Story Published:
Jun 18, 2009
Story Updated:
Jun 22, 2009
WASHINGTON – Of the approximately 500,000 American youth in foster care, Native American kids are faring among the worst, according to youth advocacy and policy experts.
New analysis indicates that American Indian, Hispanic and African-American children all fare more poorly than white children in foster care – with Native youth being about three times more likely to be placed in foster care than all children nationally.
At the same time, Native children also tend to stay in the foster system longer and move more frequently when compared to outcomes of white children.
Previous research has shown that children of color in foster homes and their families are treated differently from – and often not as well as – white children and their families in the system.
The new analysis comes by way of the Annie E. Casey Foundation, a children’s advocacy organization, where researchers and advocates are especially concerned about how to improve the foster system for children of color.
Douglas W. Nelson, president of the foundation, is among those who want change. “The basic human need for a family connection that can be counted on for life must be recognized as essential for all children and families, including those who interact with the child welfare system.”
Advocates for youth, like Nelson, are hopeful that new legislative updates will soon assist Native children. Specifically, the Fostering Connections to Success and Increasing Adoptions Act, passed by Congress in 2008, holds great hope for bringing improvement, youth policy experts believe.
The legislation, considered to be one of the biggest reforms in the foster care system in more than a decade, provides federal foster care funds directly to tribal governments so more American Indian and Alaska Native children can remain in their communities.
The law requires participating tribes to provide matching funds if they enter into direct agreements with the federal government to perform child welfare services under the Title IV-E Foster Care and Adoption Assistance program.
Policy experts have noted that the law does not force tribes to end any ongoing tribal-state agreements in terms of foster care. That is, tribal officials who feel the current structures of their agreements with states are working well for Native kids don’t have to immediately begin operating their own child welfare systems. But they now have a bolstered option of getting to that point.
Officials with the National Indian Child Welfare Association, which took the lead on helping structure the tribal provisions of the bill, called it groundbreaking legislation when it passed last year.
Still, the legislation is not a panacea, child welfare experts said – especially in light of the recent dire findings about Native kids in the foster system.
Along with the release of the new research that focuses on Native youth, the Annie E. Casey Foundation is calling on federal fiscal policy to better promote permanence and well-being for all kids in the child welfare system.
Advocates with the organization say that to make a difference in child welfare outcomes, the federal government must also take a leadership role in reducing the pervasive racial disparities found throughout the system.
Along those lines, foundation officials said the federal government should require states to disaggregate by race all data on key child welfare performance indicators; set aggressive goals for reducing and ultimately eliminating racial disparities; and regularly publish data measuring the amount of progress being made against these goals.
Tribal officials have also long called for the federal government to work more closely with tribes on foster care matters that directly affect Native youth.
Further, some policy experts say the federal government should balance between funds dedicated solely to out-of-home care (Title IV-E, more than $6 billion of federal spending in 2006) and funds that can be used more flexibly to keep families intact and promote innovative practices (Title IV-B, less than $650 million of federal spending in 2006).
Various proposals to do so have been presented to the Obama administration, according to child welfare experts.
Tuesday, Oct 6 at 12:09 AM Barbara wrote ...
the law system is very irrate these days and it is very unfair that alot of children and there families have to suffer under such so called laws that alot of these people in the judicial system call there own game to have people jump through there hoops just to get there children returned to them when the tribal social servicesdoes nothing to help individuals get there children back because all they care about is their families and it's all about money and the economy and their lives that is all
30177627Saturday, Sep 26 at 8:12 PM Barbara Bordeaux wrote ...
I had my children kidnapped from me three times in a row by these hidieous people who think there grounds don't fly when really the icwa or tribal social services should be there to help get children back to there parental custody i know where alot of people stand these days and we are all in the same boat and know it's time to take a stand and let the games begain and let these entities know who we really are we are the warriors of self defeat and we need our children back in our custody?
29721997Monday, Jul 13 at 9:42 PM Autumn wrote ...
This is absolutely deplorable. The Native children and their wellbeing is just as important as any other child. Something has to be done. We need to flood every politician's mailbox out there until someone listens.
25999307Saturday, Jul 11 at 6:26 AM Private Attorney General PJ Stewart wrote ...
If America ever made good on it treaties with our Indigoes people then this would not be happening. More genocide, by acts of removing our children to some other group must stop and the only way this will stop is to abolish CPS all together. CPS is not the three part of the three branches of government and act out side the law! Hold those who would violate the law as criminals they are and restore justice to the nations of the Turtle Island.
25835317Wednesday, Jul 8 at 6:24 PM Deborah SevenWolves wrote ...
Being adopted out at a very young age, I always had to struggle finding my way in a white world,that regulated my racial identity as extinct,that somehow I couldn't possibly be an American Indian. I had to be either Hispanic,Filipino or some other race. To this day ,almost sixty years later, Non-Natives refuse to believe were still alive.
25647712Wednesday, Jul 1 at 8:37 PM Candace Colbert Odom wrote ...
Every Native American Child deserves to know their Indian Heritage at Birth. It should be a Child Welfare Law that every Indian Child be enrolled at birth with the Tribe of their enrolled mother or father. I know its not that cut and dry, but it does not seem fair to deprive a child from the Indian Heritage and Culture.
25276222Tuesday, Jun 30 at 5:42 PM Julie oka Yanalli wrote ...
There are many problems involved in the child welfare/CPS system. In some states when CPS contacts the Tribe, even if the family is NA, if they are not "registered" then the child will not be accepted. Another problem is many states are using out dated data showing African American children are disproportional to all other children of color in the foster care system. Therefore all of the studies and monies are going to fight THAT problem. Let's unify,learn ICWA laws & DO something about it!
25207632Monday, Jun 29 at 7:38 PM vivianl@yakama.com wrote ...
The state of the "governed" reflects the governors doesn't it? In our case, American Indians, the state of the people reflects our leaders. The Tribal Council, program managers, and our Tribal courts do what is most expedient and not necessarily what is best.
25153344Monday, Jun 29 at 12:23 PM Candace Colbert Odom wrote ...
I was not informed of the guardian hearing as the Maternal Grandmother and enrolled member of my Tribe. My daughters Father told the Judge she owned no property on the Probate papers and the house she was living in had her name on the Property Taxes on-Line and also, the house she just purchased a week before she died was in her name. My ex-husband then transfered the properties to his new wifes name illegally when the house had been in my family since my father built the house in 1974.
25129254Monday, Jun 29 at 11:35 AM Candace Colbert Odom wrote ...
I sought help from my tribe, to get custody of my granddaughter after my daughter passed away from an asthma attack. They said it was not their jurisdiction. I have not been able to see or talk with her in over 5 years. This is an abomination, the man she is living with is a convicted felon... I hired 3 attorneys in Okc Don Nicholson III and Don Meyers w/Lawyers for Children and drove 1500 miles to the hearing and the Judge UPP would not hear our case in Ok County. I cry myself to sleep!
25126254Thursday, Jun 25 at 11:03 AM Native wrote ...
Reading these comments makes me sad and mad! I was a very proud indian and had the best parents in this whole wide world. My children are all gown up now and raised the way my parents raised me. I am willing to help with withever I can, how do I go about having a facilities for Indian children. My tribe just got restored and I am willing to give back. Any suggestions?
24944799Monday, Jun 22 at 12:13 PM Foster Mom Michigan wrote ...
As a Native Foster Parent, I find the system to be oppressive and ignoring the unprofessional behavior of caseworkers with private agencies. Hear our voice and help us protect the future of our children-help us instead of working against us. Tribes need to hear from their foster parents-we have a lot to share of what is really going on within the system-they just might learn the truth. The child's interest need to be protected from losing who they are and must be enrolled with their community.
24234079Monday, Jun 22 at 11:54 AM Caring One wrote ...
The issues are complex. One thing is clear and that is the need for a tribe's families to open a homes to the children of relatives and non-relative members of the tribal community. The "linch-pin" is the support of tribal government to families who foster. Reliance on BIA or ACF for funding means following the rules of those who give the gold. The ICWA gives tribe's tremendous capacity to raise the children of the community. It takes sacrafice from functioning families to make it work
24233107Saturday, Jun 20 at 3:44 PM Candace Colbert Odom wrote ...
I was adopted out at a week old, and never knew my tribal affiliation until I had my adoption records opened after both of my adopted parents had passed on... I went to the Juvenile Court in the county where I was born and asked the Juvenile Judge to open my adoption records because I was concerned about any undue health problems in my birth family history. By law Native Americans have a Right to their Heritage so she had to open the records, she told me who my real parents were...
24172359Saturday, Jun 20 at 10:00 AM lilliel wrote ...
I am a Native American survivor of foster care and this is such a dire need that is not being addressed, we as Native people HAVE to step up and say "we have had enough". What can we do to fix this? Tribal Social Service can only do so much with their limited resources, they need community backing and families stepping in to care for their kin. What do you do when you have children to place and no Native homes to place them in?
24162212Saturday, Jun 20 at 9:07 AM joel mastin wrote ...
my girlfriend died my twins were taken from me by stearns county minn.she is white earth ojibwe my twins were put in foster care and i was completly cut off from them .
24160754Friday, Jun 19 at 10:15 PM SPNCRinAZ wrote ...
This problem is just the tip of the iceberg. State agencies are not well versed about ICWA. We need our own CASA program for off-reservation children. All those who care to make a difference. We need to unify to save our children. I know first hand because I am foster (2) girls. My experience with AZ CPS is very hostile. It is time to service our community. I am but one who is DOING. Knowledge is power,so let get familiar with our ICWA laws and help prevent the IGNORANCE.
24147517Friday, Jun 19 at 11:57 AM James Armstrong wrote ...
When taken by a state agency, what is being done to assure that the child is enrolled with their tribe? Many native children are lost for the fact that some tribe have enrollement laws that conflict with what is being. Foster children should have a way to be enrolled or they are lost.
24110407Friday, Jun 19 at 9:46 AM working the system wrote ...
I work in Indian Child Welfare and face the problems everyday. Though the tribes are funded it is minimal and not nearly enough to work the cases all over the country. The biggest problem I see is state caseworkers and courts ignoring ICWA and even not allowing tribes in the court. It is nice to pass laws but who is out there forcing the courts to comply with those laws.
24101817Thursday, Jun 18 at 10:07 PM Ranch Good Days wrote ...
Ranch Good Days is a project to provide teen girls, including American Indian girls, with a wholistic healthy program. Most girls have been sent through the foster care program when a family setting may not be the right fit. Since 2003, Dr Donna Otabachian has developed a culture based program that connects the spirit of the horse with the child needing healing naturally. www.ranchgooddays.org
24084242Thursday, Jun 18 at 2:52 PM Triniti Braided Blood wrote ...
It's always the African-American, American Indian, and Hispanic American children that are neglected. This is nothing new, and we should not sit idly by and allow it to continue!
24061077Thursday, Jun 18 at 2:22 AM Wise One wrote ...
Did this study include the effectiveness of the current tribal Social Workers and staff to determine whether or not many of these children are being ignored, as part of the tribal responsibility? In most cases, Indian Child Welfare monitors off-reservation child disposition and insures some level of tribal participation and protection. Although the tribal Social Services budgets are minimal, BIA reportedly provides TA to the tribes. Throwing money at the problem is not an effective resolution.
24020979Add a comment
Most Popular