Gale Courey Toensing Indian Country Today

John Echohawk (right), the executive director of the Native American Rights Fund, was an invited guest at a panel discussion on tribal sovereignty along with Frank Ducheneaux, former legal counsel to the House of Representatives Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs; University of Connecticut Law Professor Bethany Berger; and state Attorney General Richard Blumenthal, pictured here with Echohawk.

Tools

‘Enemy of sovereignty’ to seek US Senate seat

By Gale Courey Toensing

HARTFORD, Conn. – A popular state attorney general with an anti-Indian sovereignty reputation is making a bid for the U.S. Senate.

Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal announced Jan. 6 that he will seek the Senate seat held by fellow Democrat Chris Dodd, who has served five terms, said a day earlier he would not seek re-election in the 2010 race.

Blumenthal began a press conference with Connecticut Democrats in Hartford with praise for Dodd.

“I’m also here to say that I intend to be a candidate for the United States Senate. I’ll be making a formal announcement very, very shortly, but I want to leave no doubt today that I intend to be a candidate and I have the goal of fighting as tirelessly and tenaciously in the U.S. Senate for the people of Connecticut as I have done for the last two decades as attorney general. I will be a fighter in Washington for change. I will stand strong against scams and special interests,” Blumenthal said to loud applause.

Blumenthal, who has been the state’s attorney general since 1991, is popular in his home state.

Not so much in Indian country.

According to his state biography, the attorney general has advocated “aggressive law enforcement for consumer protection, environmental stewardship, labor rights and personal privacy.”

But throughout Indian country, Blumenthal is known for advocating aggressively against tribal sovereignty, federal recognition, and tribal governments’ jurisdiction on tribal land, and for leading other state attorneys general to join him in court cases that aim to diminish tribal sovereignty.

For example, Blumenthal intervened in San Manuel v. the National Labor Relations Board in which the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit Court disregarded 75 years of tribal exemption and ruled that federal labor laws apply on sovereign Indian land.

He also led a coalition of more than a dozen state attorneys general to intervene in the Narragansett Indian Tribe’s efforts to place 31 acres of land into trust for elder housing. The years-long case wended its way through district court and the 1st Circuit Court of Appeals, which ruled in the tribe’s favor, and ended up last year as Carcieri v. Salazar in a U.S. Supreme Court decision that said the Interior secretary does not have the authority to take land into trust for tribes recognized after the 1934 Indian Reorganization Act.

In November, Blumenthal testified in front of the House Resources Committee against legislation to fix Carcieri v. Salazar. He recommended, among other things, that “Congress should have sole authority to approve post-1934 tribal trust land requests.”

In Connecticut, Blumenthal has fought the federally recognized Mashantucket Pequot Tribal Nation and Mohegan Tribe on land claims, land into trust, taxation, jurisdiction on tribal land over labor issues, sovereign immunity, smoking bans in casinos, and other issues.

But he is perhaps most notoriously known for his successful effort in 2005 to reverse the federal acknowledgment of the Eastern Pequot Tribal Nation and the Schaghticoke Tribal Nation.

Blumenthal worked with Dodd and the other members of the state’s congressional delegation, state and local elected officials in the town of Kent where the Schaghticoke Nation has a 400-acre reservation, and a group of wealthy casino-opposing Kent land owners, who hired the power lobbying firm of Barbour Griffith and Rogers to pressure the BIA to overturn its decision to acknowledge the tribe.

Chief Harry Wallace of the Unkechaug Indian Nation, a New York state recognized tribe that has not sought federal acknowledgment, was dismayed by the news of Blumenthal’s possible election to the Senate.

“I don’t think that’s good for Indian country. I think he’d certainly be an enemy of sovereignty. I think he will be someone who will bring his prejudicial notions of Indian tribes and Indian nations and his political influence against the tribes of Connecticut, and spread that further across the country. I think he’ll be an impediment to sovereignty and issues of land claims, taxation, economic development, security – all these things.”

Sunday, Feb 7 at 1:06 AM NW Native wrote ...

Two Feathers: A question. Is it just your council that you are upset with or is it councils in general? Our Rez has a small casino in comparison to some others but it is doing quite well, but we as individuals, do not receive any kick back from it, rather, it goes into providing health services and educational services for our members, which we all agree is one way of becoming self reliant, and that, ultimately is our goal. Sovereignty cannot and should not be used by any council, as a tool or bargaining chip in any way. We, as Native people need to protect what we have..but most importantly..who we are. Do not trust his man!! Period!! I understand that not all Native people have access to profitable enterprise and usually it has to do with location, but for us our casino was a feasable venture and it's working. I know there are other ways Tribes can succeed financially, and I do hope there can be some accountability and answers within your council..for you and yours.

37150329
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jan 22 at 10:49 PM Two Feathers wrote ...

It is the Council's fault. Casino's with no Indians. Recognition with gambling ties? There's other ways to prosper without gambling. Leaders who cannot hear and cannot see. It is the Tribes fault. I distrust Indian leaders as much as I distrust Mr. Blumenthal.

36173667
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jan 20 at 12:08 AM Os wrote ...

Really, who supports "sovereignty?" Not even tribal officials support sovereignty, because tribal governments are corrupt compradors that represent the interests of American imperialism, by and large. True sovereignty for our nations isn't determined by whether or not the state "allows" us to build a casino or other gaming venues.

35960712
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jan 16 at 4:08 PM fristin wrote ...

You want to stop him? Consider supporting Peter Schiff the Libertarian running for the red team. Do some research and you may find this is the best option for Connecticut.

35762509
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jan 15 at 12:40 PM cutting corners wrote ...

would it be possible to complain directly to connecticut's human rights group, if they have one? the foreigns who have come here uninvited need to be painted in real living colors, and this can happen when their names, photos, written slurs, are presented to those bodies whose work it is lessen racial b.s. its time to get to work.

35628259
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jan 15 at 12:34 PM Steve wrote ...

For those who are having a hard time, this guy has a (D) after his name, not an (R). But does it really matter? THINGS NEED TO CHANGE!! Is any Native in Connecticut stepping forward to be a candidate? I'm sure the tribes there and the casinos can support someone to run. Let's put our own candidate into the mix and kick both parties out! Don't Tread on Me

35627764
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jan 14 at 11:39 AM Tye wrote ...

Clark - "If you can't contribute, die." I don't know where you came from but history is unmistakable. The land belonged to the Indians. If that isn't enough contribution, I suggest that you open your eyes, or better yet, a history book coupled with the history recounted by tribal elders. You'll find that much was "contributed" and we ALMOST died at the hands of those we "contributed" to. I don't need to be reminded of the history of tribes, perhaps you do.

35546809
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jan 14 at 9:42 AM WAMP1MASHPEE wrote ...

YOU KNOW I WAS BROUGHT UP TO BELIEVE THIS WHITE MAN THAT CAME HERE TO TAKE OVER AND DID TAKE OVER WAS THE DEVIL AND NOW LOOK WHERE WE ARE

35537682
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jan 13 at 7:51 PM NahtekAneam817@yahoo.com wrote ...

There is much dishonor on the non-Indian."The case of the American Indian is clear and uncomplicated.Amearican Indians suffer because the non-Indians have devised ways and means of not keeping their word".The dishonorable ways of the USA.

35505972
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jan 13 at 4:11 PM native4sure17@gonmail.com wrote ...

So what has changed ? Look at the way these white people treat obama . And they want to teach this democracy to other Nations ! These types of people just dont get it . This is why most of the world can't stand yous'se .

35489454
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jan 13 at 3:45 PM A "real" Indian wrote ...

Since almost all "white skinned" Indians are republicans, I need to hear from one of you wannabes as to why us "real" Indians should support such a conservative republican like this? Please be more creative that just saying "It's in your best interest"!

35487107
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jan 12 at 7:37 PM Wanbli wrote ...

Clark nothing on this continent belongs to you or the United States of America, "remember that" and maybe the Creator will take pity on you!

35418787
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jan 12 at 6:36 PM NdN Cleopatra's says: wrote ...

Off with his head!

35415189
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jan 12 at 5:12 PM Clark wrote ...

Go ahead and govern yourselves and whatever else you want to do...just stop doing it with my money. I'm tired of supporting deadbeats of every race, creed and ethnicity...whites included. If you can't contribute, die

35408889
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jan 12 at 3:51 PM hamlaw wrote ...

As a life-long Democrat and former Clinton appointee, it takes a lot for me to say "I'd rather see a Republican elected to the Senate than to give Blumethal the power of a Senate seat so that he can spread his subtle brand of hate from a national pulpit so he can advocate for the "disappearance" of all tribes.

35402447
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jan 12 at 1:05 PM WAMP1MASHPEE wrote ...

I AGREE WITH EVERY ONE LETS BAND TOGETHER EAST COAST WEST COAST AND THE LANDS IN BETWEEN WE CAN FIGHT THIS DEVIL HEAD ON JUST ELECT SOME ONE WHO IS AND WILL BE FOR THE PEOPLE DON;T TRUST OBAMA HE HASN'T DONE ANYTHING YET AND YOU KNOW WE ARE NOT THE MAJORITY IN THIS COUNTRY LET ME A POWERFUL NATIVE WOMAN HOOK UP WITH THIS PERSON HE MAY HEAR THINGS THAT WILL MAKE HIM CRY DON'T GIVE UP MY PEOPLE IF WE DO WE WILL BE GONE

35388547
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jan 12 at 9:59 AM Indian Survival wrote ...

Clearly, there is prejudice against NDNs in the federal and state governments and among the political parties. Every time we speak of sovereignty and our right to govern ourselves without interference, we challenge the legitimacy of the federal govt and the states and threaten the power of the political parties. If they agree on nothing else, they agree that our sovereignty must be stopped. We need to work together to gain enough power to survive against that unified effort against us.

35373707
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jan 12 at 1:09 AM Thomas wrote ...

I'll take this article to work and show people there. I'll take this article to my friends. I'll take this article to my neighbhors. I'll take this article to the native American Community Center. I'll take this article to Harmony Cafe. I'll take this article to and talk to as many people as I can. Thank you for the article.

35357857
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 10:55 PM eagle eye wrote ...

let this tybo do his thing, because what come around goes around and it is all up to the man up stair to call his bluff when the time is right. like all politicians they rise and fall in time!the creator will protect us so long as we be traditional and not asimulated

35351192
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 10:32 PM Skinwalker wrote ...

Adopted crow is serving tea at the white house and now he needs another lawyer who happens to not play well with bill clinton's Pequot (black brand) or Mohigan (Irish Brand) casino indians invented in connect-I-cut. Lawyers are for sale where ever the helpless lay wounded. Now imagine nevada's speaker talking in the closet with blu-menthal over a one sugar or two held by a light colored black adopted crow who happen to not know what tribe he belongs to from Africa. The melting pot is turning in

35350014
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 8:58 PM Longwind wrote ...

the chief is right about Blumenthal he is a white man lover and a indian hangman. You and all indians has to get unify to beat this devil

35345022
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 6:59 PM Lucille A. Quilt wrote ...

To all Natives out there. It is time to pray! You have the Father up there who knows every heart. Nothing is hidden before him. He gave this land to the Natives and their prayers are heard concerning their land. Get busy and pray every day. Whatever religion that you belong to. Get Back to your roots! That means fear no man. Believe on our Lord! Hoyt! Lucille

35337684
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 4:45 PM chizzi wrote ...

its time to declare blumenthal a foreign alien. get him arrested and deported pronto!

35327897
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 4:37 PM Wawashkeshei wrote ...

Blumenthal, english for Americzn Taliban

35327347
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 2:30 PM Wanbli wrote ...

"Christian White Nationalism" is going mainstream and Blumenthal is their national voice to maintain "red people" and "people of color" continued repression and oppression upon "First Nations" divine homelands. This kind of political violence is nothing new, its came here 500 years ago and before that. This should be alarming to all people. A sign! But, American People are colonized. The "Oppressor" cannot liberate the oppressed because its seen as a threat to "US" and its "human" legitimacy.

35317522
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 2:21 PM Sovereignty wrote ...

how do we stop a group that would be financing his election? How do we oppose it? Whats most effective here?

35316824
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 2:20 PM Sovereignty wrote ...

How do we stop him from winning?

35316704
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 2:20 PM Wamp1Mashpee wrote ...

what can I say stop his money people and we stop him he is one unhappy dude towards us first people racist and just plain stupid he should know he can not stop progress and all of us that speak up so every one speak up and be heard

35316699
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 1:50 PM H.R. Hudson wrote ...

I'm convinced that people who don't support tribal sovereignty, like Blumenthal, must be stopped. And "Forces of Freedom" is right: Find out the group that is financing his campaign.

35314412
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 1:08 PM Georgett Abrahamson wrote ...

What do we need to do, to stop him from being elected besides pass the word. We seem to overcome one hill, then another keeps popping up. thank God for our persistence and what leaders we do have in the system.

35311139
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 1:03 PM Candace Colbert Odom wrote ...

I firmly believe in Indian Soveign Rights! It should be protected and retained... I don't know who is backing Blumenthal but the Native American People should put someone in there that believes as they do and will protect the Soverignty at all costs.

35310757
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 11:41 AM Proudpequot wrote ...

As a CT native and Eastern Pequot, I can confirm that Blumenthal is anathema to New England's regional tribal issues. Dodd and Lieberman aren't much better. The problem with Blumenthal's candidacy that the Democratic party and the Obama administration, which I support, needs a Democrat to win Dodd's vacating seat so they're going to support him come hell or high water to keep the GOP from winning that seat.

35304359
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 9:11 AM Ray wrote ...

This guy is no different than a thousand other jackleg politicians who worship one master- the green dollar. They will do everything to make sure they get more and more and more...

35294867
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jan 11 at 3:40 AM Forces of Freedom wrote ...

Blumenthal is just a front man for the wealthy special interest in Connecticut who want to control all the wealth in Connecticut. They want stop the Indian Nations from becoming wealthy and free. Do not put all your attention on Blumenthal. But find out the group that is financing his election.

35288917
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

By posting a comment, user agrees to all Terms Of Use. Comments may also appear in other website locations and in other Indian Country Today products, without notice and at the discretion of Indian Country Today.

Indian Country Today and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand