Photo courtesy Shadi Rahimi

Nov. 26 was a celebration of the 40th Anniversary of the Occupation of Alcatraz – a day when a group of Natives took a leap into history.

Tools

Thousands celebrate 40th anniversary of Alcatraz occupation

By Shadi Rahimi, Today correspondent

SAN FRANCISCO – It began and ended like any other prayerful sunrise ceremony on Alcatraz Island. Crowds bundled in layers of clothing huddled onto ferries. Drummers sang as the boats took turns floating more than 3,500 people across icy waters. Dancers pounded bare feet across the cool floor of the island turned prison turned museum.

But this year, memories of the youthful spirit that painted in red the declaration “Indians Welcome; Indian Land” around the island’s United States Penitentiary sign took precedence. This sunrise ceremony on Un-Thanksgiving Day was a celebration of the 40th Anniversary of the Occupation of Alcatraz – a day when a group of Natives took a leap into history.

The paint remains, but few could personally recall Nov. 20, 1969, when 79 Natives landed to reclaim the island under a loose interpretation of a treaty that dictated the return of unused federal land to the Natives from whom it was acquired. And few could remember a time when physical and armed confrontation, and the loss of lives, was almost a required part of the civil rights struggle for Natives.

Click here to view a photo slideshow of the 40th Anniversary of the Occupation of Alcatraz


For those who could, the day was a powerful reminder.

“Alcatraz was to put your life on the line, it was a struggle; it was a sacrifice. We were ridiculed and put down but we didn’t care because we knew we were right,” said Lakota Harden, 52, Minnecoujou-Yankton Lakota and HoChunk. “We knew what we were doing was powerful. This taught us all not to give up.”

Harden was 12 and in boarding school at the time of the occupation, which was a successful third attempt after the two others lead by Native San Francisco State students and a small group of Sioux. It lasted 19 months and along with a forceful wave of American Indian activism that followed influenced the federal government’s decision to end its policy of termination and pass the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act of 1975.

Harden was a young representative of the American Indian Movement’s “We Will Remember” Survival School on the Pine Ridge Reservation, which was established out of the 1973 Wounded Knee occupation. She has since worked with organizations including the International Indian Treaty Council, Women of All Red Nations and the Black Hills Alliance, and was the ceremony emcee.

Her cousin and aunt joined the Alcatraz occupiers in 1969, and Harden could remember a time on the reservation when it was “powerful to look Indian, with long hair and braids, jeans and AIM symbols. You could get shot at.

“This was the birthplace of everything – after this, everything changed.”

For J.R. Laiwa, a California Pomo and Wailaki who joined the Alcatraz occupiers in his 20s, the island was a place of personal change. He had returned from serving in a war he opposed in Vietnam and was haunted by the realization that Natives faced similar circumstances to the Vietnamese under U.S. military occupation.

“I look back and have a lot of happy memories of being here. But I don’t think of it as a legacy; I see it as a beginning. We still have to ask for everything, we still have to beg for everything. I walk the streets and I don’t see more than one indigenous person. We still have to struggle.”

That sentiment was echoed by the honored speakers – Bill Means, IITC founder and U.N. Working Group on Indigenous Populations co-founder, and Clyde Bellecourt, one of the AIM founders and a participant in the occupations of Wounded Knee and a BIA building in 1972.

Bellecourt mentioned the excitement felt across the world when President Obama took office, and his own warning to “be vigilant and watchful. We’ve had promises before.” He watched as industries and Wall Street were bailed out, while Native people continue to wait for what is theirs to be returned.

In his talk, Means referred to the struggles of indigenous people south of the U.S. border and repeated several times to loud cheers, “There are no immigrants, only migrants.”

Means said there is a worldwide indigenous movement that is 375 million strong. But “we have to reignite the flame,” sparked by Alcatraz.

Monday, Dec 28 at 5:28 PM Dreamsthunder wrote ...

So much anger, so much hate, so much fear...a moment of quiet thought would be nice...a little unity would be better.

34494622
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Dec 8 at 8:07 PM then how come? wrote ...

i'm always standing in line..im a vet and i didn't see any of these migrants in my vacinity layin it all on the line. now its too the back of the line everytime i need a job. They kick us out as they get treated better than us natives. it gets old and cold really quick. as alcatraz...who cares as a new flood of immigrants are the new alcatraz!

33336771
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Dec 8 at 1:24 PM Oakland Wicasa wrote ...

I was there on Alcatraz that sunrise 40th Anniversary. As a Lakota growing up in Rapid City and moving around alot and being here in Oakland the last few months - I felt proud to be Indigenous with the few hundred Natives and the majority of white attendees/suporters to the cause. Whether you agree or disagree of this event and the news story article - we as Natives must not forget the history and civil rights that evolved from the Alcatraz occupation. Teach your children! Hoka Hey!

33311194
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Dec 4 at 5:07 PM Lakota Men wrote ...

Dennis Banks is a laugh, he thinks he is a ojibwe warrior, ha!! clyde Belcourt is onlye there when there is money involved, they sold us out on the first longest walk, they were paid by the U.S. government to leave, we had to make it back on our own, we are all doing our own for our people. we are educated, run our own organizations these monkeys got to go and you are wasting your time writing about them.

33115621
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Dec 2 at 9:37 AM Scott wrote ...

When the Condor flies with the Eagle, great change will come. This is symbolic of north american natives realizing their relations across the continent (and vice versa). Euro definition of who Aztec were prior to colonization can't be trusted.Euro had church supported dungeons for all kinds of torture. Paintings of peppers, we are told arebloody human hearts. Discover the Aztec yourselves. Pepper farmers

32959414
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Dec 2 at 12:39 AM lightning wrote ...

I think the beginning of the indian civil rights movement is more likely to be the fish ins at Wash State in the early 60s. They used civil disobedience and enlisted celebrities in their cause. They went to jail for their beliefs, went to court to argue the treaty rights and then got a supreme court decision recognizing their rights to fish. I think Banks claims that one too.

32946674
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Dec 2 at 12:21 AM Bright Red UNA "Indian Power" Buttons wrote ...

James M. Fortier & Troy R. Johnson Are Much To Blame For Their So Called "well-researched" Documentary Titled Alcatraz is Not an Island. They Failed To Acknowledge The Picture's of UNA Members Clearly Wearing Their Bright Red "Indian Power" Buttons. They obviously Failed To Do Any Research Into Which Militant Indian Organization Had Their Members Present From Day One to The End of The Alcatraz Take Over.

32946299
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Dec 2 at 12:03 AM The Events That Lead Up To Alcatraz wrote ...

Alcatraz Was Not The Start of The Civil Rights Movement For Native American People. Here It Is. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Wd1uLgV7mc Part One. October 9th 1969 "Indian's Are BECOMING Militant"

32945701
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Dec 1 at 8:42 PM Video Evidence of UNA's Claim wrote ...

Video Evidence Showing UNA Members Denis Turner & LaNada War Jack From Day One Of The Alcatraz Take Over. Occupation of Alcatraz Island: Day 1 http://diva.sfsu.edu/bundles/187779 Show Us Some Picture's of AIM Members Whom Were There From Day One??

32937824
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Dec 1 at 11:43 AM mesa jump wrote ...

unity among indigenous peoples is necessary if indigenous peoples are ever to win their place in the sun. acceptance of all dance groups is necessary. indigenous unity is necessary.

32906014
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Dec 1 at 2:12 AM victoria wrote ...

Why is so important to undermine the commitments that were made for the best intrest of the people-many have died and sacrifed their lives or wellbeing for us to have the ability to have the rights we have...we all are in the same struggle...this was a ceremony for healing, empowering one another and honoring those ancestors.

32887191
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 30 at 11:07 PM Brock Conway wrote ...

Bravo! Bravo! Mino Anokhin Anishinabewi!

32881821
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 30 at 8:16 PM igmuska wrote ...

it seems like every time someone like Quanah steps up; there are many talking crazy about what they've did. Change takes time. AIM proved this, that it is easy to forget where you came from, so how about facing where we are going and I emphasize WE, not the token Injuns and their wasicu masters.

32875326
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 30 at 11:39 AM Yvonne L. Swan wrote ...

I went once again to the ceremony at Alcatraz to pray. In my mind I back to the day of Creation and imagined how pure and peaceful it was on earth. I felt the love that governed our minds and hearts and the warmth in our relationship to all life. I felt the spirit of the Ohlone, the prisoners, the people on relocation, and all people on earth and I began to cry. I prayed harder. I watched the bare feet dancing in prayer to the drumbeat and welcomed the strength it gave me. I will not forget.

32848539
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 30 at 11:39 AM High Prophet wrote ...

Nahuatl, these are the people that came as friends, betrayed, and took everything the TOLTEC had, sound familiar. this dude could have used two shells or even a conch, but he used a yuban coffee can to give blessing to the " I AM". there is probably a reason why the gov. lets you do your thing where no one can see you. there's a big old land over here that needs lots of healing and alot more righteous people to respect and honor.AMERICAS

32848514
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 30 at 3:11 AM Read This wrote ...

A Letter From Dr. LaNada War Jack aka LaNada Means-One of Leaders of The Alcatraz Take Over http://blogs.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=blog.ListAll

32834181
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Nov 30 at 12:06 AM CHUCK wrote ...

True Again,I and brother-in-law both 29 year olds. we went over and spent 2 hours there. we walked the area and went below into the pitch black area where they put the bad guys. Anyway,we never met or shook hands with no one. That's the good old ways. Ignore each other.

32830211
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 29 at 10:54 PM Anonymous wrote ...

I lived in the Bay area for 7 years and never went to the sunrise gatherings - I wanted too. But it wasn't a big deal to me. As far as I'm concern these folks that went there went for a reason to honor those that occuppied the island and offer prayers to all indegineous people. Nothing more nothing less...so get over it.

32828142
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 29 at 10:13 PM Cuauhtli Xochitl wrote ...

Hey My Land, why hide your Identity? Talk big shit but too much of a coward to share who you are? I am an Aztec dancer and my skin is probably more RED than yours. I am proud of WHO I AM AND I KNOW WHERE MY PEOPLE COME FROM! Traditional you are asking for? Our dances are hundreds of years old. Get educated before you go opening up your mouth, I mean type.

32826871
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 29 at 9:41 PM toasty wrote ...

Sure there were many at Alcatraz but the people taking front and center at these celebrations WERE NOT THERE. Clyde wasn't there. Bill wasn't there. The treaty council wasn't there. What's more is that Clyde and Co used to play down the Alcatraz occupation, the Fish ins and every other native act of resistance. Now, 40 years later they all want to grandstand on the occupation they weren't a part of. I'm sure the Treaty Council will claim it in another grant.

32825824
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 29 at 9:20 PM Chichimeca/Yo'emem presente wrote ...

There was more than one origination, more than one group of students and more than one family present at the start of this historic event. Those individuals should also receive recognition and credit in the history books.

32825156
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 29 at 9:19 PM Chichimeca/Yo'emem presente wrote ...

Divide and conquer, that is all I see on these post. Who dares speak of another nation not being indigenous just because they are from the other side of the boarder that the white man put up? You are just as white and ignorant as your oppressor. How many of us are full blood? Unfortunately, very little. As far as who was there during the occupation; where any of the original occupiers from day one to the very end present on this day and invited to speak and share the entire story?

32825124
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 29 at 8:08 PM AIM Sucks wrote ...

How Come We NEVER HEAR ANYTHING ABOUT ANY AIM Protests or Actions Out On Their Home Minneapolis, MN? They Allow a Philippine to Run Their So Called International Treaty Council that Has Been Accused of Smuggling DRUGS Into America For Year's. . . Learn Whom You Are Backing, Before You Open Your Heart to These Crooks http://www.coloradoaim.org/history/1994chargesagainstbellecourts1.htm

32822454
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 29 at 6:55 PM Kayla wrote ...

Nice photos Shadi. Keep up the good work. As a Cali native woman, thanks for following protocol and not photographing the Cali natives in regalia that don't want to be photographed. Anyone with a brain would understand that's being respectful of their wishes. Lots of us have been burned before on that. A las Aztecas y otras gentes indígenas - let the haters hate and work out their own identity issues... We've got loads of them as colonized peoples, no exceptions. ¡Viva la indigena! =)

32820061
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 29 at 3:25 PM A reply to Sister wrote ...

It's funny you should mention that about Quanah! He's always on this hate tone about who should get credit and talking negative about other groups and other people. As much as he and other people hate others like Russell Means, the bottom line is Quanah and his pops combined have not come close to the work Russell Means has done and they never will come close. You know you're doing something right when people hate on you and he and his dad hate Russell Means.

32813289
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 29 at 3:17 PM Anonymous wrote ...

Why do those rediculous aztec dancers always have to show up at any Bay area event? They don't even know their own history. Anybody can be an aztec dancer, as long as you can dance and have a little color (even though I did see a blondie dancing at DQ). I want to see more traditional natives out there that know their culture and history.

32813056
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 29 at 3:16 PM My Land wrote ...

Why do those rediculous aztec dancers always have to show up at any Bay area event? They don't even know their own history. Anybody can be an aztec dancer, as long as you can dance and have a little color (even though I did see a blondie dancing at DQ). I want to see more traditional people.

32813016
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 29 at 3:14 PM Xicano wrote ...

I know it is important to take pride in your roots but whats up with all the I am more Native than you stuff (suggesting I am better than you!). Self worth does not equate what percentage native you are.What really brings us down as a people of color is our lack to find common ground and work together and support eachother. We should find strenght in our united voices not our individual self-ritious ones!This is the only way we will have the power to create true change!

32812979
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 29 at 3:20 AM Dianna wrote ...

Alright Shadi! Nice work!

32796289
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 29 at 3:12 AM JBG wrote ...

Wonder if Bellecourt and Bill Means remembered the sacrifice of other "warriors" in the struggle, like say, Anna Mae Aquash? No? Must have slipped their indictments...oh, I mean slipped their guilty minds.

32796239
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Nov 29 at 2:07 AM apes44 wrote ...

To attach Shadi Rahimi for writing a story that doesn't match YOUR story Brightman, shows how BRIGHT you really are. That's whats wrong with natives like yourself. EGO always wanting to be the center of attention to take all the credit. You didn't add that there were SFSU Students not just Berkeley students. And how do you have ownership over these Berkeley to say your students? People appreciate the work you put in but don't try and take all the credit cuz you were not alone. Wise up elder!

32795344
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Nov 28 at 6:53 PM brothers wrote ...

I've never met the Brightmans and I dont live in cali. Over the years I have met a bunch of people who were at Alcatraz and have heard their stories about why they were there and what it meant to them. I have nothing but respect for them but I don't respect opportunists latching onto their sacrifice. The same has happened here in the plains. I am putting this out there because others have been saying the same thing and the opportunists should know that they don't fool all of us.

32784409
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Nov 28 at 3:43 PM Xotzinomecihuatl wrote ...

Piyalli ihuan tlazcamatl mitotianis ! I wasn't there so I have nothing to say about the acual event other than thank you! TIUAHUI To ALL NATIONS who stand and fight for the rights of all people ! Oh and as "Azteca" We are what we are eh? Not a single one of chose to be mixed and we are Indigenous to this continent just like you only our people make it a point to do our best to not ever speak to anyone the way you've just spoken here. Paz fe y harmonia! Ceremonies are for healing ALL!

32780177
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Nov 28 at 2:54 PM Mitotiani wrote ...

Spanish/Mexicans,compared to what? Native/English? So the Aztec impersonators dont look anything like the nahuatl speaking peoples of central mexico who happen to be among the most numerous indigenous language speaking peoples of mexico? Just that population is greater than those in ALL the plains who speak their language put together. Even after almost 500 years of pillage in mexico.You think “Mexicans”Lost their language and their nativish looks by choice?we're still vulnerably divided.

32779221
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Nov 28 at 1:26 PM Quanah Parker Brightman wrote ...

If You Don't Know What UNA Has Accomplished Since Our Birth Back in 1968 In SF CA. Then Were Have You Been?

32777269
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Nov 28 at 1:12 PM haha wrote ...

Quanah Parker Brightman your comments are so self serving and angry...what do you want from us???to give you thanksgiving???you werent there and you need to humble yourself

32776884
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Nov 28 at 12:33 PM Jaime wrote ...

Tau, Tainoti Guatiao...I am Taino Jibaro Boricua of the Greater Antilles and this is one of the reasons that I do not participate in ceremonial activities in the states as much as I want to and would love to do. It's all due to the "who's that person, he/she doesn't look indian" attitude...instead of accepting people for who they are whether they have a moustache or not, or balding hairline, or not, if their skin colour is lighter or not...it's stupid and plain ignorance that destroys Unity.

32775917
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Nov 28 at 12:29 PM If you weren't there wrote ...

Quanah it is people like you who attack your own communities organizing efforts and don't respect the work of others that causes such devision. When have you been willing to come together in an organized effort for events such as this to happen? Where has UNA been these past 20 years? What work have they done to serve the community? Have they reached out to work with the other bay area organizations? Keep complaining and be unwilling to work together. It will get you far in life andforourpeople

32775829
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Nov 28 at 12:23 PM If you weren't there wrote ...

LISTEN TO THE BROADCAST! PRAYERS and OFFERINGS WERE NOT ALLOWED TO BE PHOTOGRAPHED! http://kpfa.org/archive/id/56482

32775694
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Nov 28 at 12:09 PM ottawariverndn wrote ...

people should think about things before they open their mouth. unless you were there, you shouldn't speak about what you don't know about.. pretty much everything was forbidden to be photographed except for the Aztec dancers. and who is anyone to judge whether that man who was cedaring people off is native or not? just because he has a mustache makes him white? I'll take the unity and support (from the non-natives present) I saw there over the judgments made here any day..

32775279
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Nov 28 at 11:58 AM Quanah Parker Brightman wrote ...

I Find it Interesting That IITC, Which Was Founded In 1974 In Standing Rock South Dakota, And AIM, Which was Founded In Minneapolis Minnesota, Host An Event That Should Be Hosted By The Bay Area Founded Groups Whom Were There From DAY One To The End Of The Take Over Of Alcatraz. . .

32775006
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Nov 28 at 11:51 AM Sisters wrote ...

To address "Brothers", The sunrise gatherings have been held for the last 20 years. Many of the people in the photos are original occupiers and the dancers are there to share their prayers and dance in honor. We need less attacks on eachother as indian people and more effort made of coming together and willingness to move forward. Put your egos in check BROTHERS, it only blinds you as we cannot come together as a people with individuals wanting to take credit for efforts made as a movement!

32774809
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Nov 28 at 11:44 AM Sisters wrote ...

It is disheartening to read such negative comments of those that did not attend such a beautiful honoring and celebration. Typical that Lehman (or should we say Quanah) Brightman wants to take credit for the whole occupation. It was Indians of All Tribes, not UNA and many students from UCLA and SF State involved in the occupation. The late Bill Wahpehpah started the Sunrise Gatherings as the starting point of the 1978 longest walk and in 1979 in honor what the Alcatraz Occupation represented

32774416
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Nov 28 at 11:23 AM High Prophet wrote ...

what is this, a gathering of comedians? funny how these spanish/mexican always choose to act like Aztec. where are the real Natives, like the Zopatec, Huichol, Maya and so on? where's the photo of Plains Natives, Cali Natives, and all the other tribes? some joke, having a white guy smoke people out of a piece of garbage. i hope it's not like here, where the white eye wannabe claims to be Native, recieves funds and grants in the Natives name, and keep it all for themselves.SHOW SOME RESPECT,MAN!

32773409
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Nov 27 at 11:12 PM Again? wrote ...

Brothers, There are always Natives ready to talk smack about every other Native who does something good. what a shame. 500 years of facing the same threats and you are still not united.

32761616
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Nov 27 at 6:41 PM Melanie Cervantes wrote ...

Yes my husband designed the anniversary poster which we gave as a thank you gift to the occupiers and over 200 elders that attended the sunrise ceremony. We have limited edition screen posters available at www.dignidadrebelde.com

32754524
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Nov 27 at 4:56 PM Brothers wrote ...

I have a tremendous amount of respect for the original occupiers of Alcatraz. The question I have is how did this anniversary become a platform for those who weren't even involved with the 1969 occupation. I look at these pictures and I see a bunch of non natives and see references to issues that have more to do with bay area pet issues than native rights. Why don't these groups like iitc and aim and their followers earn their own legacy instead of latching on to this one?

32751709
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Nov 27 at 4:14 PM clayton finkbonner wrote ...

any posters made for this anniversary? Would like to buy some.

32750451
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

By posting a comment, user agrees to all Terms Of Use. Comments may also appear in other website locations and in other Indian Country Today products, without notice and at the discretion of Indian Country Today.

Indian Country Today and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand