Story Published:
Dec 8, 2009
Story Updated:
Dec 8, 2009
WASHINGTON – The Obama administration has taken a definitive step to settle a long-running trust mismanagement class action lawsuit involving hundreds of thousands of Native Americans.
The Department of the Interior announced Dec. 8 that it had negotiated a settlement to the Cobell v. Salazar litigation, which could amount to a $1.4 billion payback to Indian plaintiffs involved in the case.
“We are here today to right a past wrong,” Interior Secretary Ken Salazar said during a briefing on the plan held at Interior headquarters.
For the settlement to become final, Congress must pass legislation to approve it, and the court overseeing the case must also agree, said Attorney General Eric Holder.
Salazar said he is hopeful that legislative action will occur before the end of the year, based on discussions he’s already had with some lawmakers.
The litigation has centered on the argument that the government mismanaged billions of dollars in oil, gas, grazing, timber and other royalties overseen by the Interior for Indian trustees since 1887.
The case has gone through numerous appeals since it was first filed in 1996.
If the settlement is approved, a $1,000 check will be sent to each member of the class, said Associate Attorney General Tom Perrelli.
Then, a formula established by the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, the overseeing court, would provide more settlement funds to individual class members.
President Barack Obama said he was proud of the decision to settle.
“As a candidate, I heard from many in Indian country that the Cobell suit remained a stain on the nation-to-nation relationship I value so much,” the president said in a statement.
“I pledged my commitment to resolving this issue, and I am proud that my administration has taken this step today. …”
Elouise Cobell said that she was thankful to Interior for the gesture, adding she had thought the case would be settled long ago.
“Today we have an administration that is listening to us,” the lead plaintiff said. She had expressed dissatisfaction with the administration last spring that it had not focused on the issue more quickly.
Cobell said that there is “no doubt” that the settlement amount is “significantly less than the full accounting to with the class members are entitled.”
One settlement figure offered by lawyers for the Indian plaintiffs during legal proceedings was $47 billion.
But Cobell said that as the case has progressed through the years, some class members have passed away, and many are living in extreme poverty.
“A settlement can address the situation,” Cobell said, adding that she doesn’t believe trust reform should stop at this point.
She said she is hopeful Interior will work to permanently correct wrongs so Indian account holders will have knowledge of money that is rightfully theirs.
As part of the settlement, a $2 billion fund would also be set up by Interior aimed at buying back trust interests from individuals, Salazar said, although he awknowledged that some class members would likely be distrustful of choosing to sell their interests.
Salazar called the plan a “land consolidation program,” saying it will provide individual Indians with an opportunity to obtain cash payments for divided land interests and free up lands for the benefit of tribal communities.
In order to provide owners additional incentive to sell their interests, the settlement authorizes Interior to set aside up to 5 percent of the value of the interests into a college and vocational school scholarship fund for American Indian students.
The decision to settle did not come easily, according to administration officials who said serious work on the deal had been ongoing since summer.
Holder noted that Justice could have decided to continue litigating the case “at great expense to taxpayers.”
Interior currently manages about 56 million acres of Indian trust land, administering more than 100,000 leases and about $3.5 billion in trust funds.
For fiscal year 2009, funds from leases, use permits, land sales and income from financial assets, totaling about $298 million were collected for more than 384,000 open Individual Indian Money accounts and $566 million was collected for about 2,700 tribal accounts for more than 250 tribes.
More information on the settlement is available at http://cobellsettlement.com.
Friday, Feb 12 at 5:14 AM Cheyenne wrote ...
Dear Ms. Corbell: Many thanks for your tireless efforts to you and to whomever worked with you. May the Great Spirit watch over you and yours.
37476126Saturday, Feb 6 at 3:23 PM Martin NoRunner wrote ...
It will never be a wrong righted, and land is better than money, but as many of us said we need to unite. If we want to fight the power we need to get the power to fight. If each of us getting a check put 10% or more into a united fund for ourselves to accumulate interest we would have the money, united POWER, and the demanded respect due to us by the United States government TO FIGHT! In todays economically driven world even the most sensible and justified causes are only heard when flown by the wings of the almighty dollar. Money talks.
37130114Friday, Feb 5 at 7:23 PM Indians still lost wrote ...
yes, but even with this little bit of money..the PEOPLE will see none of it. Like goverment our tribe leaders will find a way to get the money and none will go to the people. I am 50 years old and received 1 per-capita payment at 18 for $1800.00 No settlement money EVER goes to the people!!!!!!!!!!
37089852Wednesday, Feb 3 at 1:52 PM bystander wrote ...
`For the settlement to become final, Congress must pass legislation to approve it, and the court overseeing the case must also agree [...] government mismanaged billions of dollars in oil, gas, grazing, timber and other royalties overseen by the Interior for Indian trustees since 1887.' mmm.... a $1.4 billion payback is awefully puny to `right a past wrong' of this magnitude. i may only have a spot of native in me and have no entitlement but this looks like a spit in the face instead of a `settlement.' they need to calculate inflation into their wrong.
36925134Thursday, Jan 28 at 1:41 AM WINDSPIRIT wrote ...
Seems to me that we win small battles but fail to win the war. What will it take to overcome our oppressors? What will it take for us to all unite and fight for what is rightfully ours? A $1,000. check to each tribal member... That's chicken feed. What we need is some real money that would allow us to make an entire lifestyle change and allow us to become a real force to be reckoned with in this white man's world. When we have money, then the forces that be are forced to deal us on our terms.
36508429Saturday, Jan 23 at 11:30 AM quietelk wrote ...
we wamt the money cause we are humans but the love of money is the root of all evil. keep the land the way it is now. let each ownership decide. We INDIANS must stick togeather as one nation to make a decision for our lands and mineral rites. GREAT SPIRIT BE WITH US ALL.
36194804Wednesday, Jan 20 at 2:42 PM Shawn Charbonneau wrote ...
U know it is funny we all fight against each other. Rez against Rez family against family. we all need to stand together and fight. Seems to me lots of embeziling is going on under our eyes. whoes the richest on the rez? Fight for our dreams stand up for our dreams. Fight to prosecute tribal embezalers who take from us the poorer. So please quit fighting one another and stand up and fight together and lets work together and unit to one instead of none. Be proud of who u are! Chippewa nation!!!!!
36001887Friday, Jan 15 at 11:57 AM Anonymous wrote ...
It is clear after reading over 1/2 of these posts,there should be several law suits yet to come. Obviously the treaties that were signed by our ancestors were to safeguard our future existence on our original territories. We are entitled the rights to have education, health, welfare, hunting, gathering and fishing rights, etc... Very sad days continue, when the tribes continue to allow settlers to keep us divided and conquered. Oldest trick in the book!Unite! N cool it with the broken English
35624774Friday, Jan 8 at 3:02 AM kristin D wrote ...
and what about housing? majority of natives are on housing, natives lived on the land long ago didn't have to pay rent why should we now? we deserve alot more we're just being suckerd again!!
35115987Friday, Jan 8 at 2:48 AM kristin D wrote ...
I think every native american should recieve 1,000 a month for 100 years thats how long this has been put aside if its only a 1,000 one time that is just riddiculious!!!
35115584Thursday, Jan 7 at 7:00 PM onewhostands out wrote ...
Its biz as usual.Life is a struugle we all know to well and it keeps getting harder.I believe TERMINATION IS NEXT.We know the usa is broke.
35092312Wednesday, Jan 6 at 1:41 PM D, LITTLE wrote ...
I THINK THAT THIS SETTLEMENT SHOULDNT BE OVER BECAUSE THE LAKOTA SIOUXS ON THE PINE RIDGE INDIAN REZ!!!!!!! ARE HOLDING ON TOO TTHE BLACK HILLS BUT WE ARE THE POORIEST RESERVATION IN THE STATES!!!!!!!!! WE NEED A PER CAP CHECK TO!!!!!!! ALL THE OTHER TRIBES GET IT WHY CANT WE???????????????????????????? BUT WE THE LAKOTANATION NEED FUNDING TOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
34990301Wednesday, Jan 6 at 1:24 PM Everette whitewolf wrote ...
1000!!!!! WHAT IS THAT?? IF THE GOVERMENT KNEW WHAT IS IS LIKE TO GROW UP ON A REZ WIT NO LIGHTS OR WATER THEN THEY(THE GOVERMENT) WOULD UNDERSTAND WHY THE NATIVES ARE MAD ABOUT THE SETTLMENT!!!!!!!! ITS BEEN OVER100 years AND THIS IS WHAT WE GET!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
34988889Sunday, Jan 3 at 9:22 PM Anonymous wrote ...
All you with Native Blood, stand up and be one. It's time to come together and stand tall like our Grandfather's once stood.
34819777Saturday, Jan 2 at 2:44 PM Judy Long wrote ...
WHY ARE THEY GETTING THE MONEY WERE FRGHTING FOR, THY ARE STILL WINNER THEY GET THE MILLIONS WE GET THE SCRAPS THAT ARE LEFT FROM THEM GETTING PAID WHAT ABOUT THEM USEING OUR MONEY TO BUY OUR LAND FROM US .ONCE THY GET IT GROVUMENT REALLY GETS IT CAUSE THEY REALLY CONTOLL IT BEHINE GROVUMENT ORDER
34765357Wednesday, Dec 30 at 2:15 PM Robert William Nicholson wrote ...
The Gros Ventre's appreciate the hard work & dedication you have put forward for us Natives!!!!!!!!
34624982Tuesday, Dec 29 at 7:55 PM Anonymous wrote ...
coming from the large water and helped them survive; only to watch them take, take, take or should I say steal the land, remove a generation of Native Children and massacre a generation, with alcohol, weapon's and deceased blankets. So I say this offer is a disgrace to all. The offer should be in "Many Billion's" and the United States government should pay all legal fee's. "So I ask you this, is this unreasonable?"
34574946Tuesday, Dec 29 at 7:53 PM Mahkwah wrote ...
"To make the settlement work, lawyers for the plaintiffs agreed to cap legal fees at $100 million" Who makes such a statement, the white-eye lawyer or the politician. I can't see an Native American even thinking such a thought. This theft or offer is a disgrace to all. I love this country, but don't understand the reasoning of our leader's. Sell domestic interest abroad, fund Billion's to war's and heartships outside our boundaries, ect.. Our Grandfather's trusted those coming from the large wat
34574872Tuesday, Dec 29 at 4:24 PM Indian Trust Land Owners wrote ...
Do you honestly think after 122 years of dishonesty on behalf of our government that they are going to pay back what we were cheated out of? 3.5 billion is chicken scratch to what they honestly owe the Red Nation!
34562046Friday, Dec 25 at 8:38 PM mahkwah wrote ...
Do you all realize the 100 million dollar's the lawyer's will take is equal to what the white-eye has done to a Proud people for many moon's. These monies are a sell-out, and once distributed throughout, it will again compute to pennies or half pennies. If you praise these actionsthe path you walk is clouded. Stand up and be one, Remember those that came before you and those spirit's that shout in disgust. This agreement is no better than those of our Grandfather's "I'm ashamed!"
34349861Wednesday, Dec 23 at 2:57 PM Amy wrote ...
I am concerned about the tribal governments IRA having anything to do with this money......look at the debt we are in now from all the previous and present administrations.....all half-breeds to boot.......they are corrupt and greedy, only thinking of their own gain and their own families. As far as the ones who should get it should be the 1/2 or more.....all these iyeska's take and take but don't look at the whole nation as one but just what they can get, what about us poor real Natives..
34240042Monday, Dec 21 at 7:57 PM Anonymous wrote ...
No matter what we get, still be grateful instead of I want, I want... It was our grandfathere who we should be thinkin of..not the money and todays spending
34112631Sunday, Dec 20 at 12:02 AM tonto wrote ...
I have fractioned trust land rich in oil filled with dinosaur bones tied up in pick sloan red tape under payments for grazing, timber,and of course cobell then they offer me change for it i think not they better dig in their pockets a little deeper and get rid of the middle man or i pass this land on to my kids and the fight will continue won't matter to me i will be worm food by then.
34003707Thursday, Dec 17 at 11:59 PM 2-Spirits wrote ...
Glad someone stood up to fight, but for all that has been lost and ripped away from our Ancestors and our people, nothing (especially 1000 worthless dollars) can ever replace what is lost. Much love and remembrance to our ancestors who suffered under the tyranical, oppressive boot heel of the US Government in years past. At least they are all in a much better place now where their pain and suffering has been relieved. This fight is for the future of our people in remembrance of our past.
33887699Thursday, Dec 17 at 5:33 PM RedBird007 wrote ...
Well this is about TIME we also have letters to prove who we belong to and with what should have been EVEN our family members who are tribal members CANT get what should sent to them, although they have pushed for us... Well MAYBE God has seen his way to bless us on this day
33867676Thursday, Dec 17 at 5:16 AM soaringeagle wrote ...
they hate each so much that they fear they will become they're gov. next target. they have run out of people in amer. to kill so they turn on each other lik a mad dog fight relax brothers we will be there to mop up the mess. we are the great spirits chosen human beings. after the scrap who wins ? US! so relax and don't worry buy what u can barter for what u need and we will still suceed don't forget the old ways they still APPLY!....
33825989Thursday, Dec 17 at 4:53 AM he who kills at nite /lumbee nc wrote ...
now they want us to be political. we still own what is ours in secret but they want to to make you believe that u have to fight for it the fight is over and is is still ours . they need us to guide them in their failures thats why wankintanka alloys us to still be here screw the money take back our lands with the knowledge they beat into us. they will die and we will begin anew to reclaim the earth. they are trying to make us difficult like them they hate their own mothers.peace.
33825627Wednesday, Dec 16 at 11:40 AM youknowwho wrote ...
i hope that ones that get that money are at lest 1/4 native and have a BIA latter to prove it,,,,13/16 native here,,,aye,
33769782Sunday, Dec 13 at 12:44 PM wannabe12 wrote ...
Just want to say, don't allow this oppressive government to walk on you any longer. I think it is over due that the great people of the American Indian Nations should separate themselves from the control of the US Government and be a true independent nation. History has shown time again the true intentions of the government....suppression & control History
33592019Saturday, Dec 12 at 12:37 PM Rick from Laguna wrote ...
Native Americans managment of thar own lands hmmmmmmm.
33550969Saturday, Dec 12 at 12:00 PM kanaratanoron bear clan five nation wrote ...
Native land`s our mother earth is not forsale for any amount it is not your`s nor my to put a figure on her the next generation and the next after that 1000 wow that`s all.I spent that in one day in white man`s law`s imposed on me and my people suffer everyday from whiteman`s law`s.ASK the people of this turtle island our mother earth is it eough sell your right`s why not land`s instead of money`s settle for land it will alway`s be here long after you?????????? for the future of our children XX
33549611Saturday, Dec 12 at 1:34 AM granddaughter of a cherokee wrote ...
and of coarse they are gonna tax every bit of the money, if anyone ever even sees it.
33536221Friday, Dec 11 at 8:12 PM Anonymous wrote ...
What about the Freedmen - the black Indians who were spit out and left to die. Their children can not even get an Indian enrollment. Come on Black Freedmen. Let us file. Pass the law Congress.
33525686Friday, Dec 11 at 1:21 AM Colville lady wrote ...
Its important to recognize this is not about the $$ but about the government taking responsibility for transgressions against native people..its a step in the right direction. Great respect to those who never gave up the fight- corbel and followers.
33477489Thursday, Dec 10 at 11:16 PM Melinda J G Hyman wrote ...
Thank you Elouise I know your ancestors are so happy.I am glad you didn't stop the struggle the world needs more people like you & me.I am also fighting a similar case but I can't get representation.And it forces my family to be pro se and keep up with the timelines as the legal system trys make me tired but that won't work.
33472717Thursday, Dec 10 at 4:32 PM Michael Mack wrote ...
Eloise Cobell is one of my heroes - she educated herself on the facts, worked with tribes, sacrificed her own time and comfort to take on the biggest messiest bureaucracy that has ever existed in modern times - the U.S. government. Yes, the amount settled upon is a joke, but given the full-picture of the economic and political realities of the U.S. government, that amount is probably as best as can be expected, sad to say.
33454062Thursday, Dec 10 at 3:31 PM Nish wrote ...
Obama is dangerous in that he fooled us into actually believing him... He is a puppet of Wall Street and the military industrial complex.
33450292Thursday, Dec 10 at 2:30 PM David Eli Guardipee,Blackfeet,member. wrote ...
Oki my Relative's in Browning,oldNapi still lives,$1000.don't do much gee who care's anyway it would be nice to icefish or trap on the land my Father Stanley,Cholate,Guardipeeleased out to DR.Bacon for 99 years yup it would be nice to camp on Milk River,all my relative's .
33446104Thursday, Dec 10 at 12:29 PM Many Bands wrote ...
My grandmother passed a decade away or so, left the land to her son who did not have children. He left alloted land to his non-tribal, non-native wife. This land has water running through it....we visited our "muuah" grandmother there. The law at that time allowed this inheritance, but should of never been allowed. How many natives have had their ties to what is rightfully our stolen.... We want out land for our people, to stay in our families, and to be returned!!!!! This sole lady wins...
33437862Thursday, Dec 10 at 12:21 PM Many Bands wrote ...
The settlement of IIM accounts and land trust accounts will pay Individual accounts $1,000.00 and a minimum of $500.00 to those who have an interest in fractionated land. Is it true, that if you have interests in your maternal and paternal families allotments, which could be from several different tribes, you will be offered a one time $1,000.00? Will Nativz be cheated by this? We need some clarification. It appears WE have only one account!!!!!
33437162Thursday, Dec 10 at 9:49 AM NotSoCrazyHorse wrote ...
So this administration wants to be the indian's best friend now, and is in a hurry to do it and settle past accounts. Hmmmmmmmmmmm, sounds like there is more to this story, maybe like WE ARE GOING TO TAKE YOUR LAND NOW BUT WILL SHARE THE WEALTH WITH YOU, right. And how many years will it be before the Cobell monies are distributed to the rightful owners, even in their lifetime? How many committees and commissions and bureaucracy stands in the way of this? I say never.
33426649Thursday, Dec 10 at 8:45 AM Maori Political Warrior wrote ...
Kia mau te wehi, amazing work to all those past and present genrations of those descendents of ancestors who suffered the injustice - its only a start on the war path to justice fight forever - kia whawhai tonu mo ake tonu ake!!
33423889Wednesday, Dec 9 at 11:11 PM Crow Warrior wrote ...
Could I have Mine in Euros, or better, Gold! Jus' Kiddin'! Any thanks should go to Eloise Cobell who never gave up the fight! Too bad they probably won't prosecute the Individuals who stole from Native Tribes!
33409314Wednesday, Dec 9 at 8:05 PM Mr. TN from Muskogee wrote ...
Congratulations to you, Elouise and your kind. More people should stand up to corruption in governmant lest we turn into another Afganistan!
33400849Wednesday, Dec 9 at 6:52 PM cloud97408 wrote ...
@afropick...wassup with you hating on Obama. Native Americans have lived a long time, without any advice from you. As a American of African decent, I am glad Obama reache out to the Natives, and tried to right a wrong. Let's get behind this President and try to make a better world for us all.
33397181Wednesday, Dec 9 at 6:06 PM Digoweli wrote ...
Didn't Grandmother Cobell say she HADN'T been offered seven billion? As for Churchill, rez missed the point. The point is not the person but the parallel process in both cases. You win, : >)) you lose, I win. Same old game but you still allow yourself to be distracted with the same old same old. They don't care anymore about us than they do Churchill. It's happened before.
33394464Wednesday, Dec 9 at 5:46 PM ritareples wrote ...
My computer did not allow me to see all of my text so I couldn't proof-read. Here is the last of what I wanted to say. Since Nov. 2008 the oil cos. in North Dakota have been drilling $10 million worth of oil a day in the Bakken Oil Formation. Will we share in that? WE SURE AS HELL SHOULD!
33393294Wednesday, Dec 9 at 5:38 PM ritareplies wrote ...
I think $1.4 billion is a huge "slap in the face!" The monies will be dispersed among class members and IIM holders, and monies for the education of indian youths and land improvemnts, etc. but what about the mineral rights if and when the lands are reverted back to tribal lands? Shares can be bought back for peanuts. Since Nov. 2008, the oil companies in the Bakken Oil Formation in North Dakota have beeen drilling as much as @10, million a da! Do we share in that? WE SURE AHELL SHOULD!
33392762Wednesday, Dec 9 at 5:33 PM Blackfeet People wrote ...
Congradulations, Eloise Cobell Warrior woman of the Blackfeet, We are all so happy and proud of your accomplishments for Indian Country.Thank you, for 14 years of hard work and dedication to the 1st. people of America.
33392494Wednesday, Dec 9 at 3:07 PM indiancowboy wrote ...
The BIA is still mismanaging trust lands... This settlement will not stop this mismanagement...
33382831Wednesday, Dec 9 at 2:48 PM rez wrote ...
Elouise Cobell ROCKS! Much Luv.
33381439Wednesday, Dec 9 at 2:46 PM rez wrote ...
yea, but what does ward churchill have to do with Indians? or for that matter, the price of wheat???
33381309Wednesday, Dec 9 at 2:43 PM Sara Marie Ortiz wrote ...
I am saddened and sickened at this "outcome," which isn't really an outcome at all, but a toxic half-wrought disgrace of a point along an already illimitably long spectrum of mismanagement, deceit, dispossession and outright verifiably criminal activity by a government legally bound to protect and adhere to the congressionally granted rights of American Indian Peoples. Government to government relationship in this context: null & void. You get an 'F' on this one, no doubt, Mr. President.
33381109Wednesday, Dec 9 at 1:55 PM Anonymous wrote ...
Once we get the "crumbs" this amount will be sent to Prescott,Az, where they will skim off their share, then it will be sent to our area offices where it will be whittled down somemore, then sent to Alburquerque where they can get their hands on it also, then sent to us!
33377852Wednesday, Dec 9 at 12:17 PM hiatsistsalagi... wrote ...
outstanding!!!hope it comes to fruition and the $$$ get paid out...
33370681Wednesday, Dec 9 at 12:11 PM Gail Hanson wrote ...
I challenge all my sisters and brothers in Indian Country to take heart and keep faith in our Creator! Our God will right the wrongs. Evil men do wrong and think they are getting away with it, and no one sees or takes account of their evils done. But there is one who does His name is Jesus and in His hands are the true wieghts and balances of money,land,and prestige owed to us. He will bring justice when He returns for His people.
33370229Wednesday, Dec 9 at 11:46 AM tabwae wrote ...
check is spelled CHEQUES!
33368492Wednesday, Dec 9 at 11:41 AM Digoweli wrote ...
This sounds like a replay of the old Dawes allotment solution. America is capitalist. To offer the documented heirs of an atrocity such a paltry payment is in line with the Colorado award of 1$ to Ward Churchill for "winning" the suit. If America truly wanted to settle the problem honorably America would pay enough for a genuine” capital nest egg” to those documented individuals who held out for so long and fought the fight so that they could start their business and feed their children.
33368101Wednesday, Dec 9 at 11:09 AM NRproducer wrote ...
The malfeasance of the trust fund is a crime - IT IS A CRIMINAL ACT - yet no one will be punished. I'm angered that my grandmothers and grandfathers were lied to and manipulated by the very government that said they would look out for them. Trust fund indeed! More like LIARS fund.
33365591Wednesday, Dec 9 at 4:55 AM Insulted wrote ...
Problem: The US government cannot handle their OWN money, witness the national debt, and Natives are expected to TRUST them to handle their money for them? OUTRAGEOUS!!! This is racist that they think Natives are inherently incapable of handling their own financial affairs. The US have proven it is incapable BUT will continue to (mis)manage the funds? My common sense tells me this is WRONG!!! And the guilty parties walk away free men? OUTRAGEOUS!! They just made another enemy for the US Gov'
33353511Wednesday, Dec 9 at 1:36 AM cesar elliott wrote ...
super !!!!!!finally some justice ,give back some power and RESPECT, to native american indians,the owners of Unites States of America PLEASE!!!!
33349259Wednesday, Dec 9 at 12:02 AM Wanbli wrote ...
Sense the U.S currency in the next few years or sooner will be completely worthless, that’s why US is going to the New World Order Euro, maybe we should tell these IRA leaders to give all of it to our red nationalist youth; the “Seventh Generation” in "gold" for their future.
33345764Tuesday, Dec 8 at 11:45 PM Wanbli wrote ...
When IRA withholds this money from the people they are willing thieving co-conspirators of empire, money that can be used to bring unity and understanding and healing, money that would free our red people and nations from the western ideological sin’s, guilt, shame and greed of empire. Its time for all our Red Nation’s to get this US monkey of paternal dependence and denial off our backs and collective consciousness.
33345102Tuesday, Dec 8 at 11:35 PM Wanbli wrote ...
Every “Just” red cent should go into the accounts of red people for red nationalist reforms; that will bring about authentic competent and accountable traditional governments that are truly self-determine and free sovereigns and loving.
33344632Tuesday, Dec 8 at 11:34 PM Wanbli wrote ...
A mere thousand dollars for each member, this is a national spit in the face of the Creator, the Son and the poor among our people and all living things. The IRA Tribal Governments shouldn't get one cent of this money to maintain the oppressive and repressive systematic Imperial structure of BIA and IRA that is killing our people, cultures and “Way of Life”. What kind of wisdom is this?
33344566Tuesday, Dec 8 at 9:53 PM The $7 Billion Offer That Never Was wrote ...
From Aug 2008: Elouise Cobell has complained that some news accounts have incorrectly stated that the plaintiffs once rejected a $7 billion offer from the government to settle the Indian Trust lawsuit. "That simply isn't true," she said in a statement sent to news media and posted at her Indian Trust Web site. Her statement singled out The Associated Press for spreading the misinformation. http://www.reznetnews.org/article/7-billion-offer-never-was-17850
33339141Tuesday, Dec 8 at 9:04 PM Rocky Mountains wrote ...
Thanks Ms. Cobell, you deserve cudos for your dedication to righting these egregious wrongs but those lawyers who are lined up behind you get the first cut which will be the lion's share of the settlement so Indians had better not celebrate too quickly for they'll get to pick up the crumbs.
33336619Tuesday, Dec 8 at 8:55 PM HMM wrote ...
I didn't know this was less than what the Bush Administration offered...if that's the case, please don't let Obama get away with this and get credit for it...that would be an insult!!
33336204Tuesday, Dec 8 at 8:42 PM HMM wrote ...
This is a step in the right direction but someone has got to demand more out of Obama... 1.4 billion is a loooong way away from 47 billion!!
33335484Tuesday, Dec 8 at 8:29 PM ojibwelw wrote ...
Black African: Obama did just that at the Tribal Leaders Summit on Nov. 5. BTW, Thanksgiving is not a holiday most NDNs would celebrate as others do... Again, it was NOT Cobell who refused the McCain offer, it was the Bush White House who pulled the rug out from under that offer. Look it up.
33334807Tuesday, Dec 8 at 8:14 PM afropick1 wrote ...
As a Black African american i warn you not to trust Obama...as Rev Wright was his pastor over 20 years who obama threw under the bus to please the neo-cons and has not invited him to the white house for a beer as he did the boston cop who unjustly arrested his friend and harvard professor Henry L Gates AND when will INDIANS receive a thanksgiving invite to the Obama white house to talk turkey?
33334102Tuesday, Dec 8 at 7:59 PM Anonymous wrote ...
No one's complaining about the settlement-just the Obama-love out there. The press makes it seem like this big deal that he settled the case for this much money. All everyone is saying is that the Bush Administration (which includes McCain as the Head of the Senate Committee) offered to settle it for more $$ 2 years ago. No one was happy when they offered $7 billion, but when Obama offers $1.4 everyone is screaming for joy!
33333284Tuesday, Dec 8 at 7:36 PM Jessie wrote ...
If anyone complains about the settlement, they should have filed it themselves. Ms. Cobell deserves the respect, at least it's still in the billions. Like someone mentioned, it's for our ancestors who came before us and now it will benefit the generations after us. Without Obama, it would have never gotten settled, but it did, in his first year, he's on our side.
33332094Tuesday, Dec 8 at 6:19 PM ojibwelw wrote ...
"where's my Check"?? Go register at: http://www.cobellsettlement.com/class/index.php#rights BTW- it wasn't Bush who made the settlement offer it was McCain who suggested it as head of the Senate NDN affairs committee then. The Bush admin. reigned him in PRONTO!! said no way.
33327659Tuesday, Dec 8 at 6:05 PM Canadian NDN wrote ...
Where's my check?
33326739Tuesday, Dec 8 at 6:03 PM Anonymous wrote ...
http://64.38.12.138/News/2008/006930.asp Here's the link to the article referencing the Bush Administration's $7 billion settlement offer, for those of you out there who think its nonsense.
33326591Tuesday, Dec 8 at 5:43 PM Quixote wrote ...
AND, even though this is LESS than what the Bush Administration would have settled for, it STILL has to go through Congress. Don't spend any of that settlement money before you actually get it..... This is a mere pittance. MAYBE the plaintiffs will see those $1000 (!!!) checks....but I bet it will be years, if not decades, before they see any more money, if they ever do.
33325264Tuesday, Dec 8 at 5:34 PM x wrote ...
forget the $$ people. as natives, be thankful that we are still alive. the u.s. gov't nor it's citizens wanted "indians" to survive the 19th century let alone be fully functional outstanding and remarkable individuals in the 21st century. aho! Lots of blood, culture, language, pride and identities were lost and given-up so that you can still be breathing and walking on makawitha (earth island) today. The $, resevations, blood quantums: all methods to divide and conquer. waste~
33324734Tuesday, Dec 8 at 5:01 PM native wrote ...
Obama's proud that he's settled the IIM worth over $200 billion dollars to down mere peanuts, while his best pride will be the fact that the majority of these monies will end up in the non-native private sector where they feel "it belongs." They have nothing to apologize for. Nevertheless, Indian country still and always will greatly respect Elouise Cobell. And the trust reform should not stop at this point, that we are all in agreement with!!
33322179Tuesday, Dec 8 at 4:38 PM Many Bands wrote ...
Let us now fight for the right of our children who are eligible for membership in more than one tribe, but who must pick and choose what tribe to enroll. They usually do not inherit land interests from both native parents. Natives should be recognized and receive credit for having Native blood, and not being 1/27 and being equal with a full-blood. This practice is equal to native fractionalization and is discriminatory.
33320664Tuesday, Dec 8 at 4:29 PM HonorIndians wrote ...
Yes, Ms. Cobell deserves praise and thanks for taking this issue on and fighting for all these years. However, the plaintiffs played a round of "Deal or No Deal" and lost, leaving billions on the table. Also, please don't tell me that Obama is "listening to us". ACORN, Unions and Wall Street executives will get more money than the Cobell plaintiffs. I don't want to hear how Obama is good for "listening" and settling for 3.4 billion and Bush is bad when he offered 7 billion.
33320069Tuesday, Dec 8 at 4:28 PM Daniel wrote ...
No, the Bush Administration did not offer approximately 6 billion dollars to settle. That is just nonsense.
33319964Tuesday, Dec 8 at 4:20 PM Rezbilly wrote ...
In 2005, the National Congress of American Indianz, the Intertribal Trust Monitoring Association, and Eloise Cobell presented Congress with a $27.6 billion settlement proposal.
33319467Tuesday, Dec 8 at 3:38 PM Nimiipuu wrote ...
Thank you Eloise Cobell for having the back bone to stand up to the Bureau and holding them accountable. We did not get what was entitled to us, but it was never for me, it was for our ancestors. They were the ones ripped off. Thanks again, you are in my prayers.
33316211Tuesday, Dec 8 at 3:24 PM Always Indigenous wrote ...
Thank you Elouise for fighting. 1.4 Billion is nothing compared to what the US has ripped off Indian people. We have to agree to settle for peanuts essentially is what they want. Im tired of taking peanuts and would rather die without and let those in charge settle with the maker themselves. Obama needs to have more integrity when dealing with our people. Im sorry he thinks corporate america is worth more support than Native people, not to mention all other people living in our country.
33315169Tuesday, Dec 8 at 2:37 PM HonorIndians wrote ...
I stand corrected; the Bush offer was $7 BILLION dollars. As reported on Indianz.com on February 8, 2008: "Interior Secretary Dirk Kempthorne reiterated the Bush administration $7 billion offer to settle the Indian trust when asked about the Cobell case on Thursday. Half of the money would be used to end the Cobell case and pay for future damages claims arising from the Individual Indian Money (IIM) trust. The other half would be used to settle more than 200 tribal trust claims."
33312141Tuesday, Dec 8 at 1:59 PM to commenter wrote ...
No, the Bush admin never offered 6 billion!
33309274Tuesday, Dec 8 at 1:58 PM Crow Warrior wrote ...
Present a counter Offer for the amount Bush offered! At least!
33309159Tuesday, Dec 8 at 1:44 PM Anonymous wrote ...
Independent experts have agreed that a settlement should be in the billions, with figures ranging from $6 billion to $10 billion. A bill that was introduced last year would have provided $8 billion to end the case. The Bush administration, on the other hand, believes account holders are owed in the low millions. A counterproposal to the settlement bill would have provided up to $3.5 billion to end the Cobell case and extinguish any future damages claims.
33308084Tuesday, Dec 8 at 1:43 PM Anonymous wrote ...
Independent experts have agreed that a settlement should be in the billions, with figures ranging from $6 billion to $10 billion. A bill that was introduced last year would have provided $8 billion to end the case. The Bush administration, on the other hand, believes account holders are owed in the low millions. A counterproposal to the settlement bill would have provided up to $3.5 billion to end the Cobell case and extinguish any future damages claims. http://64.38.12.138/News/2007/004845.asp
33308021Tuesday, Dec 8 at 1:40 PM Women Warrior Society wrote ...
Elouise, thank you for fighting the battle. It took much longer than expected but your shear determination brings benefits to many people young and old.
33307786Tuesday, Dec 8 at 1:19 PM HonorIndians wrote ...
Someone will have to remind me, but didn't the Bush administration offer approximately 6 billion to settle the lawsuit a couple of years ago? Now Obama offers approximately 3.5 billion, and “Today we have an administration that is listening to us”. What are we saying today that we weren't saying 2 years ago? "Please give us less than what the previous guy offered, and we will be happy and like you better!"
33306261Add a comment
Most Popular