Story Published:
Jun 10, 2010
Story Updated:
Jun 11, 2010
Correction: The Cape Wind project is being developed by Energy Management Inc., of Boston. In 2002 EMI bought out UPC Wind Partners’ share in Cape Wind. In 2008 UPC changed its name to First Wind Holdings, LLC.
MARTHA’S VINEYARD, Mass. – As opponents of a massive wind energy factory in Nantucket Sound watch the impact of energy giant BP’s oil blowout on the ocean and delicate ecosystems of the Louisiana coast, they are drawing parallels between the energy projects and warning that another environmental disaster is likely to happen in the waters off Cape Cod.
Opponents say that the Cape Wind project, the first offshore wind energy plant in the country, will destroy marine and avian life of the Sound, as well as cultural and historic treasures, create a hazard to public safety and cost taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars.
And despite Interior’s insistence the department abided by every required regulation in reviewing and approving the Cape Wind project, opponents continue to question procedural exceptions and the connections between Cape Wind and members of the Obama administration.
The controversial wind turbine plant proposal was approved by Interior Secretary Ken Salazar April 28, a week after the BP explosion that killed 11 men and began spewing crude oil into the Gulf of Mexico.
The approval came despite an avalanche of opposition from the Mashpee and Aquinnah Wampanoag nations, and an array of environmental groups, local, state and federal elected officials, shipping and airport authorities and federal agencies, including the National Register of Historic Places.
Cheryl Andrews-Maltais, chairwoman of the Aquinnah Wampanoag Nation on Martha’s Vineyard, said President Barack Obama’s comments during a May 27 press conference on the BP disaster reflect what the tribe has been saying all along about Cape Wind.
“Cape Wind got a no-bid sweetheart deal on the federal lands and waters of Nantucket Sound that had already been designated as a marine sanctuary and monument decades ago. They got a waiver on the open vetting process and on balancing the need versus the benefit of taking of public lands for private development and profit.”
The Cape Wind proposal includes 130 wind turbine generators towering 440 feet above water level across 24 square miles of the sound; a 66.5-mile buried submarine transmission cable system; an electric service platform with 40,000 gallons of oil; a helicopter landing pad; and two 115-kilovolt lines crossing 25 miles to the mainland power grid.
Nantucket Sound is sacred to the Wampanoag nations – the People of the First Light. The wind energy plant would obscure their view of the rising sun in ceremony and would destroy the ocean bed, which was once dry land where their ancestors lived and died.
Obama’s comments about the government’s responsibility to “reduce threats to our environment” were bitterly ironic to the Wampanoag nations.
“The construction of Cape Wind isn’t a ‘threat’ to our environment, it is an absolute certainty,” Andrews-Maltais said. “It is the total destruction of the only known submerged Paleo-Indian archeological site in existence today.”
Most painful, she said, were Obama’s comments about growing up in Hawaii “where the ocean is sacred. … (and) an integral part of who (the Hawaiians) are.”
“Why is it that the president is recognizing all of this for everyone else except for us? We feel that he is marginalizing or dismissing us as Indians, almost like we don’t have the same reverence, responsibility, culture and right to practice our religious traditions as the Hawaiians or any other federally recognized tribe,” Andrews-Maltais said.
The Federal Aviation Administration approved the project in May, reversing its earlier opinion that the wind factory is a “presumed hazard” to the 400,000 flights that cross the area annually. The approval followed Cape Wind’s agreement to provide between $1 million and $12 million to modernize a nearby radar facility to mitigate the effects of electromagnetic interference from the wind factory’s turbines.
The mitigation is akin to the untested “safety procedures” that failed on the BP oil rig, opponents said.
The measures to upgrade radar systems are “unproven theoretical mitigation,” said the Alliance to Save Nantucket Sound, which has filed two notices of intent to file suit against the Interior Department’s decision in federal district court in Washington.
“This is an entirely political decision that flies in the face of public safety and the recommendations of the pilots who use this airspace every day,” said Audra Parker, the organization’s president and CEO.
Also in May, National Grid announced that its ratepayers would purchase half of Cape Wind’s power at a premium of $442 million over the course of the 15-year agreement. The total cost of the project’s power would add $884 million to Massachusetts residential and commercial ratepayers’ bills.
Cape Wind is also depending on as much as $600 million in stimulus funds to offset the $2 billion-plus cost of constructing the plant, much of which will go to foreign countries, such as China, which manufactures the Siemens turbines that will be used for the Cape Wind project.
The Investigative Reporting Workshop found more than 80 percent of the first $1 billion in stimulus funds to wind energy companies went to foreign firms. The administration has since handed out another $1 billion, bringing the total given out to $2.1 billion with more than 79 percent going to overseas companies.
Barbara Durkin, an environmental activist who has investigated and documented the Cape Wind project for the past seven years, said Cape Wind’s approval was “based on politics, not science.”
“The Gulf disaster is a harbinger of what should be expected in Nantucket Sound by Secretary Salazar’s rubber-stamping of Cape Wind.
“The cozy relationships between MMS (Minerals Management Service) and the oil industry echo cozy relationships between the White House and the wind industry,” Durkin said, naming White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel and National Economic Council Director Lawrence H. Summers as having connections to wind energy and private equity companies.
The Cape Wind project is being developed by Energy Management Inc., of Boston. In 2002 EMI bought out UPC Wind Partners’ share in Cape Wind. In 2008 UPC changed its name to First Wind Holdings, LLC.
Former New York Sun managing editor Ira Stoll uncovered some of the political connections on his Web site, Future of Capitalism, reporting last fall that First Wind received $115 million in stimulus funds.
First Wind owners include the D.E. Shaw Group, a private equity, hedge fund and technology investment company, and Madison Dearborn Partners, a private equity firm that specializes in leveraged buyouts.
Summers held a $5.2 million a year job at the D.E. Shaw Group, and Madison Dearborn is the firm of which Emanuel said, “They’ve been not only supporters of mine, they’re friends of mine.”
Emanuel has received more than $98,000 in campaign contributions from Madison Dearborn Partners, according to www.opensecrets.org.
Asked what role, if any, Summers and Emanuel played in the process of approving the Cape Wind project, Salazar spokeswoman Kendra Barkoff said, “They had no role.”
But Emanuel and Summers were recently involved in discussions regarding the $2 billion Shepherds Flat project in Oregon, the Washington Post reported.
The Pentagon threatened to stop the Shepherds Flat project and other planned wind projects in other states, because the giant turbines could interfere with the Air Force’s radar systems. The owners, Caithness Energy, worried a delay would cause a loss of eligibility for federal stimulus funds.
“Pentagon officials have met with aides to White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel, National Economic Council Director Lawrence H. Summers and White House energy and climate change adviser Carol Browner in an effort to resolve the impasse,” the Post reported in April.
By the end of April, the heavy political fire had worked, and the Pentagon dropped its opposition, according to The Oregonian.
You have indicated this comment should be removed.
The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .
Cape Cod Warrior said on Wednesday, Jun 23 at 7:35 AM
Obama and Salazar simply say whatever his teleprompter tells them the people want to hear that day. On June 15 he swore he would protect and respect the rights and ancient ways of the Indian Nation. He then turns around and allows a private for profit wind farm developer (Cape Wind) to excavate 25 square miles of the Mashpee and Aquinnah Wampanoag sacred ancient burial grounds after his own Federal Advisory board recognized the cultural significance of Nantucket Sound and advised him to kill the project before it disturbed the buried and blocked the “People of the First Light’s” sunrise forever. Would they build an industrial wind plant on Arlington Cemetery? There is no trust and no respect from the Obama administration and Salazar when it comes to the dirty politics of clean power.
46000389WAMPIMASHPEE said on Thursday, Jun 17 at 7:49 AM
WAMPIMASHPEE IS HERE IN MASHPEE!!!!!!!
45562833Eva Mae said on Wednesday, Jun 16 at 10:17 AM
This is a sacred place. It doesn't matter which particular set of political circumstances regarding oil, wind power, government, insider groups, or environmental concerns are at play. This is a sacred place. No reason exists to justify desecrating it. This is a sacred place. Why is it so difficult to accept that the Creator creats sacred places, not construction companies? This is a sacred place.
45495433feather flight said on Tuesday, Jun 15 at 9:59 PM
Dear ??? The Mashpee already know who they are. Your words only say who YOU are.
45456488??? said on Tuesday, Jun 15 at 11:11 AM
Dear shouting Mashpee, chill lol, you do realize or obviously not, that your Tribe, which I looked and couldn't find listed anywhere in any postings of the listings of the original confederacy referenced below, but I digress, I live in the Northeast too and have read all Cedric's comments so...he can't take them back now, unless you are saying he does not speak for you, your Tribe has no interest in protecting the environment and has stated it. I read articles and notes asking where the word Mashpee even came from, you don't address that or the other Wampanoags referenced below and of course there's the most silly thing you posted...I'm Native American, have been all my decades, and decades of life, of a Federally Recognized Tribe (not 2007) as are most people who read this paper and you are in no way, as proven by the spout off nature of your comment if nothing else, the most Native Nation in the country...all other Tribes feel free to give him an education
45412774WAMP1MASHPEE said on Tuesday, Jun 15 at 10:06 AM
DEAR RUKIDDING GET A LIFE I AM MASHPEE AND VERY PROUD OF IT WE ARE FEDERAL RECOGNIZED BECAUSE WE HAVE THE BEST RECORDS AND GENELOGY IN ALL OF INDIAN COUNTRY WE CAN GO BACK OVER 9 GENERATIONS LOOK AT THE EARL REPORT MY PEOPLE ARE THERE LOOK AT EVERY THING MY LEADERS ARE TRUE TO THEIR CAUSES WHAT EVER THEY ARE FOR RECOGNITION TO THEIR OWN SELF WORTH PLEASE FEEL FREE TO COMMENT ALL YOU WANT WHEN YOU KNOW THE TRUTH ALSO COMMENT BUT YOU ARE WRONG IN SO MANY WAYS
45408004rukidding said on Monday, Jun 14 at 3:16 PM
Specialized treatment, and questionable methods...that should be addressed, for example why the Mashpee still are Federally recognized when they came in under Abramoff, etc. and the others just refused to operate that way. Complaining now about not being taken seriously as Natives (Indians come from India) is a little silly. I don't know why the Mashpee and Gay Head (Aquinnah) are the only (especially the Mashpee with their proven questionable methods of gaining Federal Recognition, read any article on the former Chairman and his deeds, quotes etc.) BTW - it is irresponsible to not disclose the fact that both of the Tribes (the only two of the 9 in the Confederacy you mention) had several members, even in their small numbers as Tribes, who disagreed that there was even such a practice as the sunrise ceremony. CNN, the DOI and Salazar himself came up to review the ceremony and they had none to show, that's why it went through. This writer needs to review those facts and more
45359993rukidding said on Monday, Jun 14 at 12:39 PM
The Mashpee leaders aren't upset with China or Southeast Asia at all, in point of fact, they are their publicly announced financial backers for a casino that they want to put on an area, a piece of land owned by the city of Fall River, MA (where they as some part of the original 9 Tribes of the Wampanoag Confederacy and is directly next to another Wampanoag Tribes' reservation, have no connection except to learn to respect their brother Tribes in the confederacy) are taking land that was, is and has been protected from development for environmental impact reasons. A law that is still on the books in MA to protect it, that their Chairman has frequently stated "isn't an issue" development is... The writer lives in the area and should do further complete, unbiased research and not just pick one tribe or Tribal leader over what the full facts are and what all the People of the First Light think and believe.
45348463feather flight said on Sunday, Jun 13 at 11:09 PM
I stand with the Wampanoag. If Secretary Salazar could participate in ceremony and witness Nantucket Sound in its sacred essence, then approve this wind farm, he is a man without a soul. Mother Earth is showing us all what she thinks of his movements.
45315724Jonathan Foxrun said on Sunday, Jun 13 at 10:38 PM
* The ECOCIDE SalaCZAR HOPES WIND WILL COVER HIS OILY TRACKS ************************ The GULF OIL TRAGEDY & CAPE WIND have a LOT IN COMMON – Alliance with Cozy KEN SALAZAR and his CORRUPT Minerals Management Services. Remind those who are now running for office, “We constituents are judging YOU by the company you keep. Are you sure it’s wise to make a pact with the ECOCIDE SalaCZAR?”
45313538molly o'malley said on Sunday, Jun 13 at 10:44 AM
The wind farm is a gift to Larry Summers, Obama's chief financial advisor. He wanted to be over the Energy Dept. , but was not allowed to. Summers was a marketing director of D E Shaw Group, which owns 42% of First Wind. He was found out and stepped down.There are many ex Enron employees in this corporation and it has huge political backing which allows them to get away with everything.Larry Summers is hated by environmentalists for dumping toxic wastes into third world countries. No friend to the environment or people.You think it is bad in Mass. Here in ME , where I live, First Wind is very strong..as it has state govt. backing.They can build wind farms now and the surrounding towns and villages cannot object. No hearings. even though property loses as much as 50% of it's value if it is located next to one of these disasters.
45288299Abena Songbird said on Friday, Jun 11 at 10:12 AM
As an Abenaki Dawnland woman, I stand with the Wampanoag .."The Cape Wind proposal includes 130 wind turbine generators towering 440 feet above water level across 24 square miles of the sound; a 66.5-mile buried submarine transmission cable system; an electric service platform with 40,000 gallons of oil; a helicopter landing pad; and two 115-kilovolt lines crossing 25 miles to the mainland power grid. Nantucket Sound is sacred to the Wampanoag nations – the People of the First Light. The wind energy plant would obscure their view of the rising sun in ceremony and would destroy the ocean bed, which was once dry land where their ancestors lived and died.
45174498NightHawk said on Friday, Jun 11 at 1:20 AM
This President is no friend to us, and just another two face like all the rest. This wind farm is a gift to China for a pay back.
45155858Use Less said on Thursday, Jun 10 at 11:42 AM
UPC, now First Wind/Deepwater, was formerly IVPC in Italy. IVPC executives have been arrested and charged with fraud in Italy for collecting subsidies on wind "farms" that produced little or nothing. Now they want to do the same here with the blessing of their political cronies.
45102933Use Less said on Thursday, Jun 10 at 11:33 AM
The Cape Wind boondoggle was approved by the same Minerals Management Service who's failure to enforce regulations on oil drilling led to the catastrophe in the Gulf. The same Minerals Management Service that was doing drugs and sleeping with members of the oil industry they were suopposedly regulating.
45102099WAMP1MASHPEE said on Thursday, Jun 10 at 9:46 AM
MOTHER EARTH IS BELLDING NOW THE STORMS ARE BREWING OFF THE COAST OF MASHPEE HURRICAN SEASON IS UPON US WHAT AND HOW WILL TURBINES SURVIVE A MASSIVE HURRICAIN OR A MASSIVE NOR'EASTERNER NO ONE KNOW LIKE THE BLOOD GUSHING FROM MOTHER EARTH HOW DO YOU FIX IT NO ONE KNOWS WHERE WILL WE GET OUR ENERGY WHEN THIS HAPPENS WE ARE GETTING ALL OF THIS SHOVED DOWN OUR THROATS AND WE HAVE NO RECOURSE BECAUSE THEBIG DADDY SAID THIS IS IS WILL GET A FIX PLAN BEFORE WE HAVE A BROKEN PROBLEM LIKE MOTHER EARTH IS TELLING US TO BACK OFF YOU TOOK ENOUGH OF ME ALREADY
45092893Add a comment
Most Popular