Coulter: Obama: Make a fresh commitment to indigenous peoples
By
Robert T. Coulter
|
| As a starting point for improving the situation of Native nations, this country needs to affirm the fundamental rights of Native nations and individuals. |
The White House should make that commitment and reverse the Bush policy of rejecting all measures for indigenous human rights. Native leaders deserve an answer Nov. 5 – a real commitment to respect the human rights of Native nations – and the best way to do this is to endorse the UN Declaration. Leaders of many Indian nations in the United States have demanded this for years, and they will surely demand it Nov. 5 as well.
Despite the pretended reasons for voting against the Declaration, the U.S. representatives at the UN publically agreed to practically all of the provisions of the UN Declaration. In the open negotiations, the U.S. delegation repeatedly voiced its support for most of the rights in the Declaration, because almost all these rights are already a part of United States law or are required by the U.S. Constitution.
Some of the provisions concerning land rights were actually proposed by the United States. The U.S. vote against the Declaration was dictated by the Bush policy of rejecting all new human rights commitments, not because of serious opposition to the provisions of the Declaration. The U.S. objections were hardly more than a cover story for voting “no” on human rights. The Obama administration should promptly reverse that stupid policy.
For many generations, the federal government has kept Native nations begging yearly for support to meet the crying human needs on reservations – while never making a formal commitment to respect the most basic rights to fairness, equality before the law, respect for treaty commitments, and self-determination.
| I hope Obama will take this opportunity to reverse the senseless Bush policy and truly embrace the UN Declaration and the developing American Declaration. |
Native leaders have little choice but to lobby constantly for programs and appropriations that can provide jobs and other relief for desperate human needs in Indian communities. Leaders are also forced to seek “fixes” for seemingly endless new problems caused by federal wrong-doing related to their lands, their resources, their money and their self-government. But to end this sad cycle, Native leaders are also demanding – and they deserve – real respect for the fundamental rights that others enjoy, including the human rights contained in the UN Declaration.
I hope Obama will take this opportunity to reverse the senseless Bush policy and truly embrace the UN Declaration and the developing American Declaration.
And by the way, the OAS will have a negotiating session on the American Declaration in Washington, D.C. Nov. 30 – Dec. 2. I urge Indian and Alaska Native leaders to be there and participate in the negotiations. The Obama administration needs to be there too with a fresh and positive commitment to human rights for indigenous peoples.
Robert T. Coulter is executive director of Indian Law Resource Center.
Classifieds
On Demand
-
Digital Copy
Receive Indian Country Today in digital format Read more »
-
ICT Insider
Sign up to receive ICT Insider E-Newsletters Read more »
-
ICT audio
Listen to audio programs from ICT Read more »
-
Video
Watch ICT videos right in your browser Read more »
-
RSS Feeds
Stay up-to-date with ICT Read more »
-
Mobile
ICT on your cell phone or PDA Read more »
You have indicated this comment should be removed.
The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .
Art Fisher said on Saturday, Nov 7 at 4:44 PM
Obama = FAIL on Nov 5th. The happy rhetoric on nation-to-nation partnership continues. Where's the real prospect of federal-tribal partnership when the Federal element refuses to formally acknowledge fundamental tribal human rights, as nearly all of the world's countries readily did. Lets see an indication of genuine commitment in the form of joinder in the U.N. Declaration and getting behind the OAS Document BEFORE Adoption.
31756521Anonymous said on Saturday, Nov 7 at 4:43 PM
Obama = FAIL on Nov 5th. The happy rhetoric on nation-to-nation partnership continues. Where's the real prospect of federal-tribal partnership when the Federal element refuses to formally acknowledge fundamental tribal human rights, as nearly all of the world's countries readily did. Lets see an indication of genuine commitment in the form of joinder in the U.N. Declaration and getting behind the OAS Document BEFORE Adoption.
31756494Wise One said on Friday, Oct 23 at 1:40 AM
Indigenous is a general term which combines many different cultures into one "Big Melting Pot", which like America, totally destroys our individual tribal uniqueness and identity. Who comprises these Indigenous identities when you consider the multitudes around the world? The UN has to make general policy definitions for these Indigenous people for human problem resolution. Similar to the American melting pot, we must resisted this and the traditions of individual Native groups must remain.
30989803Keep it REAL said on Thursday, Oct 22 at 6:01 PM
To Phillip Edward: If you are interested in the real meaning of the word "arbitrary", then I would suggest reading Chief Justice John Marshall's statement in Johnson v. M'Intosh ruling. Or simply read Newcomb’s book, "Pagans in the Promised Land: Decoding the Doctrine of Christian Discovery."
30974333Phillip Edward said on Thursday, Oct 22 at 10:59 AM
The problem with these indigenous nations resolutions is that there is no workable definition of who the indigenous people are, it is made up a an arbitrary vote of current nations, each of which is totally biased toward current events. When you partner with terrorists, as this resolution does, then you will get not reasonable people to help
30951437Larry Hamana, Hopi-Tewa Civil Rights Advocate said on Wednesday, Oct 21 at 12:13 PM
The Hopi-Tewa People on our reservation in AZ pray that President Obama and his team help to reinstate our human and civil rights against an illegal Hopi tribal council's atrocities and civil rights violations imposed on us as an indigenous people. This would be a real test case for Obama to investigate and overturn for the benefit of my people.
30900992Gerad Kipp said on Wednesday, Oct 21 at 9:21 AM
I hope the UN Declaration has a component on the Supreme Court Rulings that effect all tribes with one blow, when each and every tribe has different policies set in place. Such as Treaty Tribes, non-Treaty Tribes, Executive Order Tribes, IRA tribes, Non-IRA Tribes, PL280 tribes, partial PL280 Tribes, Corparations, Rancereas, and the combinations of all thes different policies that govern the tribes as a single soverign unit.
30888977Add a comment
Most Popular