Photo courtesy Alliance to Protect Nantucket Sound

This simulation of the Cape Wind wind power factory in Nantucket Sound shows a view of the project from the Centerville bridge.

Tools

Salazar approves Cape Wind

Multiple lawsuits to follow

By Gale Courey Toensing

BOSTON – America’s “energy future” has trumped the most cherished sacred site of the People of the Dawn – the indigenous Wampanoags who welcomed the first European settler colonists to Turtle Island.

Interior Secretary Ken Salazar has approved the Cape Wind project, a controversial wind power factory in Nantucket Sound, despite objections from the Wampanoag nations, who consider the area sacred, and from environmentalists and federal historic preservation agencies who fear the project will devastate the Sound’s rich biodiversity, and impact dozens of significant traditional, cultural, historic and archaeological properties.

“After careful consideration of all the concerns expressed during the lengthy review and consultation process and thorough analyses of the many factors involved, I find that the public benefits weigh in favor of approving the Cape Wind project at the Horseshoe Shoal location,” Salazar said in an announcement at the State House in Boston accompanied by Massachusetts Gov. Deval Patrick, a strong supporter of the project.

“With this decision we are beginning a new direction in our nation’s energy future, ushering in America’s first offshore wind energy facility and opening a new chapter in the history of this region.” Salazar said.

His approval gives Cape Wind Associates the green light to construct a wind energy plant consisting of 130 wind turbine generators towering 440 feet above water level in a 24-square-mile area on Horseshoe Shoal in Nantucket Sound, which lies between Cape Cod, Martha’s Vineyard and Nantucket. The proposal includes plans for a 66.5-mile buried submarine transmission cable system, a centrally located electric service platform and two 115-kilovolt lines totaling 25 miles connecting to the mainland power grid.

The Mashpee Wampanoag Tribe of Cape Cod and the Wampanoag Tribe of Gay Head (Aquinnah) on Martha’s Vineyard have vigorously opposed the project. The wind energy plant would obscure their view of the rising sun in ceremony, and the Sound, which was once dry land, is where their ancestors lived and were buried. Both nations have urged the secretary to require Cape Wind to relocate the project a few miles further offshore where they would be out of sight.

Massachusetts’ Office of the State Historical Preservation Officer determined that the proposed Cape Wind site is a traditional cultural property and in early January, the National Park Service said Nantucket Sound is eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places as a significant traditional, cultural, historic and archaeological property. In early April, Advisory Council on Historic Preservation issued a seven-page report of its findings and recommendation to deny permits to Cape Wind Associates.

Salazar said he understood and respected the views of the tribes and the ACHP, but noted that as secretary of the Interior, he must balance broad, national public interest priorities in his decisions. “The need to preserve the environmental resources and rich cultural heritage of Nantucket Sound must be weighed in the balance with the importance of developing new renewable energy sources and strengthening our nation’s energy security while battling climate change and creating jobs,” Salazar said.

The Aquinnah Wampanoag Tribe has promised to file suit against the federal government’s decision. In a prepared statement, the tribe said: “We are disheartened and disappointed with Secretary Salazar’s decision to proceed with the Cape Wind project. The tribe has no choice but to explore all of its options for relief from this decision, including injunctive relief. Under the advice of counsel, no further comment will be made at this time.”

Earlier this week, the tribe announced it had retained Attorney Samantha Greendeer of Whyte, Hirschboeck Dudek S.C., to prepare for administrative and judicial relief if the project was approved. The tribe may assert claims under the Administrative Procedures Act, the National Historic Preservation Act, the National Environmental Policy Act, the American Indian Religious Freedom Act, the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act, the Archaeological Resources Protection Act, the Archaeological and Historic Preservation Act and the Endangered Species Act.

Aquinnah Wampanoag Chairwoman Cheryl Andrews-Maltais said the tribe’s decision to pursue legal recourse is not only to protect its own sacred sites and rights under federal laws, but also to help protect tribal historic sites throughout Indian country.

“We view the Interior’s actions regarding the project to be the litmus test for the promises made by President Obama to tribes – to respect and honor the government-to-government relationship between the federal government and the First Nations of these lands.”

Mashpee Wampanoag Chairman Cedric Cromwell expressed the nation’s “extreme disappointment.”

“Every state and federal preservation agency has concluded that Nantucket Sound is a place of great historical and cultural significance. We have raised these concerns about Cape Wind for more than six years, but unfortunately the consultation process mandated by federal law was not followed. While we strongly support renewable energy, and appreciate that Secretary Salazar will be reopening the government-to-government consultation, no amount of mitigation will change the fact that this is a site of great historical and cultural significance for our tribe, and is inappropriate for this project.”

The tribes are partners with the Alliance to Protect Nantucket Sound, a nonprofit environmental organization comprised of dozens of state and federal elected officials, towns, businesses and organizations. Ten notices of intent to file suit have been filed by alliance partners, including two in federal district court in Washington by the alliance itself, said Audra Parker, the organization’s president and CEO.

“We will ultimately prevail,” Parker said. “This was purely a political decision. It was a slap in the face to Native American tribes, to the Cape and island communities, and to ratepayers of Massachusetts who will have to bear the extraordinary cost of this project. It’s far from over. This decision will ultimately be made in the courts based on facts, not on politics.”

Parker denounced Salazar’s claim that he was approving the project with stringent mitigation conditions, including a reduction in the number of turbines from 170 to 130.

“The mitigation proposal is absolutely meaningless. The 130 turbines have been on the books for years. The only effective mitigation is either denial or relocation of the project to a better alternative site.”

In addition to years of possible delay because of the lawsuits, the project could still be blocked by the Federal Aviation Administration, whose approval is required to locate turbines in the Sound. Local air and water authorities strongly opposed Cape Wind and say the turbines threaten the area’s heavy air and boating traffic, including commercial fishing.

Before proceeding, Cape Wind also needs to reach an agreement to sell the power in order to secure investment for the $2 billion-plus project. The company is currently negotiating with National Grid.

 

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Jonathan Foxrun said on Tuesday, Jun 8 at 11:52 PM

**** SalaCZAR OF ECOCIDE HOPES WIND WILL COVER HIS OILY TRACKS -- Oil Spill Highlights Need For New Secretary of the Interior **** GULF OIL TRAGEDY & CAPE WIND HAVE A LOT IN COMMON -- KENNETH SALAZAR's signature AND THE CORRUPT MMS. Remember, all candidates, that we constituents are judging YOU by the company you keep. Are you sure you want to risk pictures with the salaCZAR OF ECOCIDE? He's putting a very dark stain on renewable energy, and it will be right next to your name.

44989928
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Wednesday, Jun 2 at 7:38 PM

To moonbeam 123 - Yes you have summed it up very well. That's it.

44590809
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

moonbeam123 said on Tuesday, Jun 1 at 7:41 PM

Windy, I understand why you are concerned, and so am I. I wonder if anyone has anyone considered simply moving the project to another location other than the sacred Nantucket Sound? That way, the windmills would be out of the way of the Wampanoag and the project could still go on as planned without offending anyone. It would not be resorting to the use of more carbon-producing fuels that harm the environment, yet it also would not be infringing on anyone's rights. Thank you for your time, moonbeam123

44509849
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Eva Mae said on Friday, May 7 at 8:47 AM

I totally agree. Where are they?

42754279
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Whatsnext said on Friday, May 7 at 8:00 AM

I agree that desecration of Indian sacred sites nationwide deserves more serious attention. Why aren't we hearing from First Americans for Obama about the Cape Wind decision?

42751574
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wampintheknow said on Friday, May 7 at 7:31 AM

The Mashpee tribal council is bought and paid for by casino investors, another trick of the colonizer only one the tribal council must buy into before it can work. It's just greed, Ray, which like hatred, ignorance and dishonesty comes in every color,not just white.

42750479
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Ray said on Friday, May 7 at 3:49 AM

To Wampintheknow, If you are ‘in the know’ how come you are using an old trick of the colonizers. That is, when a human right has been grossly violated, change the subject by demonizing or diminishing the victim using rumor and innuendo. Shame on you. The ongoing desecration of Indian sacred sites nationwide by government approved corporate ‘development’ deserves more serious attention.

42746822
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wampintheknow said on Thursday, May 6 at 10:55 PM

Although the Mashpee tribal council would not comment on whether the tribe made a deal for mitigation payments you can bet they did and there is little doubt that this group of people who are now a wholly owned subsidiary of the Malaysian casino investment group will continue to act in ways that bring shame to us all.

42737502
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Grateful said on Thursday, May 6 at 7:38 PM

To the one who calls him or herself god – glad you shared your discriminatory attitudes and your values. We were curious to know what you hold sacred. Thanks a bunch!

42719779
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

god said on Thursday, May 6 at 6:52 PM

Sacred? Really? The only thing sacred to indians is money, and long may she jingle!

42713964
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

To What’s Next …. said on Wednesday, May 5 at 4:15 PM

If the decision was already made by the 'powers above', that is not ‘consultation’ but some kind of deceptive and distorted policy. But you’re right about what they put before religious freedom for Indians. Everything.

42617832
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

WAMP1MASHPEE said on Wednesday, May 5 at 8:27 AM

YES INDEED US WAMPANOAGS SHOULD OF THROWN ROCKS AT THE PILGRIMS MAYBE WE WOULD OF BEEN BETTER OFF THE GREAT CREATOR SHOULD OF WARNED US OF THE GREEDY AND COLD HEATED DEVILS THAT THEY ARE YES MOTHER EARTH IS VERY UNHAPPY WITH WHAT WE ARE DOING TO HER THE SNOW,THE RAIN THE OIL COMING FROM HER LIKE BAD BLOOD THE FIRES THE BROTHER WIND BLOWS WE HAVE TOLD FOR GENERATIONS TAKE CARE OF MOTHER EARTH AND SHE WILL TAKE CARE OF YOU NOW THEY WANT BROTHER WIND TO HELP BUT ON CAPE COD THE WIND DOESN'T BLOW THAT MUCH OUT IN THE OCEAN WHAT HAPPENS WHEN WE GET A BIG NOR'EASTERNER OR A HURRICAN WHO WILL FIX THOSE WIND MILLS THEN

42580879
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

What's next? said on Wednesday, May 5 at 8:11 AM

When it became clear the Obama administration and prior administrations had not consulted with Massachusetts tribes as required by law Salazar went out and consulted and then made the decision that had already been decided from above to advance a political agenda. There is no change in the fundemental motivation of this administration not matter how they try tobprrsent themselves, power, money and personal gain before religious freedom for indians. That is what Salazar's decision said no matter how it is dressed up and no matter how many mitigation dollars are thrown at it.

42579919
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

feather flight said on Tuesday, May 4 at 11:51 PM

Dear Eva Mae, no, it doesn't matter at all except to the PR machine of "the invaders." As they keep pressing a CO2 argument in media, I keep fighting back with facts about their greenwashing and half-truths. No, nothing compares ... my heart knows this as full truth.

42568497
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

ruffruff said on Tuesday, May 4 at 4:51 PM

John, your words are proof that the environmentalist’s arguments have been successful. This is not an argument about wind power vs. fossil fuel power or any other kind of energy production. No one is balancing these windmills with drilling at Martha’s Vineyard. You are right that the Wampanoag were not considered when the colonists took over the land. However, this fight is neither stupid nor ignorant. This fight is about the legitimate human rights considerations of an Indian people and their right to practice their own beliefs at their own sacred places. No one would even think about locating a windmill in the middle of a cathedral or church or synagogue or mosque and against the wishes of the congregants. Why is that all right for an Indian sacred place just because windmills are nice? Now that’s a stupid argument.

42547479
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

WAMP1MASHPEE said on Monday, May 3 at 9:10 AM

WELL LETS BE TRUE HERE NO MATTER WHAT ANY ONE PUTS ON THIS PAGE ITS NOT THE SAME TO ME OR MY PEOPLE RENEWABLE ENERGY WE WOULDN'T NEED IT IF PEOPLE WOULD OF JUST TAKEN OUR WORDS TO THEIR HEAD YOU CAN'T MESS WITH GREAT CREATOR WE ARE ALL PAYING THE PRICE NATIVE AND PILGRIM I LOOSE MY SUN IN THE EAST AND THEY WILL HAVE TO BE ALWAYS REMEMBERED AS THE GOVERMENT THAT HAS TOLD LIES AGAIN AND TOOK FROM US POOR NATIVES SOMETHING THAT BELONGS TO EVERYONE THE GOVERMENT DOESN'T OWN THE WATER OR THE AIR THEY WERE GIVEN TO US TO OVERSEE AND TO HELP US LIVE THINK ABOUT ALL OF THIS BEFORE YOU GO TO SLEEP AT NIGHT

42447332
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

John said on Sunday, May 2 at 11:57 PM

Those that are fighting this don't give a rat's *** about the Wampanoag. The Native people are being used in this fight. All those white people didn't care what the Wampanoag thought when they butchered the land. Wind turbines will not stop the sun from rising or block it from shining in the East. Putting the Native concerns over this project out in front makes the fight look stupid and the rest of us Native people just as ignorant. The alternatives to energy production are much more of a rape to our mother than a wind farm. Tearing at her flesh to gouge coal out of her, pumping toxic fluids at ungodly pressures into her veins to access natural gas, creating radioactive waste that will invariably end up stored in or near Native lands and drilling oil out of her bowels and spilling it on land and sea make wind farming look innocent. The Wampanoag should have stopped the ships on the Eastern horizon when they had the chance, before the real damage began; 400 years ago.

42435997
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Sunday, May 2 at 8:59 PM

I think it would be good if we could move past words like ‘heartbreaking’ and ‘unfortunate’ (although they are true) and think differently. When it comes to a sacred place, not just a beautiful place, the “scar” is a human rights violation that could not occur without a discriminatory set of double standards that make Indigenous peoples “less” than some other peoples. Then we have to call the United States what it is … the most powerful country in the world that still builds its strength by violating the human rights of Indigenous peoples. Reverse Robin Hood – it continues to steal from the poor to give to the rich.

42429337
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

frenchindian said on Sunday, May 2 at 8:16 PM

It's heartbreaking and unfortunate our childrens, children will not see the world as we saw it. The rate at which the earth is being developed, is heartbreaking. Once these turbines are put in place, it will scar the beauty of the sound and the waterways, not to mention the hearts and minds of humanity.

42427887
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Eva Mae said on Sunday, May 2 at 9:24 AM

Oh feather flight, does it matter how much CO2 it takes to destroy a sacred place? Is it more acceptable if it is an ecologically sound exercise? Some call the destruction of an aspect of an Indigenous culture (such as the destruction of a sacred place, a language, a ceremony) ethnocide. Well ethnocide is a first step in genocide. Has anyone ever cared how much fuel the gas ovens burned? But you are right. We all have to stand up against this.

42400944
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

feather flight said on Saturday, May 1 at 11:55 PM

How much CO2 does it take to manufacture the wind turbines then ship them to MA? How much CO2 to dredge, dig, and decimate the sacred ground and waters of the First Light Peoples? How much proposed to be offset? Maybe 1% of proposed emissions in 2014 and only from that little place in the world. If not so terribly tragic, this project would be laughable as a "Save the Earth" jump-start. We all have to stand up against the idiocracy plaguing MA. It's like a psychopath is locking us all in the room with him.

42390124
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Justine said on Saturday, May 1 at 11:45 PM

Chucka, Mr. Salazar "appears" to have been working on cleaning up the oil spill today, too, as he wore a demin shirt and ball cap for his press conference. Like a real working man. He's a real working politician -- and on that you should have faith. Just saying.

42389709
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Skinwalker said on Saturday, May 1 at 10:34 PM

"Approve" What's that america is done approved any thing fast,quick,and failed. We will out live "them" not needing approve.

42387589
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

native said on Saturday, May 1 at 8:50 PM

I AGREE WITH THE CONCERNED LAKOTA,UNITED TRIBES UNITY FOR INDIGENOUS TRIBAL RIGHTS.IF THE WAMPANOAG TRIBE WOULD PURSUE IT WITH TRIBAL LAWYERS,TO PRESENT THEIR CASE TO THE U N HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION.WHAT DOES THE TRIBAL COUNCIL SAY ABOUT THIS.ONLY A VERBAL DISENT?THIS IS SACRED LANDS.WHAT ABOUT ENVIRONEMENTAL ISSUES,HEALTH ISSUES,DESECRATION OF SACRED TRIBAL RESERVATION LANDS.AND ARCHEOLOGICAL SITE.I`M SURE THERE ARE US GOVERNMENT LAWS ON TRIBAL SACRED SITES AND ARCHEOLOGICAL SITES.DOES THE TREATY INCLUDE THE CAPE AREA?IT SHOULD IF IT`S PART OF THE TRIBAL RESERVATION AREA.IF NOT INCLUDED WHY NOT?

42384194
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

native said on Saturday, May 1 at 8:12 PM

i agree with anonymous wrote on 4/28/10.add disrespect broken treaties,over 200 years of it.

42383079
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Saturday, May 1 at 5:33 PM

To Chucka. The Secretary of the Interior would have to earn my confidence, which he certainly cannot do if he violates the human rights of the Wampanoag by allowing a corporation to desecrate their sacred space. He, like many before him and many who will follow, has decided that its better for the future of the ‘nation’ to stomp on the human rights of an Indian nation. More expedient so to say. Something HAS gone wrong. The Secretary of the Interior has become a human rights violator. But as you say, he appears to be a man of honor and integrity. To whom?

42378479
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Chucka said on Saturday, May 1 at 3:05 PM

It seems to me that more confidence should be placed with the Secretary of Interior. He appears to be a man of honor and integrity, so maybe, he investigated the case thoroughly and decided that it's best for the future of this nation to accept the turbine design. But he'll own it if something goes wrong.

42374097
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Kinajin said on Friday, Apr 30 at 12:34 PM

So it's the Wampanoags who let these guys in huh! Heck by the time We Lakota were burning wagon trains it was too late. LOL

42313919
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Friday, Apr 30 at 9:18 AM

In one article, Salazar says this is the final decision of the United States. No it isn't. It is the final decision of Ken Salazar and his non-Indian buddies. Just because non-Indian people do not understand that a sacred place made by the Creator is just as sacred as a cathedral or a synagogue or a mosque does not mean that it is up for destruction! Shame on Ken Salazar and on the United States for this gross violation of human rights (ICCPR, Article 27 to which the U.S. is a party by its own choice.) This is a legally binding treaty.

42298194
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

DD said on Thursday, Apr 29 at 8:39 PM

Someone should look at the fact that these wind farms or solar panel farms are not economically viable without government forcing increases in utility cost to provide subsidies to the companies who build these systems. This is big business and the government deception at it again.

42271672
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Irish Eyes Are Crying said on Thursday, Apr 29 at 8:23 PM

So much for Obama's promises to Ted Kennedy, too.

42270857
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Get Up Stand Up said on Thursday, Apr 29 at 8:15 PM

“I don’t know the cost of the project, but I know it will be subsidized, but not sure by how much.” Secretary Salazar, Cape Wind Costs, 4/29/10. “You need to ask the developer . . . I am not being cute with you. You need to ask the developer.” MA Governor Patrick, Cape Wind costs, 4/29/10. "We have no comment on the project’s costs." Developer Jim Gordon, Cape Wind costs. 4/29/10. "The only reason why the project would ever go ahead, aside from the complicity of gullible public officials, is the billion dollars or so in subsidies that the developers stand to gain if it does." David G. Tuerck, professor of economics at Suffolk University in Boston, 4/06/10.

42270504
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Vargric said on Thursday, Apr 29 at 5:30 PM

Agrees whole heartedly with Concerned Lakota. Its time for the Nations to put aside their differences and work as One People with many voices.

42261292
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Eva Mae said on Thursday, Apr 29 at 2:33 PM

Sailor you ask “how long will the Indians complain.” Are you kidding? If your places of worship were being destroyed by the Federal Government just because they could, would you be silent? Really? The same week this same government claims that they will reconsider the recognition of your human rights? That’s how long we will ‘complain’. As long as the two-face creatures play in the meadow with human rights violations.

42247839
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Dakota said on Thursday, Apr 29 at 2:05 PM

Don't ya'all have nor easters (?) there also? and if or when they get built...the sea will claim them because not much survives the sea salt. Sounds like quite a hot topic there and I just want to say that I side with you that oppose this stupid idea! who will eventually pay the costs for these!?..hmmmm! I think ya'all know the answer to that one.

42245357
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sailor said on Thursday, Apr 29 at 1:50 PM

How long will the Indians complain? The Roman Army slayed my ancestors too. These poles just look bad and they are a marine hazard for sailors and spoil the seascape. It would have been better to put them out 100 miles off shore

42244127
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

great basin said on Thursday, Apr 29 at 1:32 PM

Isn't Salazar a politician from the West? I think Colorado. A real shame. Americans should not think of enery use as a luxury.

42242514
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Thursday, Apr 29 at 12:38 PM

To M. They never have and they are not listening now.

42237584
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

M. said on Thursday, Apr 29 at 11:38 AM

A few miles upshore and the government couldn't manage. Don't think our government listens to our concerns much anymore.

42231697
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Ray said on Thursday, Apr 29 at 9:42 AM

One by one the sacred places are destroyed or desecrated by the representatives of the majority, for the 'good' of the majority. If this were to happen to any other set of beliefs, all America would be outraged. This is racism. This is discrimination. This is 2010.

42221602
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

concerned lakota said on Thursday, Apr 29 at 9:17 AM

they could have chosen many other places to put up that wind farm...seems to me that they also wanted to send a message to indian country at the same time...when are we going to join together as one nation istead of individual tribes...

42219782
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Kinew said on Thursday, Apr 29 at 6:12 AM

The only sacred entity to the U.S. govt. is a corporation, in this case an energy one. To them the San Francisco peaks, Bear Butte the Black Hills and many others are not sacred. Hell not even the water these turbines will sit in recieves that respect. I'll still do sunrise ceremony though.

42211147
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

WampWoman said on Wednesday, Apr 28 at 10:21 PM

Mashpee should join Aquinnah and sue based on indigenous property rights. We have nothing to loose. the state of Massachusetts hates Wampanoags anyway. Lets make the ancestors proud of for fighting what we are bound by Spirit to protect.

42197984
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

feather flight said on Wednesday, Apr 28 at 7:53 PM

Dearest Eastern Friends, many good thoughts surround you. Take heart in this truth - such silliness makes for much bungling. Doesn't bode well when it takes real work to get a job done. Someone might break a fingernail. P.S. Who is running against Deval Patrick?

42190657
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

virginia said on Wednesday, Apr 28 at 7:49 PM

Mr Salazar made a decision even after listening to the comments by ACHP,NRHP,USNPS,Wampanoag People. Mr Salazar I have one question for you "How do you sleep at night?"

42190449
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Concerned Chumash said on Wednesday, Apr 28 at 6:23 PM

I hope that the Wampanoag tribe does not give up, just because one man has said so.This is just another example of the attitude that this country has for the history the indigenous people of this land. Oh, my bad, the history of this land only begin a few centuries ago.

42185709
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Candace Colbert Odom said on Wednesday, Apr 28 at 5:11 PM

I watched a PBS deal and this man said he put up windmills on his land but it is so noisy that it sounds like a jet airplane taking off in his backyard! He said it is hard to sleep when the turbines are going at night... He said if he had it to do all over he would not have put them up.

42179749
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

WAMP1MASHPPE said on Wednesday, Apr 28 at 4:35 PM

MAY THE GREAT CREATOR WATCH OVER US WE HAVE LOST THE SUN RISING IN THE EAST ALONG WITH EVERY THING ELSE THE GREAT CREATOR GAVE US TO WATCH OVER 50 OR 100 YEARS FROM NOW THEY WILL WANT TO KNOW WHAT WENT WRONG WITH THIS GOOD EARTH IT WENT UP IN THE WIND

42176729
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Eva Mae said on Wednesday, Apr 28 at 4:05 PM

Just another example of colonialism. Kill the Indian, steal their lands and resources, and then when they are in the minority, only then enforce the will of the majority to do whatever they please. Good play Bozo.

42174212
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

To Windy said on Wednesday, Apr 28 at 3:55 PM

Alternative energy is OBVIOUSLY a main priority and wind energy is an excellent movement towards our energy independence. BUT, negotiation and suggestion was made for the different geographical placement to make all sides happy, no? Of course, they [corporate] also fail to make the public aware of the negative effects. The detrimental and hazardous effects on wildlife, and even humans (inner ear, for those living close enough) because of the turbines and the sound waves put off. It's everyone's responsibility to do their research before joining the bandwagon or supporting whichever cause. Here, "man" is again using and abusing the earth, at any length possible and no matter who gets stepped on, to sustain their selfish, indulgent ways.

42173359
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Wednesday, Apr 28 at 3:44 PM

This action reveals that the United States government and the Department of Interior in particular still have no respect for the 'religious' practices of the Indigenous peoples within its boundaries.Their talk about respect for human rights rings hollow, and they still choose to steamroller the human rights of Indigenous peoples in the name of progress. May they all get uncontrollable cases of acne so that they are recognizable from a distance.

42172357
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Windy said on Wednesday, Apr 28 at 3:23 PM

When you choose NOT to build wind power, you are choosing the other things that are currently being built such as coal. Which will do worse to damage the area long term? Coal or even natural gas through global warming.

42170742
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Free Man said on Wednesday, Apr 28 at 1:34 PM

Is anyone surprised what this man called Salazar has decided? It should be obvious by now that he is one of the worst interior secretaries since James Watt. He will decide what is best for the business interests only without regard to anyone or anything else.

42162129
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

By posting a comment, user agrees to all Terms Of Use. Comments may also appear in other website locations and in other Indian Country Today products, without notice and at the discretion of Indian Country Today.

Indian Country Today and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand