knowledge to run the plant? No knowledge no job.I work in the industry over 14 years and there are other factors.CO2,chemicals,dust,insulation,flammables,what about those?

12956313 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Nov 11 at 4:36 PM Anonymous wrote ...

native americans happen to be the keepers of the land. we need to make sure that we are not polluting the water, land, air, and the animals.If we poison our environment, there is no place for us to go. we will have nothing to give to our children and their children. At the same time, we need jobs, and we need to make a living. It is a balance we have to meet head on. Once the air, water, and land are gone, where are we then?

12184818 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 10 at 3:11 AM Concerned crow Indian wrote ...

As native americans we need to be more eco friendly we proclaim that mother earth and father sky are sacred to us.But all we see is green,cnotes being put in our faces.We need to explore an eco friendly business adventures and look at all the the aspects of what this plant can and can not give us as crow indians.

12101653 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Sep 17 at 12:42 PM montana cat wrote ...

the crows got it down they are ready for the future and they understand that here on the plains it is hard to come by jobs and a real economic source for the people. we the cheyenne people are thinking of ways to get our economy running. we are almost there and we will continue to work with the state to get where we need to be. its a challege we all have to over come, the crows found there opportunity we now have to find ours.

7089649 Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 500 Characters Left

By posting a comment, user agrees to all Terms Of Use. Comments may also appear in other website locations and in other Indian Country Today products, without notice and at the discretion of Indian Country Today.

Indian Country Today and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand